Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2523532034> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 82 of
82
with 100 items per page.
- W2523532034 abstract "Although preemption cases require courts to apply a broad range of statutory regimes, the underlying question in each is the same: Does federal law oust state law? Thus, it is reasonable to expect that the analytic framework courts use in these cases should be consistent. In all preemption cases the analysis requires four steps: the court must construe a federal law, construe a state law, determine whether any overlap or tension between the two laws may be tolerated, and identify the basis for Congress’s authority to displace state law. The Supreme Court has been fractured over the basic rules for performing each of these steps. The law in this area is indeed a “muddle.” Counter to the long-held view of the Court as the arbiter of conflicts between federal and state regulatory authority, this Article argues that as long as no stable majority of the Justices has established a position on the basic analytic framework, the Court should exercise its certiorari discretion not to review most preemption cases. Even if the Supreme Court were to do so, lower courts would remain in a bind. These courts lack the discretionary authority to refuse to hear preemption cases yet are tasked with implementing the muddle of contemporary preemption doctrine. One way in which lower courts might avoid this bind is by applying a variety of techniques that Alexander Bickel and other have referred to as “passive virtues.” This Article finds in the on- and off-bench writings by Judge Merrick Garland an illustration of how a judge with an aversion to preemption decisions that broadly and unpredictably displace state law might apply some of these techniques in order to avoid preemption decisions. The Article concludes by examining two questions. First, does the use by appellate judges of standing and other doctrines to avoid the far-reaching and unpredictable results of deciding preemption questions risk distorting the former out of proportion to the benefits of the latter? And second, is an approach premised on avoiding preemption cases a desirable one for the Supreme Court over the long term? Using Judge Garland’s judicial output as a case study, this Article suggests that while there are risks, avoidance may be preferable to the application of the current, muddled doctrine of preemption." @default.
- W2523532034 created "2016-09-30" @default.
- W2523532034 creator A5065905146 @default.
- W2523532034 date "2016-01-01" @default.
- W2523532034 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2523532034 title "Avoiding the Preemption Muddle: Reading Professor Bickel and Judge Garland" @default.
- W2523532034 doi "https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2838945" @default.
- W2523532034 hasPublicationYear "2016" @default.
- W2523532034 type Work @default.
- W2523532034 sameAs 2523532034 @default.
- W2523532034 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2523532034 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2523532034 hasAuthorship W2523532034A5065905146 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C11413529 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C158129432 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C170706310 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C17319257 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C206952183 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2776210200 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2776211767 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2777006572 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2777351106 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2777488897 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2777632292 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2778272461 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C2780598601 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C3020037990 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C46415393 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C48103436 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConcept C87501996 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C111919701 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C11413529 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C158129432 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C170706310 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C17319257 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C17744445 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C199539241 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C206952183 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2776210200 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2776211767 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2777006572 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2777351106 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2777488897 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2777632292 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2778272461 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C2780598601 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C3020037990 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C41008148 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C46415393 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C48103436 @default.
- W2523532034 hasConceptScore W2523532034C87501996 @default.
- W2523532034 hasLocation W25235320341 @default.
- W2523532034 hasOpenAccess W2523532034 @default.
- W2523532034 hasPrimaryLocation W25235320341 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W1590684528 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W1591507830 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W2074151737 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W2229120737 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W2259503676 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W230631776 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W2338896905 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W252952362 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W289487225 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W2907845963 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W2942393106 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W2947252479 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3086758006 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3121492764 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3121775757 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3121913738 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3123747267 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3125044240 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3148078688 @default.
- W2523532034 hasRelatedWork W3122526670 @default.
- W2523532034 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2523532034 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W2523532034 magId "2523532034" @default.
- W2523532034 workType "article" @default.