FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2524885770> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2524885770 endingPage "592" @default.
• W2524885770 startingPage "563" @default.
• W2524885770 abstract "The Thomist 74 (2010): 563-92 METHOD, ORDER, AND ANALOGY IN TRINITARIAN THEOLOGY: KARL RAHNER'S CRITIQUE OF THE PSYCHOLOGICAL APPROACH JEREMY D. WILKINS University ofSt. Thomas Houston, Texas IT IS STILL widely taken for granted in contemporary Trinitarian theology that there exist two fundamentally divergent traditions aptly characterized as Greek and Latin, despite a decade of withering criticism. IfAugustine is the villain of this story as the originator of Latin essentialism, Thomas Aquinas is generally considered to have perfected the type in his Summa Theologiae. Because a judgment of value is almost invariably implied when these assertions are made, recent decades have seen numerous efforts to defend Thomas and Augustine. This typology has its origins in the monumental work of the Jesuit historian of doctrine Theodore de Regnon, Etudes de thiologie positive sur la sainte Trinite. 1 De Regnon discerned a turning point connected with the Arian, Sabellian, and Macedonian crises, when, in order to safeguard the revealed mystery, the Fathers formulated the Trinitarian dogma in terms of person and nature.2 He systematized this insight into an analytic scheme for understanding the historical development of Trinitarian theology. Since the dogma of the Trinity affirms three who are distinct as persons but identical in nature, the concepts of 'nature' and 'person' provide two ways into a synthetic account of 1 4 vols. (Paris: Victor Retamc, 1892-98). 2 See ibid., 1:117- 244, esp. 117-28 where he sets up the problem. 563 564 JEREMY D. WILKINS the mystery, variously realized as the concepts are variously ordered.3 Latin philosophy first contemplates the nature in itself, and proceeds to the supposit; Greek philosophy first contemplates the supposit, and then penetrates it to find therein the nature. The Latin sees personality as a mode of nature; the Greek sees nature as the content of the person. There are here two opposed designs, which project conceptions of the same reality onto different backdrops.4 According to de Regnon, on the Latin starting point, one conceives la nature in recto et la personne in obliquo. On the Greek starting point, conversely, one conceives la personne in recto et la nature in obliquo.5 Now since in recto and in obliquo refer to conceptual orderings, the adequacy of the typology clearly depends on the actual execution of any given author. In other words, it may have its uses as an ideal type, but it is not itself a description of anyone's actual theology. The expectation fostered by this scheme is that Thomas Aquinas will be typical of the Latin pattern. In fact de Regnon does not hesitate to say that Latin Scholasticism in general exhibits this pattern,6 and he specifically applies it to Thomas: At the starting point of St. Thomas's Trinitarian theory, we meet a God who is single, subsistent, possessing a spiritual nature, a God who is perfect and presents all the characteristics of a 'personal' God, of a Person-God.7 Effectively, he thinks, this means God the Father, which he tentatively approves as fitting the ancient pattern, for during the first centuries of the Church's life, the 3 Ibid., 1:250-51. 4 La philosophie latine envisage d'abord la nature en elle-meme et poursuit jusqu'au supp6t; la philosophie grecque envisage d'abord le supp6t et y penetre ensuite pour y trouver la nature. Le Latin considere la personalite comme un mode de la nature, le Gree considere la nature comme le contenu de la personne. Ce sont la des visees contraires, qui projettent Jes concepts de la meme realite sur des fonds differents (ibid., 1:433-34). Here and throughout, translations are my own unless otherwise indicated. 5 Ibid., 1:251-52. 6 Ibid., 1:252. 7 Au point de depart de la thforie trinitaire de saint Thomas, on rencontre un Dieu unique, subsistant, possedant une nature spirituelle, Dieu parfait et presentant tous !es caracteres d'un Dieu 'personnel', d'une Personne-Dieu (ibid., 2:212). METHOD, ORDER, AND ANALOGY IN TRINITARIAN THEOLOGY 565 name 'God', unmodified, preeminently meant God the Father, source of divinity.8 De Regnon did not consider his typology evaluative in itself. For him, the two patterns are..." @default.
• W2524885770 created "2016-10-07" @default.
• W2524885770 creator A5007758465 @default.
• W2524885770 date "2010-01-01" @default.
• W2524885770 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
• W2524885770 title "Method, Order, and Analogy in Trinitarian Theology: Karl Rahner’s Critique of the “Psychological” Approach" @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1481915955 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1510870401 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1521908775 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1529705508 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1547717353 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1551023056 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1583960662 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1993734204 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W1995967396 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2010380580 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2015512116 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2022939080 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2033178198 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2116871330 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2314968903 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2321848365 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2510380311 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2529168701 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W2798663458 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W3032968785 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W3135571053 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W360460789 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W580347610 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W659561286 @default.
• W2524885770 cites W785455950 @default.
• W2524885770 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/tho.2010.0034" @default.
• W2524885770 hasPublicationYear "2010" @default.
• W2524885770 type Work @default.
• W2524885770 sameAs 2524885770 @default.
• W2524885770 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2524885770 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2524885770 hasAuthorship W2524885770A5007758465 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C10138342 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C153683151 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C182306322 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C182744844 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C19165224 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C2776211767 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C2779416288 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C521332185 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C75795011 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConcept C7991579 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C10138342 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C111472728 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C124952713 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C138885662 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C142362112 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C144024400 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C153683151 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C162324750 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C182306322 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C182744844 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C19165224 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C27206212 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C2776211767 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C2779416288 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C521332185 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C75795011 @default.
• W2524885770 hasConceptScore W2524885770C7991579 @default.
• W2524885770 hasIssue "4" @default.
• W2524885770 hasLocation W25248857701 @default.
• W2524885770 hasOpenAccess W2524885770 @default.
• W2524885770 hasPrimaryLocation W25248857701 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W1546594678 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W1984206002 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W2071103446 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W2153055888 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W2346914283 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W2888275535 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W2890689331 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W3136399693 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W3213347517 @default.
• W2524885770 hasRelatedWork W647325308 @default.
• W2524885770 hasVolume "74" @default.
• W2524885770 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2524885770 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2524885770 magId "2524885770" @default.
• W2524885770 workType "article" @default.