Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2571736130> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2571736130 endingPage "25" @default.
- W2571736130 startingPage "15" @default.
- W2571736130 abstract "Reflection in medical diagnosis has been said to prevent errors by minimizing flaws in clinical reasoning. This claim, however, has been much disputed. While some studies show reflective reasoning to improve diagnostic performance, others find it to add nothing. This paper presents a narrative review of the literature on reflection in medical diagnosis aimed at addressing two questions: (1) how reflective reasoning has been conceived in this literature; and (2) what is the effect of different forms of reflective reasoning on diagnostic performance. We searched PubMed and Web of Science for papers published until June 2016 and identified additional literature through the list of references from the initial publications. By building upon dual-processing theories of reasoning, we classified the empirical studies according to two dimensions: (1) the phase of the diagnostic process in which reflection was applied, and (2) the type of reasoning instructions provided to participants. We identified 46 papers for full review, 31 of them reporting on empirical studies. Different conceptualizations of reflective reasoning exist in the literature. In 16 studies, reflective reasoning was triggered to verify previously generated diagnosis, usually (13/16 studies) by following specific reasoning instructions. Participants were requested to reflect for generating diagnostic hypothesis in 4 studies, all using specific instructions. In 8 studies, 2 of them employing specific instructions, reflection was assumed as taking place throughout the diagnostic process. Reflective reasoning positively affected diagnostic performance when conceived as a process of examining the grounds of initial diagnoses generated through intuitive judgment. The benefits of reflection were particularly substantial when physicians were provided with specific reasoning instructions that led them to be confronted with evidence from the case. Studies using other forms of reflection led to contradictory findings. Reflective reasoning can be a powerful tool to reduce diagnostic errors and increase diagnostic performance. For this to happen, reflection should be triggered for diagnosis verification and needs to interfere with initial diagnostic reasoning, which requires confrontation with evidence from the case." @default.
- W2571736130 created "2017-01-26" @default.
- W2571736130 creator A5033869597 @default.
- W2571736130 creator A5076215124 @default.
- W2571736130 date "2017-06-01" @default.
- W2571736130 modified "2023-10-06" @default.
- W2571736130 title "Reflection in Medical Diagnosis: A Literature Review" @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1811976956 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1836271141 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1854828342 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1936663290 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1970566767 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1973049686 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1974039834 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1974476540 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1975402326 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1976457864 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W1990245305 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2007560473 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2010036053 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2015769833 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2020907317 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2022112401 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2033266691 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2041680858 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2046626105 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2049750004 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2060572591 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2065667673 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2071210685 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2077711231 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2079353128 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2084265121 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2104095965 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2104889028 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2105105661 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2111138348 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2123308482 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2123997273 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2124461995 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2132131059 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2133604283 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2135415725 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2137610930 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2137619433 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2141874256 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2147195860 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2147558794 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2147782722 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2154651644 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2155479778 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2162360374 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2162731286 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2186125383 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2299184201 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2321464116 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W2323745045 @default.
- W2571736130 cites W3027703487 @default.
- W2571736130 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hpe.2017.01.003" @default.
- W2571736130 hasPublicationYear "2017" @default.
- W2571736130 type Work @default.
- W2571736130 sameAs 2571736130 @default.
- W2571736130 citedByCount "49" @default.
- W2571736130 countsByYear W25717361302017 @default.
- W2571736130 countsByYear W25717361302018 @default.
- W2571736130 countsByYear W25717361302019 @default.
- W2571736130 countsByYear W25717361302020 @default.
- W2571736130 countsByYear W25717361302021 @default.
- W2571736130 countsByYear W25717361302022 @default.
- W2571736130 countsByYear W25717361302023 @default.
- W2571736130 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2571736130 hasAuthorship W2571736130A5033869597 @default.
- W2571736130 hasAuthorship W2571736130A5076215124 @default.
- W2571736130 hasBestOaLocation W25717361301 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C103057564 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C120936955 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C126838900 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C199033989 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C20162079 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C3020000205 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C534262118 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C542102704 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C65682993 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConcept C98045186 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConceptScore W2571736130C103057564 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConceptScore W2571736130C111472728 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConceptScore W2571736130C111919701 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConceptScore W2571736130C120936955 @default.
- W2571736130 hasConceptScore W2571736130C126838900 @default.