FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2580552489> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2580552489 endingPage "182" @default.
• W2580552489 startingPage "163" @default.
• W2580552489 abstract "Pity, Gratitude, and the Poor in Rousseau and Adam Smith Adam Potkay (bio) Pity and gratitude are moral emotions—or “moral sentiments,” as Adam Smith calls them—because they respond to perceived goods or ills. Pity recognizes that an undeserved ill has befallen another, or simply that another is in pain. Conversely, the sentiment of gratitude affirms as good something given to us, as well as the agent who grants it. These two emotions are often conjoined in eighteenth-century narratives: I take pity on someone, often someone who is acutely or chronically poor; I seek to alleviate his suffering or privation through word or alms; my feelings or actions are met with a feeling and/or expression of gratitude. Take, for example, the following episode from Henry Mackenzie’s sentimental novel, The Man of Feeling (1771), in which the protagonist Harley takes pity on an impoverished prostitute who faints from hunger in his presence: “I am sorry, sir,” said she, “that I should have given you so much trouble; but you will pity me when I tell you that till now I have not tasted a morsel these two days past.”—He fixed his eyes on hers—every circumstance but the last was forgotten; and he took her hand with as much respect as if she had been a duchess. It was ever the privilege of misfortune to be revered by him. … He had one half-guinea left. “I am sorry,” he said, “that at present I [End Page 163] should be able to make you an offer of no more than this paltry sum.”—She burst into tears: “Your generosity, sir, is abused; to bestow it on me is to take it from the virtuous …” “No more of that,” answered Harley; “there is virtue in these tears; let the fruit of them be virtue.”—He rung, and ordered a chair.—“Though I am the vilest of beings,” said she, “I have not forgotten every virtue; gratitude, I hope, I shall still have left, did I but know who is my benefactor.”—“My name is Harley.”1 In this exchange, pity or compassion motivates Harley to treat a socially degraded woman with respect, indeed reverence; in his eyes, suffering ennobles her. She responds with a verbal sophistication indicative of the relative gentility from which she has fallen, and she responds with gratitude for the relief he offers. The sentimental narrative of well-placed pity met with virtuous gratitude is not so simple for Rousseau or for his Scottish interlocutor, Adam Smith. Yet the complexity of their attitudes towards pity, gratitude, and the poor has not been fully appreciated. Each author seems, at first glance, more sentimental than he is. Rousseau presents pity as the ur-virtue in his highly influential Discourse on the Origin and the Foundations of Inequality among Men (1755), and Smith in turn appears to endorse it at the outset of The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759, 6th ed. 1790). Smith’s apparent endorsement of pity leads one critic to link Smith’s work to Mackenzie’s: “Smith’s first paragraph … urges (what Mackenzie’s novel dramatizes) the moral import of one man’s ‘pity or compassion’ for another man, and allies it with the dynamics of sympathetic reading: ‘By the imagination, we place ourselves in his situation, we conceive ourselves enduring the same torments, we enter as it were into his body and become in some measure him …’”2 Upon closer inspection, however, neither Smith nor Rousseau treats pity—or gratitude—as an unqualified ethical or political good. Both teach us, rather, to be suspicious of the type of scenario illustrated in Mackenzie’s novel, and in similar examples throughout eighteenth-century British and French sentimental literature.3 For Rousseau, pity is as apt to avoid suffering as to alleviate it, and in his ideal, relatively egalitarian society, pitiable poverty would be eliminated. For Smith, pity is not only generally inefficacious, but potentially unjust—indeed, we’re most apt to pity those, including criminals and the majority of the poor, who do not (Smith argues) deserve pity or relief. Conversely, for Smith as for Rousseau, not all benefactors deserve gratitude. Gratitude is rightly bestowed..." @default.
• W2580552489 created "2017-02-03" @default.
• W2580552489 creator A5082019583 @default.
• W2580552489 date "2017-01-01" @default.
• W2580552489 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
• W2580552489 title "Pity, Gratitude, and the Poor in Rousseau and Adam Smith" @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1516464276 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1521777280 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1531180141 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1532152952 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1550822870 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1555600579 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1590129028 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1591689214 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1600477667 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1930743862 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1981579522 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1983758723 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1991480423 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W1999846801 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2045973549 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2077789847 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2088946473 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2088997182 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2159927377 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2170157960 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W225247819 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2295402833 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2604395578 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2604429717 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2618111011 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W2619553621 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W3022690772 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W303020864 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W429900507 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W568863692 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W573024883 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W579623682 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W592938630 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W610759298 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W615783883 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W615800567 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W625373201 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W647542054 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W64820725 @default.
• W2580552489 cites W819276774 @default.
• W2580552489 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/sec.2017.0014" @default.
• W2580552489 hasPublicationYear "2017" @default.
• W2580552489 type Work @default.
• W2580552489 sameAs 2580552489 @default.
• W2580552489 citedByCount "2" @default.
• W2580552489 countsByYear W25805524892017 @default.
• W2580552489 countsByYear W25805524892021 @default.
• W2580552489 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2580552489 hasAuthorship W2580552489A5082019583 @default.
• W2580552489 hasBestOaLocation W25805524891 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C11171543 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C122980154 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C133425853 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C2777976675 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C2779930795 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C2780138299 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C2992293419 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C50764671 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C11171543 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C122980154 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C133425853 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C138885662 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C15744967 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C162324750 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C17744445 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C199539241 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C2777976675 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C2779930795 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C2780138299 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C2992293419 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C50764671 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C77805123 @default.
• W2580552489 hasConceptScore W2580552489C94625758 @default.
• W2580552489 hasIssue "1" @default.
• W2580552489 hasLocation W25805524891 @default.
• W2580552489 hasOpenAccess W2580552489 @default.
• W2580552489 hasPrimaryLocation W25805524891 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W1549193359 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W1981290751 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W1997241328 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W2060369560 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W2138469372 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W2361777558 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W2580552489 @default.
• W2580552489 hasRelatedWork W2605810168 @default.

• next