FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2580959850> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2580959850 endingPage "462" @default.
• W2580959850 startingPage "425" @default.
• W2580959850 abstract "“The Blessed in the Kingdom of Heaven Will See the Punishments of the Damned So That Their Bliss May Be More Delightful to Them”: Nietzsche and Aquinas James Lehrberger O.Cist. NO DECENT HUMAN BEING can read those words of St. Thomas Aquinas, which Frederick Nietzsche quotes in On the Genealogy of Morals1 (GM) without feeling horror, shock, and disgust: “‘The blessed in the kingdom of heaven,’ he [Aquinas] says meek as a lamb, ‘will see the [End Page 425] punishments of the damned so that their bliss might be more pleasing to them.’” Nietzsche scholars regularly notice and comment on this passage from the Summa theologiae.2 The typical gloss takes it to show the spirit of hatred that lies at the heart of Aquinas’s Christianity. Thus Walter Kaufmann reads the quotation as showing how the Christian faith enables its adherents “to indulge their lust for revenge by hoping for the eternal torture and destruction of their persecutors.”3 Weaver Santinello echoes this sentiment when she claims that “‘the great teacher and saint [Aquinas]’ had a ‘bloodthirsty vision of Hell.’”4 Even so sensitive a Christian as Merold Westphal reads Nietzsche’s Aquinas in this way. “[I]t is hard to deny that the spirit of resentment and longing for vengeance burns hot in these passages . . . in them the final judgment makes the Final Solution seem almost moderate.”5 Similar comments and observations so abound in the scholarship that they form a virtual consensus on this Summa passage’s teaching.6 This proliferation of such statements on Aquinas’s meaning, however, contrasts sharply with the absence of careful analyses [End Page 426] of the passage. I do not know, in fact, of a single article, book chapter, or study that takes Nietzsche’s quotation of Aquinas for its theme. More generally, despite the vast literature on Nietzsche and Christianity, comparative studies of Nietzsche and Aquinas are rare.7 The absence of substantive studies on the Genealogy’s use of the Aquinas quotation is doubly unfortunate. First, it silences or at least muffles the voice of Nietzsche. He cites Aquinas’s text in the specific context of Treatise I of the Genealogy. The quotation reveals the full meaning that Nietzsche intended it to convey only when it is read in that context. Second, it obscures and distorts the thought of Aquinas: the quotation must be read in its own context in the Summa theologiae to grasp the teaching that Aquinas intended his words to express. In light of Aquinas’s importance as a Christian theologian and the crucial role he plays in the Genealogy’s critique of moral values, I intend to examine Nietzsche’s presentation of this text. Careful study of this matter can shed light on a key question which has long been discussed and debated: Is Nietzsche’s account of Christianity as life-inimical rooted in an extraordinarily perceptive reading of the Christian psyche? Or is it based, rather, on a profound misunderstanding of that psyche? I will argue for two points: (1) that Nietzsche has utterly misconstrued Aquinas’s teaching; and (2) that Aquinas’s Christian morality, far from being life-inimical, is life-affirming. [End Page 427] More specifically, I will show not only that Aquinas is completely free from the hatred, envy, and vengefulness that Nietzsche attributes to him, but also that the virtues and beliefs he embraces, such as meekness, mercy, and divine justice, are strong and supportive of human flourishing. I will proceed in the following steps. First, I will investigate Nietzsche’s understanding of the Aquinas quotation in terms of the role it plays in the Genealogy’s First Treatise. As already noted, recognizing Nietzsche’s purpose in quoting Aquinas requires understanding the objections he develops to Christianity throughout that Treatise. Hence I will highlight the principal criticisms of Aquinas’s Christianity found there. Second, I will analyze the quotation from Aquinas in its own context in the Summa theologiae. Lastly, I will compare and contrast Nietzsche and Aquinas in terms of those issues which the quoted passage has brought to the fore. Nietzsche’s take on Aquinas, however, is the only question I will address. I do not..." @default.
• W2580959850 created "2017-02-03" @default.
• W2580959850 creator A5027099923 @default.
• W2580959850 date "2016-01-01" @default.
• W2580959850 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
• W2580959850 title "“The Blessed in the Kingdom of Heaven Will See the Punishments of the Damned So That Their Bliss May Be More Delightful to Them”: Nietzsche and Aquinas" @default.
• W2580959850 cites W1519696280 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W1544106073 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W1593236244 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W180918106 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2014055848 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2027330695 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2079463445 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2150192409 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2312559061 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2324984004 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2325977652 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2328431635 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2460520098 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2497937821 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W2498044613 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W289213181 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W586793072 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W603030931 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W628823205 @default.
• W2580959850 cites W647759268 @default.
• W2580959850 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/tho.2016.0028" @default.
• W2580959850 hasPublicationYear "2016" @default.
• W2580959850 type Work @default.
• W2580959850 sameAs 2580959850 @default.
• W2580959850 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2580959850 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2580959850 hasAuthorship W2580959850A5027099923 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C2776727279 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C2778692574 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C2780658912 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C50764671 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C124952713 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C138885662 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C142362112 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C17744445 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C199360897 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C199539241 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C27206212 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C2776727279 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C2778692574 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C2780658912 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C41008148 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C50764671 @default.
• W2580959850 hasConceptScore W2580959850C94625758 @default.
• W2580959850 hasIssue "3" @default.
• W2580959850 hasLocation W25809598501 @default.
• W2580959850 hasOpenAccess W2580959850 @default.
• W2580959850 hasPrimaryLocation W25809598501 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W2328024538 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W2332049110 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W2335688104 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W2499960249 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W2580959850 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W3111666827 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W3146460977 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W877789731 @default.
• W2580959850 hasRelatedWork W935688917 @default.
• W2580959850 hasVolume "80" @default.
• W2580959850 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2580959850 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2580959850 magId "2580959850" @default.
• W2580959850 workType "article" @default.