Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2593009668> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2593009668 endingPage "198" @default.
- W2593009668 startingPage "182" @default.
- W2593009668 abstract "Accurate automated quantification of subcortical structures is a greatly pursued endeavour in neuroimaging. In an effort to establish the validity and reliability of these methods in defining the striatum, globus pallidus, and thalamus, we investigated differences in volumetry between manual delineation and automated segmentations derived by widely used FreeSurfer and FSL packages, and a more recent segmentation method, the MAGeT-Brain algorithm. In a first set of experiments, the basal ganglia and thalamus of thirty subjects (15 first episode psychosis [FEP], 15 controls) were manually defined and compared to the labels generated by the three automated methods. Our results suggest that all methods overestimate volumes compared to the manually derived gold standard, with the least pronounced differences produced using MAGeT. The least between-method variability was noted for the striatum, whereas marked differences between manual segmentation and MAGeT compared to FreeSurfer and FSL emerged for the globus pallidus and thalamus. Correlations between manual segmentation and automated methods were strongest for MAGeT (range: 0.51 to 0.92; p<0.01, corrected), whereas FreeSurfer and FSL showed moderate to strong Pearson correlations (range 0.44-0.86; p<0.05, corrected), with the exception of FreeSurfer pallidal (r=0.31, p=0.10) and FSL thalamic segmentations (r=0.37, p=0.051). Bland-Altman plots highlighted a tendency for greater volumetric differences between manual labels and automated methods at the lower end of the distribution (i.e. smaller structures), which was most prominent for bilateral thalamus across automated pipelines, and left globus pallidus for FSL. We then went on to examine volume and shape of the basal ganglia structures using automated techniques in 135 FEP patients and 88 controls. The striatum and globus pallidus were significantly larger in FEP patients compared to controls bilaterally, irrespective of the method used. MAGeT-Brain was more sensitive to shape-based group differences, and uncovered widespread surface expansions in the striatum and globus pallidus bilaterally in FEP patients compared to controls, and surface contractions in bilateral thalamus (FDR-corrected). By contrast, after using a recommended cluster-wise thresholding method, FSL only detected differences in the right ventral striatum (FEP>Control) and one cluster of the left thalamus (Control>FEP). These results suggest that different automated pipelines segment subcortical structures with varying degrees of variability compared to manual methods, with particularly pronounced differences found with FreeSurfer and FSL for the globus pallidus and thalamus." @default.
- W2593009668 created "2017-03-16" @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5016285763 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5018785094 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5029207426 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5036883041 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5042535330 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5042808030 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5045429640 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5045972911 @default.
- W2593009668 creator A5069060163 @default.
- W2593009668 date "2018-04-01" @default.
- W2593009668 modified "2023-10-15" @default.
- W2593009668 title "Evaluating accuracy of striatal, pallidal, and thalamic segmentation methods: Comparing automated approaches to manual delineation" @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1033578154 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1488525638 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1522580235 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1536611676 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1551871005 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1583887302 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1667869507 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W177664770 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1876943069 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1891773028 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1970804655 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1972027722 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1972817961 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1975548517 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1983208069 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1984842103 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1986130448 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1986452376 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1986499195 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1987565821 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1991456242 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W1998293256 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2002782093 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2004004650 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2004293194 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2004369235 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2015795623 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2018427609 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2020999234 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2023713957 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2030386677 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2032960445 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2038952578 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2041195767 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2041276929 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2063217743 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2066001427 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2068897382 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2069893715 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2070368610 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2071449464 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2072714066 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2073419297 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2075864361 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2076133825 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2076706295 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2077115170 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2077473514 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2079433870 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2082519017 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2084879730 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2089940272 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2097137621 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2108817119 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2109216757 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2111525009 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2116895317 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2117107597 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2118438010 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2122384242 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2123402141 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2126693856 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2127890285 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2129965408 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2135057305 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2135535334 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2138146369 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2143834603 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2145602532 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2145714441 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2148157540 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2154686256 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2156123885 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2156752476 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2159778181 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2166630181 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2171678469 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2172252744 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2276269666 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2292780717 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2308325336 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2316783339 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2389621256 @default.
- W2593009668 cites W2511501288 @default.