Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2596487679> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2596487679 endingPage "139" @default.
- W2596487679 startingPage "117" @default.
- W2596487679 abstract "Modernism’s Anti-Advice Beth Blum (bio) For a fortnight I was confined to my room, and I surrounded myself with the books of the day (sixteen or seventeen years ago); I mean those volumes which treat of the art of making people happy, wise, and rich, in twenty-four hours . . . I was in a state of mind bordering on intoxication or stupidity. —Charles Baudelaire, “Let us Flay the Poor” (1865)1 A reader of Suze Orman or Tony Robbins might well have written this passage, but it actually expresses the frustrations of the proto-modernist poet Charles Baudelaire in 1865. Baudelaire’s eulogy for self-help as “the books of the day (sixteen or seventeen years ago)” was somewhat premature. At the same time, his prose poem indicates that the parameters of the self-help industry are more capacious than most would think. Self-help’s origins extend much further back than Dale Carnegie’s American handbook, and, contrary to what Baudelaire optimistically implies, its influence has only escalated. Baudelaire’s fascination with “those volumes which treat of the art of making people happy, wise, and rich, in twenty-four hours” was hardly anomalous among his contemporaries. “On every bookstall, in every magazine, you may find works telling people how to succeed . . . they are written by men who cannot even succeed in writing books,” complained British essayist G. K. Chesterton in 1909.2 The annus mirabilis of modernism—1922—also marked the international tour of Emile Coué, the French pioneer of positive thinking, and the founding of guru George Gurdjieff’s Institute for the Harmonious Development of Man at Fontainebleau. Gurdjieff and Coué were causes célèbres of the day, boasting modernist disciples such as Jean Toomer, [End Page 117] Katherine Mansfield and Roger Fry, and detractors including John Dewey and Ezra Pound. References to Coué’s famous affirmation, “Every day, in every way, I am getting better and better,” made their way into novels by John Galsworthy (1924), Dorothy Sayers (1930), and Graham Greene (1945) (fig. 1).3 During modernism’s heyday, books by Lytton Strachey and H. G. Wells vied for space on the bestseller list beside Coué’s Self-Mastery Through Conscious Auto-Suggestion (1922), Josephine Jackson’s Outwitting Our Nerves (1921), and Lulu Hunt Peters’s Diet and Health (1918).4 Modernism has long been defined by its rejection of Victorian moral imperatives. However, the concomitant rise of the self-help industry uniquely illuminates the stakes and objectives of modernism’s own genre of anti-advice. Despite their significant oppositions, modernism and self-help developed as overlapping discursive communities, united by a shared investment in the problem of how to live. Though the modernist period witnessed the commercialization of counsel at an unprecedented pace, self-help has an ancient history. Some date it back to the ancient Egyptian genre of life-instruction called “Sebayt” (“teaching”), others to the spiritual insights of the Bhagavad Gita, the injunctions of the Hebrew Bible, or the aphorisms of the ancient Greeks.5 Every culture has its wisdom tradition, but the first glimmers of a textual industry in America premised on practical counsel can be traced to Protestant New England, where the Puritans’ anxiety over salvation created a market for guides to the devout life such as Cotton Mather’s Bonifacius: Essays to Do Good (1710), which provided instructions on how to assure God’s grace through diligence, thrift, and industriousness. Benjamin Franklin adapted the religious manuals of Mather and others to fit his more secular program of social mobility in works such as Poor Richard’s Almanac (1732–1757), which sociologist Max Weber has influentially argued inaugurated a shift from the Protestant to the capitalist work ethic, and which later found a narrative counterpart in Horatio Alger’s rags-to-riches morality tales.6 In Europe, a parallel tradition of practical advice had developed in the form of the conduct book, which began in Medieval courtesy literature, had its golden age in courtly Renaissance counsel, and remained popular well into the eighteenth century, when it shifted its focus from politics to etiquette and tackled subjects germane to the rise of the bourgeois middle class such as household management..." @default.
- W2596487679 created "2017-03-23" @default.
- W2596487679 creator A5063750582 @default.
- W2596487679 date "2017-01-01" @default.
- W2596487679 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2596487679 title "Modernism’s Anti-Advice" @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1486249793 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1486591394 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1495650319 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1496054820 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1497466718 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1498447483 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1503401484 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1510187598 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1516829637 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1518113247 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1524198487 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1529904331 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1533200881 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1536322189 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1538942742 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1547608556 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1548808044 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1552790187 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1553997310 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1554502515 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1562425073 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1563171795 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1577281365 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1578522614 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1580738992 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1583060282 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1592029648 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1593771780 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1600938746 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1604436048 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1606010650 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W164214295 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1764370611 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1967421457 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1993019209 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2009783243 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2013405237 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2022747359 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2041920289 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2055092880 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2059518239 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2071874534 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2074653917 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2080948671 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2089903392 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2089963910 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2095142423 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2120303704 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2121854175 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2147652356 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2228923419 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2325832390 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2329988852 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2330932072 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2479568401 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2488677972 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2586878537 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2799097686 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2901186798 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2908257458 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2970460809 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2972842462 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W3002494296 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W3120699515 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W3126833809 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W3127311540 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W410093626 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W563384912 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W567205502 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W570395255 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W572114868 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W578054479 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W579437625 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W601987975 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W605522741 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W620024653 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W620244910 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W624253436 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W627639206 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W632642162 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W639229042 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W641190646 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W649266090 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W657112560 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W657989274 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W1569131634 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W2954144765 @default.
- W2596487679 cites W3088770816 @default.
- W2596487679 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/mod.2017.0005" @default.
- W2596487679 hasPublicationYear "2017" @default.
- W2596487679 type Work @default.
- W2596487679 sameAs 2596487679 @default.