FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2600811232> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2600811232 endingPage "205" @default.
• W2600811232 startingPage "167" @default.
• W2600811232 abstract "Patrick Matthew’s (1831) prior-publication of the complete hypothesis of natural selection “anticipated” Darwin’s Origin of Species by 28 years and Darwin’s and Wallace’s (1858) Linnean papers on the same topic by 27. Founded on the premise that no naturalist read it before 1860, Darwin’s and Wallace’s claims of duel independent discovery of Matthew’s hypothesis have been accepted by the scientific community. However, the central premise upon which those claims have been accepted — that no naturalist read Matthew’s ideas before 1858 — is a proven fallacy, because the famous and hugely influential naturalist Loudon reviewed Matthew’s book in 1832, commenting that it appeared to have something original to say on “the origin of species”. The fact that Loudon was a naturalist has been totally ignored until now. Furthermore, it is newly discovered that after reviewing Matthew’s book he went on to edit the journal that published two of Blyth’s highly influential papers on organic evolution. Blyth was Darwin’s most prolific and helpful correspondent on the topic. Further new discoveries reveal that, besides Loudon, whose work was well known to Darwin and his associates, six other naturalists read Matthew’s book and then cited it years before 1858. One, Selby, sat on several scientific committees with Darwin, and was a friend of his father. Selby went on to edit Wallace’s famous Sarawak paper on organic evolution. Another, Robert Chambers, a correspondent of Darwin, who met with him, went on to write the influential Vestiges of Creation, which both Darwin and Wallace admitted was an influence on their work. Undeniable potential knowledge-transfer routes did exist before 1858, therefore, between those who read Matthew’s ideas and commented upon them in the literature, and Darwin and Wallace. In light of the fact that influential naturalists, known to both Darwin and Wallace, did read Matthew’s original ideas before 1858, veracity in the history of discovery requires now an investigation into the possibility of cryptomnesia or deliberate pre-1860 plagiarism by Darwin and Wallace. In that regard, the notion of “knowledge contamination” is proposed and presented in a three-fold typology of escalating culpability for replicators of prior published work with citation. Future research in this area should turn to the neglected correspondence and private journal archives of those naturalists known to Darwin and Wallace who read Matthew’s ideas before 1860." @default.
• W2600811232 created "2017-04-07" @default.
• W2600811232 creator A5004142066 @default.
• W2600811232 date "2021-05-24" @default.
• W2600811232 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
• W2600811232 title "On Knowledge Contamination: New Data Challenges Claims of Darwin’s and Wallace’s Independent Conceptions of Matthew’s Prior-Published Hypothesis" @default.
• W2600811232 cites W1550375751 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W1558125704 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W1608608161 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W1875027343 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W1944481534 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W1987884313 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2009531441 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2041802418 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2049871294 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2073180115 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2081541193 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2155301287 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2504095978 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2506259190 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2543316877 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2744860591 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2883512297 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W309442731 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W49296861 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W597311067 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W612037173 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W638947979 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W641725507 @default.
• W2600811232 cites W2057658910 @default.
• W2600811232 doi "https://doi.org/10.53763/fag.2015.12.115" @default.
• W2600811232 hasPublicationYear "2021" @default.
• W2600811232 type Work @default.
• W2600811232 sameAs 2600811232 @default.
• W2600811232 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2600811232 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2600811232 hasAuthorship W2600811232A5004142066 @default.
• W2600811232 hasBestOaLocation W26008112321 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C115903868 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C196919123 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C206118921 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C2778023277 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C2781035248 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C2992503995 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C3019183317 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C43236755 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C52119013 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C53553401 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C74916050 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C111472728 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C115903868 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C138885662 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C196919123 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C206118921 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C2778023277 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C2781035248 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C2992503995 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C3019183317 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C41008148 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C43236755 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C52119013 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C53553401 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C74916050 @default.
• W2600811232 hasConceptScore W2600811232C95457728 @default.
• W2600811232 hasLocation W26008112321 @default.
• W2600811232 hasLocation W26008112322 @default.
• W2600811232 hasOpenAccess W2600811232 @default.
• W2600811232 hasPrimaryLocation W26008112321 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W1627030629 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W1965831328 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W2024434665 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W2090040777 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W2152682422 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W2600811232 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W3025429083 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W4205728189 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W4256274873 @default.
• W2600811232 hasRelatedWork W647119795 @default.
• W2600811232 hasVolume "12" @default.
• W2600811232 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2600811232 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2600811232 magId "2600811232" @default.
• W2600811232 workType "article" @default.