Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2604497751> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2604497751 endingPage "1656" @default.
- W2604497751 startingPage "1606" @default.
- W2604497751 abstract "Abstract Tirthankar Roy's recent synthesis on the economic history of early modern India claims to provide a new, overarching narrative placing this period within the broader sweep of the history of what Roy defines as ‘capitalism’ in India in the very long term. This article provides a detailed critique of Roy's monograph, suggesting that it suffers from some serious methodological deficits, arising not least from a future-oriented paradigm that imposes anachronistic concepts on this period, including the very notion of ‘India’. Furthermore, Roy's view of the economy as being fundamentally driven forward by the rise of a coastal polity, expanding inwards from Bombay, Madras, and Calcutta, sits awkwardly with his repeated claim that colonialism was of little significance for Indian economic history. Finally, this article suggests that this period might be more fruitfully approached not only by abandoning the telos of what we know of India's future, but also by adopting both regionally focused and comparative approaches, turning away from long-distance trade as the primary lens through which to view the economy, and instead examining endogenous factors in the economies of individual regions and enriching our understanding of them by reference to studies of other world regions with comparable patterns of development in the same period. More nuanced ways of approaching economic change in the very long run, including the importance of developments in modes of consumption and market- and profit-oriented economic behaviour, are suggested as a better means of understanding both the economies of the late pre-colonial centuries in the Indian subcontinent and the development of capitalism, which should also be understood in a more specific manner than Roy allows." @default.
- W2604497751 created "2017-04-14" @default.
- W2604497751 creator A5051184996 @default.
- W2604497751 date "2015-06-04" @default.
- W2604497751 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W2604497751 title "How Should We Approach the Economy of ‘Early Modern India’?" @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1492500356 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1517835193 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1558282581 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1560644006 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W156211706 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1581679744 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1605544535 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1763230457 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1839287587 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1966645177 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1967223455 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1969786981 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1971484910 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1972327632 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1974166050 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1983278397 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1990175860 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W1997479366 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2002525301 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2017811064 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2019033561 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2028762057 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2029632817 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2034559958 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2034849930 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2035661043 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2036234655 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2049659251 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2053460805 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2061173358 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2061841889 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2063487935 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2069821211 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2072852369 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2074404934 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2083982672 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2091954458 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2092785444 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2092849649 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2096879666 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2098054124 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2102070748 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2102704965 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2120995370 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2121950611 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2124375361 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2125583491 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2131626518 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2132492727 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2140112293 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2152589165 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2153501227 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2199397862 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2234471825 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2288345593 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2333845076 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2476669874 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2479587242 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2484652326 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2493453771 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2495863739 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2501584516 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W2501953786 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3022144276 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3121569174 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3122497297 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3125817621 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3139925150 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3144287217 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3152416718 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W3209884291 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4206085194 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4211183808 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4214527445 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4214592866 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4230739519 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4236894389 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4238452775 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4242713801 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4243576110 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4244190807 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4244865133 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4245602679 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4245884402 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4247771297 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4247895640 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4248276427 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4250759125 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4252219515 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4252461805 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4253781650 @default.
- W2604497751 cites W4256626684 @default.