Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2726804541> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2726804541 abstract "Abstract We recently presented a statistical comparison between two models of latent dynamics in macaque lateral intraparietal (LIP) area spike trains—a continuous ‘ramping’ (diffusion-to-bound) model, and a discrete ‘stepping’ model—and found that a substantial fraction of neurons (recorded in two different studies) were better supported by the stepping model (Latimer et al., 2015). Here, we respond to a recent challenge to the validity of these findings that focuses primarily on the possibility of a lower bound on LIP firing rates (Zylberberg & Shadlen, 2016). The paper in question proposed alternate formulations of the ramping model, and argued (via indirect analyses) that half the neurons in the population were better explained by the new model; if correct, this would lead to an even split in the number of neurons better explained by each model. These analyses, while interesting, do not alter the conclusions of our original paper. Here, we review the criticisms raised by Zylberberg & Shadlen and report several new analyses using models with lower bounds. First, we show that the stepping model continued to provide a better description of LIP spike trains when fit using only an early period of each trial. Second, we performed a direct model comparison between our stepping model and a ramping-with-baseline model proposed by Zylberberg & Shadlen; we found that (in a pleasing moment of agreement) roughly half the neurons were better explained by each model. Interestingly, inspection of the cells that switched classifications revealed that many did not strictly exhibit the classical ramping PSTHs that motivated these analyses in the first place. We also examined two other issues raised in recent discussions of LIP: (1) We show that a non-integrating model is consistent with some core aspects of behavioral data previously offered as evidence for continuous integration; and (2) We examine analyses based on the response covariance (“CorCE”), and show that it does not reliably distinguish ramping and stepping dynamics for our dataset. Taken together, these discussions highlight the value of data-driven characterizations of both neural and behavioral dynamics with appropriate statistical tools." @default.
- W2726804541 created "2017-07-14" @default.
- W2726804541 creator A5003362529 @default.
- W2726804541 creator A5003778431 @default.
- W2726804541 creator A5047908820 @default.
- W2726804541 date "2017-07-08" @default.
- W2726804541 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W2726804541 title "No cause for pause: new analyses of ramping and stepping dynamics in LIP (Rebuttal to Response to Reply to Comment on Latimer et al 2015)" @default.
- W2726804541 cites W1589439850 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W1961056875 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W1979224386 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W1980871601 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2002824768 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2017410988 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2031534617 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2032340480 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2035849979 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2045464688 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2057470090 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2057765075 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2063716754 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2069242131 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2070029806 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2080207944 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2085406430 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2090544951 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2090948255 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2100259206 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2105007656 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2105430025 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2109234859 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2113263087 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2116991887 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2121454341 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2122066429 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2127786956 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2141729740 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2144095870 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2158130856 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2164011442 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2168648043 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2169134378 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2261997804 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2325699217 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2397708604 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2438132737 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2465196824 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2554642868 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2560240428 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2578266030 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2600031860 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W2953071419 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W4233699785 @default.
- W2726804541 cites W4254046671 @default.
- W2726804541 doi "https://doi.org/10.1101/160994" @default.
- W2726804541 hasPublicationYear "2017" @default.
- W2726804541 type Work @default.
- W2726804541 sameAs 2726804541 @default.
- W2726804541 citedByCount "2" @default.
- W2726804541 countsByYear W27268045412020 @default.
- W2726804541 countsByYear W27268045412022 @default.
- W2726804541 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
- W2726804541 hasAuthorship W2726804541A5003362529 @default.
- W2726804541 hasAuthorship W2726804541A5003778431 @default.
- W2726804541 hasAuthorship W2726804541A5047908820 @default.
- W2726804541 hasBestOaLocation W27268045411 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C115903868 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C145912823 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C149629883 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C178790620 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C24890656 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C2777644245 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C2781390188 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C2908647359 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConcept C99454951 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C115903868 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C121332964 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C145912823 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C149629883 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C178790620 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C185592680 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C24890656 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C2777644245 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C2781390188 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C2908647359 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C41008148 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C71924100 @default.
- W2726804541 hasConceptScore W2726804541C99454951 @default.
- W2726804541 hasLocation W27268045411 @default.
- W2726804541 hasOpenAccess W2726804541 @default.
- W2726804541 hasPrimaryLocation W27268045411 @default.
- W2726804541 hasRelatedWork W200885709 @default.
- W2726804541 hasRelatedWork W2013598665 @default.
- W2726804541 hasRelatedWork W2055712014 @default.
- W2726804541 hasRelatedWork W2199339534 @default.
- W2726804541 hasRelatedWork W2407721805 @default.