Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2797789229> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2797789229 endingPage "121" @default.
- W2797789229 startingPage "102" @default.
- W2797789229 abstract "The UK draft NICE guideline on depression in adults was sent out for stakeholder consultation between July and September 2017. The final guideline publication date currently remains ‘to be confirmed’. This paper sets out key concerns with the methodology employed in the guideline and its impact on recommendations for psychodynamic psychotherapies for complex and persistent depression. The draft largely ignored the subjective experiences and voices of service users, carers and members of the public, using out of date limited evidence of service user and carer experiences. The guideline fails to incorporate what limited qualitative evidence it reviewed into any treatment recommendations. The Guideline Committee created its own method for categorising depression by longevity, severity and complexity. This has resulted in erroneous and unhelpful classifications of research studies under groupings which do not match clinical and service user experiences or US and European approaches, rendering analyses and conclusions unreliable. We also outline instances of incorrect classification of psychodynamic treatments (such as inclusion of non bona fide treatments or exclusion of relevant bona fide treatment studies) which enables the omission of a recommendation for psychodynamic psychotherapy for complex and persistent depression. Depression is often a long-term condition or can become so if immediate care is inadequate; yet the draft recommendations are all made on the basis of short-term outcome data (with often less than eight weeks between baseline and outcome). NICE guidelines for long-term physical conditions would treat this evidence as inadequate. Finally, the draft guideline used the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) system of assessing methodological quality in such a way as to produce a systematic bias in favour of drug trials, selectively omitting trial data with long-term follow-up points and those which used non-symptom outcomes. Herein, we consider the increasingly evident limitations of the paradigm NICE works within for ensuring patient choice and equity of access to a wide range of therapies." @default.
- W2797789229 created "2018-04-24" @default.
- W2797789229 creator A5018039193 @default.
- W2797789229 creator A5019538631 @default.
- W2797789229 creator A5029577036 @default.
- W2797789229 creator A5046369760 @default.
- W2797789229 date "2018-04-03" @default.
- W2797789229 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W2797789229 title "Epistemological flaws in NICE review methodology and its impact on recommendations for psychodynamic psychotherapies for complex and persistent depression" @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1972592417 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1973173372 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1975021069 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1975168051 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1978560738 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1986163847 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1986866660 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W1995480497 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2014402555 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2018021892 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2018642794 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2042365206 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2069965305 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2071302139 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2074409370 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2090878752 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2099382184 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2103534105 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2113367546 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2115658723 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2116373921 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2129211216 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2132023505 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2141815976 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2142039862 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2148796661 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2150442426 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2154975061 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2155216550 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2156490804 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2167308316 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2170847042 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2190019624 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2233786344 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2253160486 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2264584315 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2275175808 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2288709245 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2323456830 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2326556724 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2346168897 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2409889497 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2489111096 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2553910288 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2558778675 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2564414954 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2592399410 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W2777253753 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W4235813114 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W4243485678 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W4247665917 @default.
- W2797789229 cites W4252621549 @default.
- W2797789229 doi "https://doi.org/10.1080/02668734.2018.1458331" @default.
- W2797789229 hasPublicationYear "2018" @default.
- W2797789229 type Work @default.
- W2797789229 sameAs 2797789229 @default.
- W2797789229 citedByCount "13" @default.
- W2797789229 countsByYear W27977892292019 @default.
- W2797789229 countsByYear W27977892292020 @default.
- W2797789229 countsByYear W27977892292021 @default.
- W2797789229 countsByYear W27977892292022 @default.
- W2797789229 countsByYear W27977892292023 @default.
- W2797789229 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2797789229 hasAuthorship W2797789229A5018039193 @default.
- W2797789229 hasAuthorship W2797789229A5019538631 @default.
- W2797789229 hasAuthorship W2797789229A5029577036 @default.
- W2797789229 hasAuthorship W2797789229A5046369760 @default.
- W2797789229 hasBestOaLocation W27977892292 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C102655426 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C118552586 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C127413603 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C139719470 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C142724271 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C147176958 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C184356942 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C201305675 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C2776867660 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C2777286243 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C2779256446 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C2780182762 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C39549134 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C542102704 @default.
- W2797789229 hasConcept C5458421 @default.