FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2800693921> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2800693921 startingPage "89" @default.
• W2800693921 abstract "It is tempting to commemorate the 2014 centenary of the exclusionary rule by celebrating our historically progressive role in constitutional rights protection, but those familiar with the facts know that Fourth Amendment violations persist unabated. As New Yorkers consider Judge Scheindlin’s damning assessment of police stop-and-frisk practices, and the country erupts in protests following fatal police encounters, are legal scholars who continue to pontificate on constitutional bona fides addressing “real” Fourth Amendment questions?Traditional academic abstraction and artificial doctrinal divides obscure the fact that rights and remedies are defined by their operation. Constitutional rights have no value if, after they have been violated, meaningful remedies are unattainable. This Article focuses instead on the functional relationship between rights and remedies and on *90 new constraints imposed by judicial recalibrations of the quantum and burden of remedial proof.The Roberts Court’s recent shotgun wedding linking exclusion to defense evidence establishing police officer “bad faith” or systemic police negligence illustrates the centrality of proof and evidence questions. Over the past few years, the Court has increased the quantum of defense suppression proof while simultaneously eliminating burden shifting to the prosecution. These shifts make most Fourth Amendment violations irremediable. It is not feasible to demand that defendants aggregate data establishing systemic police negligence. Defendants who seek, in the alternative, to prove that an illegal search was committed knowingly, recklessly, or with gross negligence invariably lack direct evidence of police officer intent. By changing the rules governing suppression under the guise of a narrow focus on deterrence, the Roberts Court has ensured that nearly all illegally seized evidence will be admitted. The only time evidence will be suppressed is when a defendant can prove circumstantially that police misconduct was so patently egregious that defense evidence supports a judicial inference of police “bad faith.”In theory, the Roberts Court has quietly erased a century of exclusion jurisprudence while eliding accountability for more overt action. In practice, if suppression is only available to defendants who can prove flagrant police “bad faith,” the Court has effectively resurrected the old due process “shocks the conscience” exclusion standard. New decisions illustrating the type of police behavior that can support an inference of bad faith under include patently race-based seizures, near-suspicionless repeated rectal searches, and (in a truly unforgettable case) the curbside excision of contraband from a suspect’s penis performed by the arresting officer.The full impact of increasing the quantum and reallocating the burden of proof is fully revealed in recent empirical studies demonstrating that illegally seized evidence is now routinely admitted. Prosecutors’ new, easy access to this evidence following warrant-based and warrantless searches will transform not just the small number of cases that go to trial, but plea calculations in every case where evidence was previously excludable on Fourth Amendment grounds." @default.
• W2800693921 created "2018-05-17" @default.
• W2800693921 creator A5059074376 @default.
• W2800693921 date "2015-01-01" @default.
• W2800693921 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
• W2800693921 title "Rights, Remedies, and the Quantum and Burden of Proof" @default.
• W2800693921 hasPublicationYear "2015" @default.
• W2800693921 type Work @default.
• W2800693921 sameAs 2800693921 @default.
• W2800693921 citedByCount "1" @default.
• W2800693921 countsByYear W28006939212020 @default.
• W2800693921 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2800693921 hasAuthorship W2800693921A5059074376 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C140334061 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C190253527 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C2777189325 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C2778272461 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C2781298881 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C60643870 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConcept C69775031 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C140334061 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C144024400 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C17744445 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C190253527 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C199539241 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C2777189325 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C2778272461 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C2781298881 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C60643870 @default.
• W2800693921 hasConceptScore W2800693921C69775031 @default.
• W2800693921 hasIssue "1" @default.
• W2800693921 hasLocation W28006939211 @default.
• W2800693921 hasOpenAccess W2800693921 @default.
• W2800693921 hasPrimaryLocation W28006939211 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W1518165293 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W162025541 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W1961167208 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W23782784 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W265198790 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3121210493 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3121878280 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3122115944 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3122400890 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3122526261 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3123803141 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3124554717 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3125338914 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3125923902 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3168921815 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3176506400 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3210947586 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W359055173 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W853543279 @default.
• W2800693921 hasRelatedWork W3121922699 @default.
• W2800693921 hasVolume "3" @default.
• W2800693921 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2800693921 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2800693921 magId "2800693921" @default.
• W2800693921 workType "article" @default.