Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2804475722> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2804475722 endingPage "1482" @default.
- W2804475722 startingPage "1469" @default.
- W2804475722 abstract "Transgenic Golden Rice has been hailed as a practical solution to vitamin A deficiency, but has also been heavily criticized. To facilitate a balanced view on this polarized debate, we investigated existing arguments for and against Golden Rice from a sustainability science perspective. In a structured literature review of peer-reviewed publications on Golden Rice, we assessed to what extent 64 articles addressed 70 questions covering different aspects of sustainability. Using cluster analysis, we grouped the literature into two major branches, containing two clusters each. These clusters differed in the range and nature of the sustainability aspects addressed, disciplinary affiliation and overall evaluation of Golden Rice. The ‘biotechnological’ branch (clusters: ‘technical effectiveness’ and ‘advocacy’) was dominated by the natural sciences, focused on biophysical plant-consumer interactions, and evaluated Golden Rice positively. In contrast, the ‘socio-systemic’ branch (clusters: ‘economic efficiency’ and ‘equity and holism’) was primarily comprised of social sciences, addressed a wider variety of sustainability aspects including participation, equity, ethics and biodiversity, and more often pointed to the shortcomings of Golden Rice. There were little to no integration efforts between the two branches, and highly polarized positions arose in the clusters on ‘advocacy’ and ‘equity and holism’. To explore this divide, we investigated the influences of disciplinary affiliations and personal values on the respective problem framings. We conclude that to move beyond a polarized debate, it may be fruitful to ground the Golden Rice discourse in facets and methods of sustainability science, with an emphasis on participation and integration of diverging interests." @default.
- W2804475722 created "2018-06-01" @default.
- W2804475722 creator A5016050844 @default.
- W2804475722 creator A5020522329 @default.
- W2804475722 creator A5024359289 @default.
- W2804475722 creator A5089099880 @default.
- W2804475722 date "2018-05-17" @default.
- W2804475722 modified "2023-09-29" @default.
- W2804475722 title "From disagreements to dialogue: unpacking the Golden Rice debate" @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1481953682 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1492535541 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1558240935 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1560486336 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1607675442 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1682467299 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1832365841 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1902841288 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1914434622 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1919574279 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1955259747 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1970616478 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1974564128 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1978851545 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1980286999 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1982748232 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1989831391 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1992275176 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1995399613 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W1998221905 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2000557723 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2001031327 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2001683367 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2003112502 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2004520758 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2007936520 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2012569440 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2017578785 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2017581418 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2021611230 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2026644581 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2028318208 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2028851317 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2038900650 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2038960430 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2039897521 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2048142130 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2048548275 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2063578306 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2071516793 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2075595653 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2080187568 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2096885696 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2097034898 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2097133092 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2098814293 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2099236544 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2103067443 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2103501989 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2106605646 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2112786757 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2115474096 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2117941873 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2121125289 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2123797837 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2125687065 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2127489561 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2134761965 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2142291762 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2143058578 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2143444126 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2143746117 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2144421176 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2144559829 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2147163641 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2153619619 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2154180993 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2156172971 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2156405640 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2158468718 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2162334426 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2167325772 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2170975368 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2172183131 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2299051078 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2300776204 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2301607506 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2335842688 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2473015971 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2477358729 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2483554928 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2525884284 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2570469061 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2589387568 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2589664716 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2593006685 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2602096881 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W2623432331 @default.
- W2804475722 cites W3123621575 @default.