FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2808434351> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2808434351 endingPage "198" @default.
• W2808434351 startingPage "185" @default.
• W2808434351 abstract "We reply to two recently published, multi-authored opinion papers by opponents of sequence-based nomenclature, namely Zamora et al. (IMA Fungus 9: 167–175, 2018) and Thines et al. (IMA Fungus 9: 177–183, 2018). While we agree with some of the principal arguments brought forward by these authors, we address misconceptions and demonstrate that some of the presumed evidence presented in these papers has been wrongly interpreted. We disagree that allowing sequences as types would fundamentally alter the nature of types, since a similar nature of abstracted features as type is already allowed in the Code (Art. 40.5), namely an illustration. We also disagree that there is a high risk of introducing artifactual taxa, as this risk can be quantified at well below 5 %, considering the various types of high-throughput sequencing errors. Contrary to apparently widespread misconceptions, sequence-based nomenclature cannot be based on similarity-derived OTUs and their consensus sequences, but must be derived from rigorous, multiple alignment-based phylogenetic methods and quantitative, single-marker species recognition algorithms, using original sequence reads; it is therefore identical in its approach to single-marker studies based on physical types, an approach allowed by the Code. We recognize the limitations of the ITS as a single fungal barcoding marker, but point out that these result in a conservative approach, with ‘false negatives” surpassing “false positives”; a desirable feature of sequence-based nomenclature. Sequence-based nomenclature does not aim at accurately resolving species, but at naming sequences that represent unknown fungal lineages so that these can serve as a means of communication, so ending the untenable situation of an exponentially growing number of unlabeled fungal sequences that fill online repositories. The risks are outweighed by the gains obtained by a reference library of named sequences spanning the full array of fungal diversity. Finally, we elaborate provisions in addition to our original proposal to amend the Code that would take care of the issues brought forward by opponents to this approach. In particular, taking up the idea of the Candidatus status of invalid, provisional names in prokaryote nomenclature, we propose a compromise that would allow valid publication of voucherless, sequence-based names in a consistent manner, but with the obligate designation as “nom. seq.” (nomen sequentiae). Such names would not have priority over specimen- or culture-based names unless either epitypified with a physical type or adopted for protection on the recommendation of a committee of the International Commission on the Taxonomy of Fungi following evaluation based on strict quality control of the underlying studies based on established rules or recommendations." @default.
• W2808434351 created "2018-06-21" @default.
• W2808434351 creator A5015355314 @default.
• W2808434351 creator A5037089017 @default.
• W2808434351 creator A5047068930 @default.
• W2808434351 date "2018-06-01" @default.
• W2808434351 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
• W2808434351 title "Sequence-based nomenclature: a reply to Thines et al. and Zamora et al. and provisions for an amended proposal “from the floor” to allow DNA sequences as types of names" @default.
• W2808434351 cites W1770209958 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W1952156077 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W1963999629 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W1969331657 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W1977192785 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W1986313431 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W1993679825 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2004568303 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2011955256 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2016473919 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2019557460 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2022880436 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2036839190 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2050437740 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2058613443 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2064504648 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2068187483 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2073569767 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2074722678 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2086138650 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2093219539 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2095195012 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2095280676 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2099319004 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2100389916 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2103412200 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2106308757 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2121011688 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2125061007 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2125948619 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2130834783 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2136879569 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2138012030 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2142486194 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2145361589 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2145371240 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2149526237 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2150112807 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2155288651 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2160360534 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2160723071 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2160947363 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2170426490 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2259452174 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2301598227 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2331456134 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2341070773 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2515572522 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2518285967 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2529396425 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2536767824 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2562915552 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2588207325 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2588655860 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2598983052 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2606790044 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2614600059 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2618847018 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2742586199 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2752404277 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2759108977 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2772376372 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2794078814 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2804148470 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2804598221 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2804858124 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2807497615 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2808434351 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2945841401 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2945845213 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W2951358594 @default.
• W2808434351 cites W4244149859 @default.
• W2808434351 doi "https://doi.org/10.5598/imafungus.2018.09.01.12" @default.
• W2808434351 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/6048568" @default.
• W2808434351 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30018879" @default.
• W2808434351 hasPublicationYear "2018" @default.
• W2808434351 type Work @default.
• W2808434351 sameAs 2808434351 @default.
• W2808434351 citedByCount "15" @default.
• W2808434351 countsByYear W28084343512018 @default.
• W2808434351 countsByYear W28084343512019 @default.
• W2808434351 countsByYear W28084343512020 @default.
• W2808434351 countsByYear W28084343512021 @default.
• W2808434351 countsByYear W28084343512023 @default.
• W2808434351 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2808434351 hasAuthorship W2808434351A5015355314 @default.
• W2808434351 hasAuthorship W2808434351A5037089017 @default.
• W2808434351 hasAuthorship W2808434351A5047068930 @default.
• W2808434351 hasBestOaLocation W28084343511 @default.
• W2808434351 hasConcept C104317684 @default.

• next