FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2810728504> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2810728504 endingPage "84" @default.
• W2810728504 startingPage "67" @default.
• W2810728504 abstract "Contested ConfessionsThe Sins of the Press and Evelyn Waugh’s False Penance in The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold D. Marcel DeCoste (bio) I dont [sic] much mind the papers saying I am beastly, which is true, or that I write badly, which isn’t. What enrages me is wrong facts. They always are wrong in these knowing “profiles.” evelyn waugh, letter to nancy mitford, september 27, 1950 Confessions no doubt speak of guilt, but don’t necessarily speak the guilt. peter brooks, troubling confessions Published in 1957, Evelyn Waugh’s The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold advertised itself as a tale drawn from the author’s life. As the prefatory note to the American edition readily confided, “Three years ago Mr. Waugh suffered a brief bout of hallucination closely resembling what is here described.”1 Just as he was eager, on his return from a 1954 trip to Ceylon, to regale friends with stories of his “sharp but brief attack of insanity,” so, when he shared this experience with the public, Waugh was determined that they too understand his newest fiction also as autobiography.2 This end, at least, he certainly achieved. First reviewers, taking up his invitation to read the [End Page 67] novel as memoir, professed admiration for this candid “experiment in self-examination,” and later critics have largely agreed with Jeffrey Heath in deeming it “the most revealing book [Waugh] ever wrote.”3 Indeed, with its depiction of an alter ego beset by dependencies and delusions, by hallucinations that accuse him of the widest spectrum of misdeeds, Pinfold has commonly been judged to be something more than a mere autobiographical vignette. Cued by Waugh to take the text as the author’s own truth, critics have been “prompt to treat the book as a confession rather than a novel.”4 On this view, the voices that harangue Gilbert Pinfold represent the penitential eruption, first into phantasm and then into print, of Waugh’s guilty conscience; thus, for R. Neill Johnson, “the mimicking voices he hears are externalizations of his own self-hatred.”5 Yet Douglas Patey’s claim that Waugh “was not a man to bare his soul before the public without some carefully contrived purpose” is both astute and corroborated by the narrative itself.6 At the novel’s conclusion, Pinfold, restored to lucidity, asks why, if he himself were the source of the voices’ accusations, he did not prepare a more damning indictment: “I mean to say, . . . I could make a far blacker and more plausible case than they ever did” (OGP, 229). Given the incoherence of many of the charges hurled at him, it is not odd that Pinfold should challenge their validity. But this question, unanswered at novel’s end and largely unaddressed by critics, does more than this: it unsettles the reader’s role as confessor by subverting the assumption that this tale is, in fact, that exercise in self-accusation Johnson and others have taken it to be. The answer to Pinfold’s question, I contend, is that Waugh’s novel neither depicts Pinfold’s confession nor enacts Waugh’s own. Rather, it is, as its title proclaims, the story of an ordeal, an agonizing and agonistic “test of guilt or innocence,” from which Waugh’s stand-in emerges, we are told, “victor” (OGP, 231).7 What the book exposes, then, is not the penitent-author’s grievous faults, but an author’s contest with his critics, and what it seeks, by its victory, to establish, is the falseness of those critics’ stock formulation and reprobation of Waugh’s sins. [End Page 68] Thus while John Foxwell maintains that “there are no metafictional ‘mechanics’ brought into play” in this text, I argue that Pinfold is nothing other than a sustained critique of the damning fiction of Waugh, and particularly of his faith, that critics had long substituted for a sober evaluation of his art.8 As Patey rightly notes, after the extraordinary commercial success of his first Catholic novel, Brideshead Revisited (1945), Waugh’s fiction met with “reviews which ritually praised his prose style before turning to the real work of damning his politics,” and more vexingly, of damning his..." @default.
• W2810728504 created "2018-07-10" @default.
• W2810728504 creator A5083913568 @default.
• W2810728504 date "2018-01-01" @default.
• W2810728504 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
• W2810728504 title "Contested Confessions: The Sins of the Press and Evelyn Waugh’s False Penance in The Ordeal of Gilbert Pinfold" @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1502573645 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1511726808 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1534984607 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1568372540 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1588396514 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1616572497 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1769044961 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W1980959521 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2027769401 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2033627661 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2055006699 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2056289046 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2071068384 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2085803930 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2091150462 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2108308495 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2317594836 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2401075347 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W2405998055 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W429040302 @default.
• W2810728504 cites W582261938 @default.
• W2810728504 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/log.2018.0018" @default.
• W2810728504 hasPublicationYear "2018" @default.
• W2810728504 type Work @default.
• W2810728504 sameAs 2810728504 @default.
• W2810728504 citedByCount "1" @default.
• W2810728504 countsByYear W28107285042019 @default.
• W2810728504 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2810728504 hasAuthorship W2810728504A5083913568 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C11171543 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C177897776 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C2776678506 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C2778690065 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C2779702343 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C2780027720 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C48918747 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConcept C520712124 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C11171543 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C124952713 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C138885662 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C142362112 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C15744967 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C177897776 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C27206212 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C2776678506 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C2778690065 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C2779702343 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C2780027720 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C48918747 @default.
• W2810728504 hasConceptScore W2810728504C520712124 @default.
• W2810728504 hasIssue "3" @default.
• W2810728504 hasLocation W28107285041 @default.
• W2810728504 hasOpenAccess W2810728504 @default.
• W2810728504 hasPrimaryLocation W28107285041 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W1035787921 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W157484469 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W2073020385 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W2381130096 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W2503349472 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W2810728504 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W3012174331 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W3111073512 @default.
• W2810728504 hasRelatedWork W3173347369 @default.
• W2810728504 hasVolume "21" @default.
• W2810728504 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2810728504 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2810728504 magId "2810728504" @default.
• W2810728504 workType "article" @default.