Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2884770003> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2884770003 endingPage "254" @default.
- W2884770003 startingPage "234" @default.
- W2884770003 abstract "Analogical proportions are statements of the form a is to b as c is to d. Such expressions compare the pair (a,b) with the pair (c,d). Previous papers have developed logical modelings of such proportions both in Boolean and in multiple-valued settings. They emphasize a reading of the proportion as “the way a and b differ is the same as c and d differ”. The ambition of this paper is twofold. The paper first provides a deeper understanding and further justifications of the Boolean modeling, before introducing analogical inequalities, where “as” is replaced by “as much as” in the comparison of two pairs. From an abstract viewpoint, analogical proportions are supposed to obey at least three postulates expressing reflexivity, symmetry, and stability under central permutation. Nevertheless these postulates are not enough to determine a single model and a minimality condition has to be added as shown in this paper. These models are organized in a complete lattice based on set inclusion. This leads us to discuss lower and upper approximations of the minimal model. Apart from being minimal, this model can also be evaluated in terms of Kolmogorov complexity via an expression reflecting the intended meaning of analogy. We show that the six Boolean patterns of the minimal model that make Boolean analogy true minimize this expression. Besides, analogical proportions extend to 4-tuples of Boolean vectors. This enables us to explain why analogical proportions also reads in terms of similarity (rather than difference, i.e., dissimilarity): a and d share the same presence or absence of features as b and c. Moreover, we establish a link between analogical proportion and Hamming distances between components of the proportion. We also emphasize that analogical proportions are pervasive in any comparison of two vectors a and d that implicitly induce the existence of “intermediary” vectors b and c forming together such a proportion. The similarity reading and the dissimilarity reading of a Boolean analogical proportion are no longer equivalent in the multiple-valued setting, where they give birth to two distinct options that are recalled. These options are also discussed with respect to their capability to handle so-called “continuous” logical proportions of the form a is to b as b is to c involving some idea of “betweenness”. In all the previously investigated issues, the pairs involved in the 4-tuples were compared via equalities of similarities or equalities of dissimilarities. This observation suggests to also consider statements of the form “a is to b at least as much as c is to d”, leading to the concept of “analogical inequalities”. Thus, instead of expressing equality between differences or similarities, as it is the case for analogical proportions, it is also interesting to express inequalities between such differences or similarities. Starting from the modeling of analogical proportions, we investigate the logical modeling of analogical inequalities, both in the Boolean and in the multiple-valued cases, and discuss their potential use in relation with some recent related work in computer vision." @default.
- W2884770003 created "2018-08-03" @default.
- W2884770003 creator A5043954025 @default.
- W2884770003 creator A5049896579 @default.
- W2884770003 date "2018-10-01" @default.
- W2884770003 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W2884770003 title "Analogical proportions: From equality to inequality" @default.
- W2884770003 cites W1829060681 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W1997423404 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2002093268 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2003345759 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2029287713 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2059975159 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2075440969 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2077912109 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2296168485 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2316000915 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2319275595 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2469455946 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W2753783655 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W3100404639 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W4213350211 @default.
- W2884770003 cites W632224533 @default.
- W2884770003 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijar.2018.07.005" @default.
- W2884770003 hasPublicationYear "2018" @default.
- W2884770003 type Work @default.
- W2884770003 sameAs 2884770003 @default.
- W2884770003 citedByCount "15" @default.
- W2884770003 countsByYear W28847700032019 @default.
- W2884770003 countsByYear W28847700032020 @default.
- W2884770003 countsByYear W28847700032021 @default.
- W2884770003 countsByYear W28847700032022 @default.
- W2884770003 countsByYear W28847700032023 @default.
- W2884770003 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2884770003 hasAuthorship W2884770003A5043954025 @default.
- W2884770003 hasAuthorship W2884770003A5049896579 @default.
- W2884770003 hasBestOaLocation W28847700032 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C10021369 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C103278499 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C114614502 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C115961682 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C118615104 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C136119220 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C169171071 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C202444582 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C207764348 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C21308566 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C24890656 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C521332185 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C81518389 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConcept C90559484 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C10021369 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C103278499 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C111472728 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C114614502 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C115961682 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C118615104 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C121332964 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C136119220 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C138885662 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C154945302 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C169171071 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C199360897 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C202444582 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C207764348 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C21308566 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C24890656 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C33923547 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C41008148 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C521332185 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C81518389 @default.
- W2884770003 hasConceptScore W2884770003C90559484 @default.
- W2884770003 hasLocation W28847700031 @default.
- W2884770003 hasLocation W28847700032 @default.
- W2884770003 hasLocation W28847700033 @default.
- W2884770003 hasLocation W28847700034 @default.
- W2884770003 hasLocation W28847700035 @default.
- W2884770003 hasLocation W28847700036 @default.
- W2884770003 hasOpenAccess W2884770003 @default.
- W2884770003 hasPrimaryLocation W28847700031 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W1496446432 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2023768598 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2037090414 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2043703128 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2064028328 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2066939736 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2369221237 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2377302330 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W2940617399 @default.
- W2884770003 hasRelatedWork W4308506997 @default.
- W2884770003 hasVolume "101" @default.