Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2891364607> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2891364607 endingPage "3158" @default.
- W2891364607 startingPage "3141" @default.
- W2891364607 abstract "Facts about justification are not brute facts. They are epistemic facts that depend upon more fundamental non-epistemic facts. Internalists about justification often argue for mentalism, which claims that facts about justification supervene upon one’s non-factive mental states, using Lehrer and Cohen’s (Synthese 55(2):191–207, 1983) New Evil Demon Problem. The New Evil Demon Problem tells you to imagine yourself the victim of a Cartesian demon who deceives you about what the external world is like, and then asks whether you nevertheless have justification for your beliefs about the external world. Internalists and externalists agree that there is something that is epistemically good or valuable about both your actual beliefs and your beliefs in the demon scenario. Internalists claim that the epistemic property which these sets of beliefs share most intuitively should be thought of as sameness of justification. Externalists, on the other hand, reject this claim, usually either by challenging the internalist intuition directly, or by arguing that there is a more plausible way to think about the epistemic property in question. Recently, both kinds of externalist objection have been raised against the argument from the New Evil Demon Problem for mentalism. The goal of this paper is to defend the argument against three prominent objections—a pair of which is offered by Littlejohn (Can J Philos 39(3):399–434, 2009) and one by Williamson (in: Timmons M, Greco J, Mele A (eds.) Rationality and the good: critical essays on the ethics and epistemology of Robert Audi, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2007; in: Dutant J, Dohrn D (eds.) The new evil demon, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2016)." @default.
- W2891364607 created "2018-09-27" @default.
- W2891364607 creator A5020573115 @default.
- W2891364607 date "2018-09-15" @default.
- W2891364607 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W2891364607 title "The demon that makes us go mental: mentalism defended" @default.
- W2891364607 cites W134338952 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W1548244421 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W1630140543 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W176365926 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W1837614620 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W1980787102 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2003096522 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2021088902 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2022251420 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2025094662 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2026757091 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2029393287 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2035956074 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2042256831 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2048122125 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2056082784 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2057583667 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2058115491 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2058493047 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2082998687 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2083149888 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2088386518 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2131143610 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2132766911 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2140856508 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2155609466 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2206538325 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2313511012 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2461314788 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2483202552 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2497067580 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2500852844 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2576241852 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W2912076009 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W3148923306 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W332643687 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W4230230893 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W4232404578 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W4248946683 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W4252591847 @default.
- W2891364607 cites W573508270 @default.
- W2891364607 doi "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11098-018-1167-7" @default.
- W2891364607 hasPublicationYear "2018" @default.
- W2891364607 type Work @default.
- W2891364607 sameAs 2891364607 @default.
- W2891364607 citedByCount "1" @default.
- W2891364607 countsByYear W28913646072021 @default.
- W2891364607 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2891364607 hasAuthorship W2891364607A5020573115 @default.
- W2891364607 hasBestOaLocation W28913646071 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C110099512 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C123556308 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C124969852 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C132010649 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C159977948 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C182744844 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C201717286 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C24726157 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C26921437 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C2779227343 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C29554801 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C521304379 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConcept C98184364 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C110099512 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C111472728 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C123556308 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C124969852 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C132010649 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C138885662 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C159977948 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C182744844 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C185592680 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C201717286 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C24726157 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C26921437 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C2779227343 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C29554801 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C521304379 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C55493867 @default.
- W2891364607 hasConceptScore W2891364607C98184364 @default.
- W2891364607 hasIssue "12" @default.
- W2891364607 hasLocation W28913646071 @default.
- W2891364607 hasOpenAccess W2891364607 @default.
- W2891364607 hasPrimaryLocation W28913646071 @default.
- W2891364607 hasRelatedWork W1973153320 @default.
- W2891364607 hasRelatedWork W2021112530 @default.
- W2891364607 hasRelatedWork W2037568661 @default.
- W2891364607 hasRelatedWork W2062567055 @default.