Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2892360421> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2892360421 abstract "In a bilateral oligopoly where strategic buyers source a good from competing suppliers over time, buyers often have an incentive to sustain competition while suppliers benefit from excluding rival suppliers. We model this situation as a two period asymmetric cost Bertrand duopoly, where in the second period only those suppliers are active whose profit is sufficiently high in the first period. One or two buyers decide in each period how to source their demand from the suppliers. We solve the model analytically for a single buyer. In the first period the buyer dual sources and sustains competition when prices are high whereas for low prices single sourcing prevails. When the cost difference of suppliers is small, a unique subgame-perfect equilibrium in pure strategies exists. The more efficient supplier excludes the less efficient supplier by pricing at or below the cost of this supplier and the buyer sources all demand from him. With multiple identical buyers, equilibrium results do not change. Implementing the model numerically, we find that results are robust for coarse quantities. Exclusion can then occur even for large cost differences, while also equilibria exist where competition is often sustained. In addition, we implement an alternative procurement process where the buyer first sets the quantities to be sourced dependent on the relative prices. Then, equilibria where the buyer sources from both suppliers and competition is sustained with a high probability can exist even for small cost differences. The surplus of the buyer can, but need not, increase compared to the initial process. This model with its predicted predominance of exclusion is used in two experiments. First, we improve coordination from the baseline model with two independent buyers across treatments by allowing communication, introducing a single buyer and automating buyers. Outcomes in the second period are not observed to differ between treatments. In the first period, buyers nearly always dual source and sustain competition when this is rational for all treatments. With two independent buyers we observe exclusionary pricing to be predominant and accordingly competition is frequently not sustained. Contrary to the subgame-perfect prediction of no difference however, with improved coordination of buyers, pricing becomes more accommodating. Accordingly, competition is sustained more often and there is weak evidence that also buyer surplus increases in turn. In addition, we analyze experimentally the role of the procurement process with two buyers. Again, in the non-strategic setting of the second period, outcomes for all procurement processes are comparable. In the first period, supplier exclusion is predominant not only in the baseline process which corresponds to a procurement auction, but also for nonlinear prices in split-award auctions. Then, suppliers demand premia for small quantities which would allow to sustain competition, an option buyers however frequently do not use. When subsidies can be paid to suppliers or when buyers take their sourcing decisions before suppliers bid however, suppliers price more passively and competition is sustained substantially more often than in the baseline, in line with the prediction. Buyer sourcing is relatively close to rational behavior across procurement processes, although buyers are not always successful in sustaining competition when this is optimal. Therefore, the predicted increase in buyer surplus for subsidies and pre-announced sourcing is not observed. We thus find that both theoretically and experimentally, even with strong incentives for buyers to sustain competition, aggressive supplier behavior often entails exclusionary outcomes. However, both improved coordination of sourcing decisions and modifications of the procurement process are experimentally found to induce more accommodating pricing and lead to competition being sustained frequently." @default.
- W2892360421 created "2018-09-27" @default.
- W2892360421 creator A5055386114 @default.
- W2892360421 date "2011-01-01" @default.
- W2892360421 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2892360421 title "Strategic Sourcing to Sustain Supplier Competition - Theoretical and Experimental Analyses" @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1525464961 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1589779759 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W159399628 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1662343475 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1970486807 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1970930773 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1982992328 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1983420017 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1985726436 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2004329945 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2006567420 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2017990047 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2018232548 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2018924421 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2025081850 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2032277298 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2034184326 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2051233632 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2054574104 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2060915819 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2074155933 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2088278769 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2089649903 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2089834355 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2097226409 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2099760418 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2112130001 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2128168853 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2130226725 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2130988718 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2133898182 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2136415844 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2139977684 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2145368778 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2147712568 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2149243684 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2149961401 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2152834818 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2154675724 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2168536511 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2241324923 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2475550116 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2645835341 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3022052863 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3121388720 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3121569834 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3122190799 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3123188364 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3123305968 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3123342696 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3124477547 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3124557024 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3125017029 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3125625282 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3125968654 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W123299565 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W1518190945 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2094587083 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W2166915861 @default.
- W2892360421 cites W3122178513 @default.
- W2892360421 doi "https://doi.org/10.11588/heidok.00012566" @default.
- W2892360421 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
- W2892360421 type Work @default.
- W2892360421 sameAs 2892360421 @default.
- W2892360421 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2892360421 crossrefType "dissertation" @default.
- W2892360421 hasAuthorship W2892360421A5055386114 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C121398111 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C142470991 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C162853370 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C16520705 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C175444787 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C175983524 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C180456769 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C181622380 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C201650216 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C202269582 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C29122968 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C40700 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C46814582 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C54355233 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C60312476 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConcept C91306197 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConceptScore W2892360421C121398111 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConceptScore W2892360421C142470991 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConceptScore W2892360421C144133560 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConceptScore W2892360421C162324750 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConceptScore W2892360421C162853370 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConceptScore W2892360421C16520705 @default.
- W2892360421 hasConceptScore W2892360421C175444787 @default.