Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2902142885> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2902142885 endingPage "534" @default.
- W2902142885 startingPage "519" @default.
- W2902142885 abstract "Abstract. Applications of planktonic foraminifera in Quaternary palaeoceanographic and palaeobiological studies require consistency in species identification. Yet the degree of taxonomic consistency among the practitioners and the effects of any potential deviations on community structure metrics have never been quantitatively assessed. Here we present the results of an experiment in taxonomic consistency involving 21 researchers representing a range of experience and taxonomic schools from around the world. Participants were asked to identify the same two sets of 300 specimens from a modern subtropical North Atlantic sample, one sieved at >125 µm and one at > 150 µm. The identification was carried out either on actual specimens (slide test) or their digital images (digital test). The specimens were fixed so the identifications could be directly compared. In all tests, only between one-quarter and one-eighth of the specimens achieved absolute agreement. Therefore, the identifications across the participants were used to determine a consensus ID for each specimen. Since no strict consensus (>50 % agreement) could be achieved for 20–30 % of the specimens, we used a “soft consensus” based on the most common identification. The average percentage agreement relative to the consensus of the slide test was 77 % in the >150 µm and 69 % in the >125 µm test. These values were 7 % lower for the digital analyses. We find that taxonomic consistency is enhanced when researchers have been trained within a taxonomic school and when they regularly perform community analyses. There is an almost negligible effect of taxonomic inconsistency on sea surface temperature estimates based on transfer function conversion of the census counts, indicating the temperature signal in foraminiferal assemblages is correctly represented even if only two-thirds of the assemblage is consistently identified. The same does not apply to measures of diversity and community structure within the assemblage, and here we advise caution in using compound datasets for such studies. The decrease in the level of consistency when specimens are identified from digital images is significant and species-specific, with implications for the development of training sets for automated identification systems." @default.
- W2902142885 created "2018-12-11" @default.
- W2902142885 creator A5005369163 @default.
- W2902142885 creator A5010273563 @default.
- W2902142885 creator A5055731007 @default.
- W2902142885 creator A5077805126 @default.
- W2902142885 date "2018-12-04" @default.
- W2902142885 modified "2023-10-02" @default.
- W2902142885 title "Reproducibility of species recognition in modern planktonic foraminifera and its implications for analyses of community structure" @default.
- W2902142885 cites W156860856 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W1612072633 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W1979151693 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W1981860511 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2005912592 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2015058447 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2017428397 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2040248661 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2047717614 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2070780080 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2078952845 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2082816877 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2083447800 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2083653245 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2099053943 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2100858543 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2110214009 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2123497049 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2153184914 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2301967005 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2521289814 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2549605043 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2551309911 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2588957164 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2746290260 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2785337623 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2893931383 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W2939021178 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W4232403897 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W4236303627 @default.
- W2902142885 cites W4300141286 @default.
- W2902142885 doi "https://doi.org/10.5194/jm-37-519-2018" @default.
- W2902142885 hasPublicationYear "2018" @default.
- W2902142885 type Work @default.
- W2902142885 sameAs 2902142885 @default.
- W2902142885 citedByCount "11" @default.
- W2902142885 countsByYear W29021428852018 @default.
- W2902142885 countsByYear W29021428852019 @default.
- W2902142885 countsByYear W29021428852020 @default.
- W2902142885 countsByYear W29021428852021 @default.
- W2902142885 countsByYear W29021428852022 @default.
- W2902142885 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2902142885 hasAuthorship W2902142885A5005369163 @default.
- W2902142885 hasAuthorship W2902142885A5010273563 @default.
- W2902142885 hasAuthorship W2902142885A5055731007 @default.
- W2902142885 hasAuthorship W2902142885A5077805126 @default.
- W2902142885 hasBestOaLocation W29021428851 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C108469399 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C116834253 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C127313418 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C151730666 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C189592816 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C198531522 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C2776436953 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C2777267654 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C2780368712 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C2987826769 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C43617362 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C71640776 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C83042747 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C90856448 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConcept C9893847 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C105795698 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C108469399 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C116834253 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C127313418 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C151730666 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C154945302 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C185592680 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C18903297 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C189592816 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C198531522 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C2776436953 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C2777267654 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C2780368712 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C2987826769 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C33923547 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C41008148 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C43617362 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C71640776 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C83042747 @default.
- W2902142885 hasConceptScore W2902142885C86803240 @default.