Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2907566400> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2907566400 endingPage "1088" @default.
- W2907566400 startingPage "1021" @default.
- W2907566400 abstract "This article surveys the debate between “progressives” and “revisionists” about the Constitution and constitutional interpretation during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. Contemporary revisionist scholarship assumes that its victory over progressive scholarship is complete. The article suggests otherwise. First, it summarizes the revisionists’ achievements. Second, in an attempt to improve the quality of the debate, it maintains that “revisionist” and “progressive” legal historians undermine their cases by using words like “progressive,” “Gilded Age,” and “Jacksonian,” and that “revisionist” is not an enlightening term, either. Third, it contends that revisionists have made straw men out of the progressives, whose diversity and contributions they ignore, and that they have shown a lack of empathy for the circumstances facing the progressives. At considerable risk, progressives called attention to the relevance of political calculation, economic self-interest, and biography to understanding the Constitution, constitutional interpretation, and judicial power. The article also observes that revisionists have not yet won the day and that there are still “progressive” holdouts in the legal academy and history departments. Finally, it argues that like the work of “revisionists,” the scholarship of the “progressives”—particularly if we rechristen both—still has something to teach us and that it is time to abandon the familiar dialectic of thesis and antithesis and turn to synthesis." @default.
- W2907566400 created "2019-01-11" @default.
- W2907566400 creator A5025361259 @default.
- W2907566400 date "2018-11-01" @default.
- W2907566400 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W2907566400 title "In Defense of Progressive Legal Historiography" @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1550536548 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1596134073 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W171216559 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1966279416 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1969356697 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1977448560 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1985685616 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1990527782 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W1992569628 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2006947235 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2024102366 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2039345068 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2076546333 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2095425822 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2099986966 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2106005961 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2132513518 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2161542132 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2165022618 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2168123091 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2168285749 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2197961185 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2250276845 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2288462706 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2303621595 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2312193070 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2313258004 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2316139883 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2319860244 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2320267170 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2320728691 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2322037435 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2326640039 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2327093872 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2328775279 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2330885059 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2333376016 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2333695167 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2335070892 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2335419433 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2336762485 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2490382802 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2499507762 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2533020502 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2539434185 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2578468855 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2772988274 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2774945305 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2792092702 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2795432567 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2795470621 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2795493112 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2795670789 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2795837371 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2796045133 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2796182308 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2796409404 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2796697074 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2796799154 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2797626003 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2797788478 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2797850761 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2797872130 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2798241163 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2800173626 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2800556961 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2800598405 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2801102097 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2801466588 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W2801650097 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W3123663510 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W3124668433 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W3124740756 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W3162867165 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W417490461 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4206972352 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4207016137 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4214635178 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4229676575 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4230605688 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4231445928 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4231545372 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4234547186 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4237930813 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4241302527 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4244035258 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4246389899 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4248323293 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4248541855 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4252921298 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4297913568 @default.
- W2907566400 cites W4298453319 @default.