Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2912283062> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 62 of
62
with 100 items per page.
- W2912283062 abstract "In this chapter I evaluate the interrogative, interruptive, and constructive reasons for favouring dialogue between courts and legislatures in light of the contemporary republican political theory of the relationship between freedom and constitutionalism. First, dialogue might be valued as a means by which courts interrogatively distinguish justifiable reasons for legislatures to violate rights from violations unjustifiably made in pursuit of certain objectives by specific means. Second, dialogue could be valued as both a chance for courts to interrupt legislative processes or statutory schemes concerning rights, and for legislatures to deliberatively respond. Third, dialogue could be valued as a means by which courts and legislatures co-ordinately construct the legally indeterminate meaning of rights in a way that protects both rights and the democratic legitimacy of political decisions implicating rights. I argue that the republican conception of freedom from domination justifies constitutional construction as the ideal republican norm of dialogue between courts and legislatures concerning most rights. Interrogative dialogue increases the risk of domination by exhorting courts to engage in a form of political contestation better suited to ancient courts than to the independence and professionalism of modern judiciaries. It also delegitimizes legislative responsibility for rights. Interruptive dialogue solicits aggressive judicial review in ‘first look’ cases that minimizes the probability of legislative responses to unjust forms of adjudication, and thereby stifles the very dialogues it is supposed to provoke. In contrast, the norm of constructive dialogue will encourage courts to minimize the risk judicial review poses to political justice by using their institutional independence and professionalism to primarily enforce the determinate meaning of rights, while recognizing and respecting prospective legislative rights constructions. It will also promote the legislative duty to correct unjust adjudicative constructions." @default.
- W2912283062 created "2019-02-21" @default.
- W2912283062 creator A5054503476 @default.
- W2912283062 date "2018-01-01" @default.
- W2912283062 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W2912283062 title "On Dialogue and Domination" @default.
- W2912283062 cites W119147662 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W1534692698 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W1730714628 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W1995286705 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2026128696 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2034635248 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W204264699 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2042708466 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2100141527 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2127111523 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2132362227 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2152768038 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2156251571 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2160260097 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2164114380 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W222564579 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2255984055 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2333641999 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2335440893 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2795831841 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W3121238260 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W3122013505 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W3124281259 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W3124821802 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W3124890356 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W353457575 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W958324130 @default.
- W2912283062 cites W2607081250 @default.
- W2912283062 doi "https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3204817" @default.
- W2912283062 hasPublicationYear "2018" @default.
- W2912283062 type Work @default.
- W2912283062 sameAs 2912283062 @default.
- W2912283062 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2912283062 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2912283062 hasAuthorship W2912283062A5054503476 @default.
- W2912283062 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
- W2912283062 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2912283062 hasConceptScore W2912283062C144133560 @default.
- W2912283062 hasConceptScore W2912283062C17744445 @default.
- W2912283062 hasLocation W29122830621 @default.
- W2912283062 hasOpenAccess W2912283062 @default.
- W2912283062 hasPrimaryLocation W29122830621 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W1502603788 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2743539335 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2765153054 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2890326160 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2922049016 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2949263084 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W2955725829 @default.
- W2912283062 hasRelatedWork W594353338 @default.
- W2912283062 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2912283062 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W2912283062 magId "2912283062" @default.
- W2912283062 workType "article" @default.