Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2951267715> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2951267715 abstract "Einstein's philosophy of physics (as clarified by Fine, Howard, and Held) was predicated on his Trennungsprinzip, a combination of separability and locality, without which he believed objectification, and thereby physical thought and physical laws, to be impossible. Bohr's philosophy (as elucidated by Hooker, Scheibe, Folse, Howard, Held, and others), on the other hand, was grounded in a seemingly different doctrine about the possibility of objective knowledge, namely the necessity of classical concepts. In fact, it follows from Raggio's Theorem in algebraic quantum theory that - within an appropriate class of physical theories - suitable mathematical translations of the doctrines of Bohr and Einstein are equivalent. Thus - upon our specific formalization - quantum mechanics accommodates Einstein's Trennungsprinzip if and only if it is interpreted a la Bohr through classical physics. Unfortunately, the protagonists themselves failed to discuss their differences in this constructive way, since their debate was dominated by Einstein's ingenious but ultimately flawed attempts to establish the incompleteness of quantum mechanics. This aspect of their debate may still be understood and appreciated, however, as reflecting a much deeper and insurmountable disagreement between Bohr and Einstein on the knowability of Nature. Using the theological controversy on the knowability of God as a analogy, Einstein was a Spinozist, whereas Bohr could be said to be on the side of Maimonides. Thus Einstein's off-the-cuff characterization of Bohr as a 'Talmudic philosopher' was spot-on." @default.
- W2951267715 created "2019-06-27" @default.
- W2951267715 creator A5060266645 @default.
- W2951267715 date "2005-07-22" @default.
- W2951267715 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W2951267715 title "When champions meet: Rethinking the Bohr--Einstein debate" @default.
- W2951267715 cites W103251751 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W134905022 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1487583654 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1488108030 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1489432724 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1496144344 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1516291783 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1523306063 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1524878283 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1525305151 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1537230236 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1539551388 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1553336703 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1560127599 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1571905937 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1576369095 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1593645531 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1640838638 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W179612363 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1966723961 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1967300267 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1970216613 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1973260862 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1973827495 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1979721696 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1986407511 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1988702282 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1990783708 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W1993262329 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2007386768 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2007433315 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2011273205 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2014306526 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2017156903 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2024812083 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2025822198 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2026842393 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2028284547 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2028815089 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2037848891 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2039004790 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2043112166 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2045220263 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2050427166 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2052140519 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2057403487 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2060199709 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2061879260 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2062292260 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2063050258 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2063900882 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2072648388 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2073251344 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2076311580 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2077182397 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2079820736 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2081717153 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2083105798 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2083318022 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2084883086 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2088992522 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2093708734 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2094185263 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2095492360 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2105750617 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2113248633 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2120334388 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2122187744 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2140458659 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2159483213 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2166754732 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2170314933 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2181392137 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2317349704 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2321294936 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2334808205 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2465012628 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2493135646 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2498006950 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2592282483 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2736770142 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2741582595 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2798424158 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W292526932 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W2950660935 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W3000632564 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W3003547482 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W3003585633 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W3004253287 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W3046321410 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W3103878769 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W3152341702 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W563133457 @default.
- W2951267715 cites W568971781 @default.