Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2952022350> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2952022350 endingPage "229" @default.
- W2952022350 startingPage "219" @default.
- W2952022350 abstract "Is sentence structure processed by the same neural and cognitive resources that are recruited for processing word meanings, or do structure and meaning rely on distinct resources? Linguistic theorizing and much behavioral evidence suggest tight integration between lexico-semantic and syntactic representations and processing. However, most current proposals of the neural architecture of language continue to postulate a distinction between the two. One of the earlier and most cited pieces of neuroimaging evidence in favor of this dissociation comes from a paper by Dapretto and Bookheimer (1999). Using a sentence-meaning judgment task, Dapretto & Bookheimer observed two distinct peaks within the left inferior frontal gyrus (LIFG): one was more active during a lexico-semantic manipulation, and the other during a syntactic manipulation. Although the paper is highly cited, no attempt has been made, to our knowledge, to replicate the original finding. We report an fMRI study that attempts to do so. Using a combination of whole-brain, group-level ROI, and participant-specific functional ROI approaches, we fail to replicate the original dissociation. In particular, whereas parts of LIFG respond reliably more strongly during lexico-semantic than syntactic processing, no part of LIFG (including in the region defined around the peak reported by Dapretto & Bookheimer) shows the opposite pattern. We speculate that the original result was a false positive, possibly driven by a small subset of participants or items that biased a fixed-effects analysis with low power." @default.
- W2952022350 created "2019-06-27" @default.
- W2952022350 creator A5047790343 @default.
- W2952022350 creator A5059103699 @default.
- W2952022350 creator A5081808595 @default.
- W2952022350 creator A5089035587 @default.
- W2952022350 date "2019-08-01" @default.
- W2952022350 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W2952022350 title "An Attempt to Conceptually Replicate the Dissociation between Syntax and Semantics during Sentence Comprehension" @default.
- W2952022350 cites W1897139626 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W1964446421 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W1985086416 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W1998648231 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2001559660 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2002931462 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2005177046 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2011804471 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2021458971 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2034396283 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2041874498 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2044147483 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2056306065 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2058046532 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2067946228 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2080238849 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2080926857 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2084332617 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2091437289 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2095827013 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2105824687 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2105962878 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2111929696 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2115442027 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2118838987 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2119150045 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2119303750 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2122538793 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2124397031 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2127030549 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2128246772 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2130680620 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2132684680 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2135493578 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2138017345 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2141138276 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2144981148 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2146042128 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2151509224 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2155034734 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2156663106 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2159203203 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2159521998 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2161498332 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2161632259 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2171045029 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2172056482 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2186059026 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2298178961 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2469338186 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2526072446 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2571093196 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2889622349 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2937302049 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2950618309 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2952384350 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W2992008956 @default.
- W2952022350 cites W615893297 @default.
- W2952022350 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroscience.2019.06.003" @default.
- W2952022350 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/6661197" @default.
- W2952022350 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31200104" @default.
- W2952022350 hasPublicationYear "2019" @default.
- W2952022350 type Work @default.
- W2952022350 sameAs 2952022350 @default.
- W2952022350 citedByCount "20" @default.
- W2952022350 countsByYear W29520223502018 @default.
- W2952022350 countsByYear W29520223502019 @default.
- W2952022350 countsByYear W29520223502020 @default.
- W2952022350 countsByYear W29520223502021 @default.
- W2952022350 countsByYear W29520223502022 @default.
- W2952022350 countsByYear W29520223502023 @default.
- W2952022350 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2952022350 hasAuthorship W2952022350A5047790343 @default.
- W2952022350 hasAuthorship W2952022350A5059103699 @default.
- W2952022350 hasAuthorship W2952022350A5081808595 @default.
- W2952022350 hasAuthorship W2952022350A5089035587 @default.
- W2952022350 hasBestOaLocation W29520223501 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C102931765 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C147789679 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C169760540 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C169900460 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C184337299 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C197914299 @default.
- W2952022350 hasConcept C199360897 @default.