Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2969852316> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2969852316 abstract "Coral reef ecosystems have suffered an unprecedented loss of habitat-forming hard corals in recent decades, due to increased nutrient outputs from agriculture, elevated levels of suspended sediment caused by deforestation and development, destructive fishing practices, over-harvesting of reef species, outbreaks of corallivorous crown-of-thorns starfish (COTS, Acanthaster planci), coral disease and tropical storms. However, in recent years climate change has emerged as the primary threat to coral reefs. While reefs have a natural capacity for recovery, recurring events like mass coral bleaching and extreme weather events is increasing in frequency, intensity and severity, and are eroding the time for recovery between catastrophic events.Marine conservation has primarily focused on passive habitat protection over active restoration, in contrast to terrestrial ecosystems where active restoration is common practice. Further, active restoration is well accepted for wetlands and shellfish reefs however coral reef restoration has remained controversial both in academia and amongst marine managers. This is despite recent research suggesting that optimal conservation outcomes include both habitat protection and restoration. Critics often argue that coral restoration detracts focus from mitigating climate change and other threats to the marine environment, while proponents of coral restoration counter that interventions can serve to protect coral biodiversity and endangered species in the short-term, while mitigation of large-scale threats such as climate change and water quality take effect. Despite this disconnect between coral restoration practitioners, coral reef managers and scientists, active coral restoration is increasingly used as a tool to attempt to restore coral populations.The field has largely developed through independent work of isolated groups, and has fallen victim to ‘growing pains’ associated with ecological restoration in many other ecosystems. Partly this is due to a reluctance to share outcomes of projects, and in some cases a lack of monitoring or appropriate reporting of project outcomes. To mitigate this, we aimed to synthesise the available knowledge in a comprehensive global review of coral restoration methods, incorporating data from a traditional literature search of the scientific literature, complemented with information gathered from online sources and through a survey of coral restoration practitioners.We identified 329 case studies on coral restoration, of which 195 were from the scientific literature, 79 were sourced from the grey literature (i.e. reports and online descriptions), and 55 were responses to our survey of restoration practitioners. We identified ten coral restoration intervention types: coral gardening - transplantation phase (23% of records), direct transplantation (21%), artificial reefs (19%), coral gardening - nursery phase (17%), coral gardening (both phases, 7%), substrate enhancement with electricity (4%), substrate stabilisation (4%), algae removal (2%), larval enhancement (1%) and microfragmentation (<1%). The majority of interventions involve coral fragmentation or transplantation of coral fragments (70%). While 52 countries are represented in the dataset, the majority of projects were conducted in the USA, Philippines, Thailand and Indonesia (together representing 40% of projects).Coral restoration case studies are dominated by short-term projects, with 66% of all projects reporting less than 18 months of monitoring of the restored sites. Overall, the median length of projects was 12 months. Similarly, most projects are relatively small in spatial scale, with a median size of restored area of 500 m2. A diverse range of species are represented in the dataset, with 221 different species from 89 coral genera. Overall, coral restoration projects focused primarily (65% of studies) on fast-growing branching corals. Among all the published documents, the top five species (22% of studies) were Acropora cervicornis, Pocillopora damicornis, Stylophora pistillata, Porites cylindrica and Acropora palmata. Over a quarter of projects (26%) involved the coral genus Acropora, while 9% of studies included a single species - Acropora cervicornis. Much of the focus on Acropora cervicornis and Acropora palmata is likely to have resulted from these important reef-forming species being listed as threatened on the United States Endangered Species List and as Endangered on the International Union for Conservation of Nature Red List of Endangered Species (IUCN 2018).We have dedicated a section to each intervention type covered in this review, and describe the potential and limitations of each intervention type in detail there. However, collating this information has highlighted the following main points which apply to coral restoration in general.1. On average, survival in restored corals is relatively high. All coral genera with sufficient replication from which to draw conclusions (>10 studies listing that genus) report an average survival between 60-70%.2. Differences in survival and growth are largely species and/or location specific, so the selection of specific methods should be tailored to the local conditions, costs, availability of materials, and to the specific objectives of each project.3. Projects are overall small and short, however substantial scaling up is required for restoration to be a useful tool in supporting the persistence of reefs in the future. While there is ample evidence detailing how to successfully grow corals at smaller scales, few interventions demonstrate a capacity to be scaled up much beyond one hectare. Notable exceptions include methods which propagate sexually derived coral larvae.4. To date, coral restoration has been plagued by the same common problems as ecological restoration in other ecosystems. Mitigating these will be crucial to successfully scale up projects, and to retain public trust in restoration as a tool for resilience based management.a. Lack of clear objectives - There is a clear mismatch between the stated objectives of projects, and the design of projects and monitoring of outcomes. Poorly articulated or overinflated objectives risk alienating the general public and scientists, by over-promising and under-delivering. Social and economic objectives have inherent value and do not need to be disguised with ecological objectives.b. Lack of appropriate monitoring - A large proportion of projects do not monitor metrics relevant to their stated objectives, or do not continue monitoring for long enough to provide meaningful estimates of success. Further, there is a clear need for standardisation in the metrics that are used, to allow comparisons between projects.c. Lack of appropriate reporting - The outcomes of a large proportion of projects are not documented, which restricts knowledge-sharing and adaptive learning.While we attempted to access some of the unreported projects through our survey, it is clear we have only scratched the surface of existing knowledge.d. Poorly designed projects - An effect of inadequate monitoring and reporting is that projects are poorly suited to their specific area and conditions. Improved knowledge-sharing and development of best practice coral restorationguidelines aims to mitigate this problem." @default.
- W2969852316 created "2019-08-29" @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5007073406 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5008847384 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5019231447 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5021573645 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5026647542 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5030882809 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5031988136 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5048736411 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5069563384 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5083343579 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5088267542 @default.
- W2969852316 creator A5089722586 @default.
- W2969852316 date "2018-01-01" @default.
- W2969852316 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W2969852316 title "Coral restoration in a changing world - a global synthesis of methods and techniques" @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1254726485 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1496907749 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1684654919 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1756663532 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1792799016 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1849969096 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1972497981 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1975176287 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1976924989 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1979003342 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1980912979 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1986803742 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1988009996 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1990134481 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1991462310 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1997679436 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W1997896258 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2000085386 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2007903264 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2010614057 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2011130662 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2011806055 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2017008898 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2018553250 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2019211268 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2020975167 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2025328010 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2026758819 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2029529982 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2036638094 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2038158566 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2043724942 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2050098937 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2052711114 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2054171341 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2057524613 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2059516571 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2068226428 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2068515278 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2069864946 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2071348830 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2075913146 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2080455768 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2082631411 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2083901411 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2086993800 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2089455986 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2100216289 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2107228627 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2109870801 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2111871301 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2115484152 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2115568441 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2116361142 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2123920115 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2132804105 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2134401898 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2138993262 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2138995156 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2139359979 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2139946011 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2140788514 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2140913808 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2141365420 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2147807123 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2148744658 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2160571481 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2164557179 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2165449317 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2166377141 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2168251275 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2168261061 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2172275656 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2187285051 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2188705206 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2217513613 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2272130757 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2285399076 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2287156250 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2318418663 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2334780982 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2341328186 @default.
- W2969852316 cites W2462368912 @default.