Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2972082360> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2972082360 abstract "Whether perception involves the manipulation of representations is currently heavily debated. The embedded view (EV) advanced by Nico Orlandi seeks a middle passage between representationalism and radical enactivism. In this paper I argue for a non-representational take on EV. I argue that this is the best way to resolve the objections EV has received from both representationalists and non-representationalists. I analyze this debate, and distinguish four sorts of objections: (1) the objection of the wrongfully cut middleman, (2) the argument against explanatory exclusionism, (3) the case for scientific benefits of representations, and (4) the charge of inconsistent ascription of representational status in EV. I argue that (1) the middleman was never cut in EV, and is controversial to boot, (2) otherwise equal, non-representational explanations have primacy over representational explanations, due to the lack of naturalistic grounds for representations and the unnecessarily ascribed cognitive load to the system. Further, I show that (3) puts the cart before the horse, and the arguments on offer are viciously circular. However, the final objection, (4) lays bare a deeper issue for EV. At the cost of giving up the middle position, however, the explanatory tools already available to EV can be shown to cover the work initially thought to require representation. I conclude that EV is best altered to be a non-representational theory of perception." @default.
- W2972082360 created "2019-09-12" @default.
- W2972082360 creator A5047963874 @default.
- W2972082360 date "2019-09-05" @default.
- W2972082360 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W2972082360 title "The embedded view, its critics, and a radically non-representational solution" @default.
- W2972082360 cites W1581461482 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W1993871138 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2067016625 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2067266304 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2109995759 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2121393203 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2124813663 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2150013078 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2154681601 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2262489537 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2293161890 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2316652185 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2319537798 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2391599638 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2397253692 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2534098824 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2604355768 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2810408525 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W2942978497 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W3001991410 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4212947750 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4231257775 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4231563569 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4232099485 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4236697611 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4241976975 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4244205768 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4244629008 @default.
- W2972082360 cites W4247883378 @default.
- W2972082360 doi "https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-019-02385-5" @default.
- W2972082360 hasPublicationYear "2019" @default.
- W2972082360 type Work @default.
- W2972082360 sameAs 2972082360 @default.
- W2972082360 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2972082360 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2972082360 hasAuthorship W2972082360A5047963874 @default.
- W2972082360 hasBestOaLocation W29720823602 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C100609095 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C110099512 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C123556308 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C168072608 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C182744844 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C198087647 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C24726157 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C26760741 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C2776359362 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C2777407727 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C2779279129 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C34048319 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C43236755 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConcept C98184364 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C100609095 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C110099512 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C111472728 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C123556308 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C138885662 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C144024400 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C168072608 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C17744445 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C182744844 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C185592680 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C198087647 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C199539241 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C24726157 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C26760741 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C2776359362 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C2777407727 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C2779279129 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C34048319 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C43236755 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C55493867 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C94625758 @default.
- W2972082360 hasConceptScore W2972082360C98184364 @default.
- W2972082360 hasLocation W29720823601 @default.
- W2972082360 hasLocation W29720823602 @default.
- W2972082360 hasOpenAccess W2972082360 @default.
- W2972082360 hasPrimaryLocation W29720823601 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W11050434 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W14573932 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W15121390 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W16702417 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W18471846 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W18734749 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W19699012 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W24120419 @default.
- W2972082360 hasRelatedWork W4000052 @default.