FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2984555626> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2984555626 endingPage "e2425" @default.
• W2984555626 startingPage "e2425" @default.
• W2984555626 abstract "Currently, there are more than 40 cases of facial allotransplantation performed by 13 different groups in 10 countries. Although it has become a potential option to reconstruct and restore the function and appearance of severely facially disfigured individuals, the ethical concerns of facial allotransplantation remain unsolved. We conducted a systematic review to better understand the ethical concerns on facial allotransplantation and the changing trends of the ethical debate over time.A systematic review of 3 databases was performed to identify articles related to ethical topics on facial allotransplantation. The inclusion criteria were peer-reviewed articles written since 1995 on the topics of ethics and facial allotransplantation in English, French, and Chinese languages. The ethical concerns extracted from the included articles were categorized into 4 core principles of ethics: autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice. The different themes under these 4 principles were extracted and subgrouped. The positions of the included articles were collected. Joinpoint regression was applied to compare the frequency of themes and positions by publication year. We presented the main topics on ethical concerns and the changing trends in ethical themes and principles of facial allotransplantation.There were 889 articles identified initially. After excluding 265 duplicated articles, 624 articles were included for title/abstract review process, and 148 articles were included in final data analysis. The publication year was from 2002 to 2018 with 136 articles in English, 11 in French, and 1 in Chinese. The most addressed principle was nonmaleficence (117/148, 79.1%), followed by beneficence (116/148, 78.4%), justice (103/148, 69.6%), and autonomy (86/148, 58.1%). The themes on immunosuppression/rejection, quality of life, and identity were the top 3 addressed ethical concerns. Twelve of 13 most addressed ethical themes demonstrated a decreasing trend after 2004. The themes of identity under beneficence showed a significant decrease after 2004. Ethical concerns on the cost/financial topic were the only one showing consistently increase trends from 2002 to 2018. There was a significant increase of the papers in favor of facial allotransplantation procedure comparing to those were against or neutral before and after 2008.More and more articles support facial allotransplantation as a feasible option to reconstruct and restore the function and appearance of severely facially disfigured individuals. The requirement of life-long immunosuppression therapy, quality of life, and identity center the ethical debates. Supported by favorable short-term results, 12 of 13 most addressed ethical concerns have trended down. The theme of cost/financial topic becomes more frequently addressed in recent years." @default.
• W2984555626 created "2019-11-22" @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5004247371 @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5010240559 @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5031302291 @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5036118060 @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5036358906 @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5048419560 @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5088069091 @default.
• W2984555626 creator A5090387818 @default.
• W2984555626 date "2019-10-01" @default.
• W2984555626 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
• W2984555626 title "The Ethics of Facial Allotransplantation: A Systematic Review" @default.
• W2984555626 cites W121703426 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W133973328 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W142421330 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1528621879 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1594930388 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1728707909 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W184349925 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W191990517 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1964289081 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1965470918 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1973896688 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1977771626 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1980710526 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1981353214 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1983589390 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1983626252 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1984247160 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1985267644 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1991896321 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1992291225 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1992373657 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1992460455 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1993844387 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1994111061 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1999399281 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W1999788681 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2000045021 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2006365962 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2009362204 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2012426969 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2013230504 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2013279891 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2015498025 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2019541583 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2020645994 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2022158834 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2023577731 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2027939818 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2033825316 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2034918287 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2034962255 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2036099696 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2040508578 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2045217379 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2045418945 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2046490005 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2047240705 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2047430642 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2048358012 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2050438371 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2050951525 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2051766043 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2053422760 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2055800571 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2056708167 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2056948451 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2058066174 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2059617178 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2060487753 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2063881874 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2064882989 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2067126118 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2067432359 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2067634930 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2068632011 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2070059706 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2070356784 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2070710675 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2071046943 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2073137654 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2073822242 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2074313140 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2076083600 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2076664928 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2077293970 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2079111657 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2080842067 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2082454132 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2085415360 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2088594392 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2090310916 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2091775009 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2091864027 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2091944098 @default.
• W2984555626 cites W2092763476 @default.

• next