Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2984704820> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2984704820 endingPage "340" @default.
- W2984704820 startingPage "322" @default.
- W2984704820 abstract "Contemporary phylogenomic studies frequently incorporate two-step coalescent analyses wherein the first step is to infer individual-gene trees, generally using maximum-likelihood implemented in the popular programs PhyML or RAxML. Four concerns with this approach are that these programs only present a single fully resolved gene tree to the user despite potential for ambiguous support, insufficient phylogenetic signal to fully resolve each gene tree, inexact computer arithmetic affecting the reported likelihood of gene trees, and an exclusive focus on the most likely tree while ignoring trees that are only slightly suboptimal or within the error tolerance. Taken together, these four concerns are sufficient for RAxML and PhyML users to be suspicious of the resulting (perhaps over-resolved) gene-tree topologies and (perhaps unjustifiably high) bootstrap support for individual clades. In this study, we sought to determine how frequently these concerns apply in practice to contemporary phylogenomic studies that use RAxML for gene-tree inference. We did so by re-analyzing 100 genes from each of ten studies that, taken together, are representative of many empirical phylogenomic studies. Our seven findings are as follows. First, the few search replicates that are frequently applied in phylogenomic studies are generally insufficient to find the optimal gene-tree topology. Second, there is often more topological variation among slightly suboptimal gene trees relative to the best-reported tree than can be safely ignored. Third, the Shimodaira-Hasegawa-like approximate likelihood ratio test is highly effective at identifying dubiously supported clades and outperforms the alternative approaches of relying on bootstrap support or collapsing minimum-length branches. Fourth, the bootstrap can, but rarely does, indicate high support for clades that are not supported amongst slightly suboptimal trees. Fifth, increasing the accuracy by which RAxML optimizes model-parameter values generally has a nominal effect on selection of optimal trees. Sixth, tree searches using the GTRCAT model were generally less effective at finding optimal known trees than those using the GTRGAMMA model. Seventh, choice of gene-tree sampling strategy can affect inferred coalescent branch lengths, species-tree topology and branch support." @default.
- W2984704820 created "2019-11-22" @default.
- W2984704820 creator A5002415472 @default.
- W2984704820 creator A5044684880 @default.
- W2984704820 date "2019-11-13" @default.
- W2984704820 modified "2023-09-30" @default.
- W2984704820 title "Divergence and support among slightly suboptimal likelihood gene trees" @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1782752371 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1924404512 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1973132881 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1975627255 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1975933692 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1976463659 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1984965430 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1986215701 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1993371508 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1993386195 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W1997995045 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2005238069 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2013277649 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2032227091 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2032476979 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2043887813 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2050715005 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2060425093 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2068102276 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2072802546 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2074077385 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2078210212 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2082519741 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2095707727 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2098448352 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2099459260 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2103546861 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2106814707 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2108039804 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2111211467 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2112702412 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2112956791 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2113093080 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2117752525 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2119428521 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2119837484 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2122240788 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2124260482 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2125024684 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2127847431 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2141052558 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2145562754 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2146604274 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2149351619 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2149557149 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2150270014 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2156524622 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2157701114 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2162240971 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2166432938 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2168696662 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2169004268 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2176633348 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2228868916 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2277574918 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2287086557 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2516981117 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2517856198 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2560068051 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2769035431 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2779929400 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2889958510 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2949571567 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2951367039 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2952543493 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W2963090447 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W4230662788 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W4231338500 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W4231784440 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W4236667340 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W4362073016 @default.
- W2984704820 cites W72659274 @default.
- W2984704820 doi "https://doi.org/10.1111/cla.12404" @default.
- W2984704820 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34618962" @default.
- W2984704820 hasPublicationYear "2019" @default.
- W2984704820 type Work @default.
- W2984704820 sameAs 2984704820 @default.
- W2984704820 citedByCount "18" @default.
- W2984704820 countsByYear W29847048202019 @default.
- W2984704820 countsByYear W29847048202020 @default.
- W2984704820 countsByYear W29847048202021 @default.
- W2984704820 countsByYear W29847048202022 @default.
- W2984704820 countsByYear W29847048202023 @default.
- W2984704820 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2984704820 hasAuthorship W2984704820A5002415472 @default.
- W2984704820 hasAuthorship W2984704820A5044684880 @default.
- W2984704820 hasBestOaLocation W29847048201 @default.
- W2984704820 hasConcept C104317684 @default.
- W2984704820 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2984704820 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
- W2984704820 hasConcept C113174947 @default.