FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2988137462> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2988137462 abstract "This study examines whether there is any evidence of bias in two areas of common critique of open, non-anonymous peer review - and used in the post-publication, peer review system operated by the open-access scholarly publishing platform F1000Research. First, is there evidence of bias where a reviewer based in a specific country assesses the work of an author also based in the same country? Second, are reviewers influenced by being able to see the comments and know the origins of previous reviewer? Methods: Scrutinising the open peer review comments published on F1000Research, we assess the extent of two frequently cited potential influences on reviewers that may be the result of the transparency offered by a fully attributable, open peer review publishing model: the national affiliations of authors and reviewers, and the ability of reviewers to view previously-published reviewer reports before submitting their own. The effects of these potential influences were investigated for all first versions of articles published by 8 July 2019 to F1000Research. In 16 out of the 20 countries with the most articles, there was a tendency for reviewers based in the same country to give a more positive review. The difference was statistically significant in one. Only 3 countries had the reverse tendency. Second, there is no evidence of a conformity bias. When reviewers mentioned a previous review in their peer review report, they were not more likely to give the same overall judgement. Although reviewers who had longer to potentially read a previously published reviewer reports were slightly less likely to agree with previous reviewer judgements, this could be due to these articles being difficult to judge rather than deliberate non-conformity." @default.
• W2988137462 created "2019-11-22" @default.
• W2988137462 creator A5008376826 @default.
• W2988137462 creator A5018077373 @default.
• W2988137462 creator A5028344006 @default.
• W2988137462 creator A5036549394 @default.
• W2988137462 creator A5050724603 @default.
• W2988137462 date "2019-11-08" @default.
• W2988137462 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
• W2988137462 title "Does the use of open, non-anonymous peer review in scholarly publishing introduce bias? Evidence from the F1000 post-publication open peer review publishing model." @default.
• W2988137462 cites W1924530614 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W1985282759 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W1997871319 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2035064966 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2041212401 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2041312511 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2051213584 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2095455968 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2102073367 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2110065044 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2117427611 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2167023602 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2171827218 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2217131821 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2235693693 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2468587249 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2494624856 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2737578613 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2744378798 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2751377575 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2771841635 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2800174757 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2913543586 @default.
• W2988137462 cites W2964481132 @default.
• W2988137462 hasPublicationYear "2019" @default.
• W2988137462 type Work @default.
• W2988137462 sameAs 2988137462 @default.
• W2988137462 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2988137462 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
• W2988137462 hasAuthorship W2988137462A5008376826 @default.
• W2988137462 hasAuthorship W2988137462A5018077373 @default.
• W2988137462 hasAuthorship W2988137462A5028344006 @default.
• W2988137462 hasAuthorship W2988137462A5036549394 @default.
• W2988137462 hasAuthorship W2988137462A5050724603 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C138368954 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C142172996 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C151719136 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C2776548248 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C2779473830 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C2780233690 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C2780439572 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C2983643791 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C2992936677 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C59822182 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C138368954 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C142172996 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C151719136 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C15744967 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C17744445 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C199539241 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C2776548248 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C2779473830 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C2780233690 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C2780439572 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C2983643791 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C2992936677 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C59822182 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C77805123 @default.
• W2988137462 hasConceptScore W2988137462C86803240 @default.
• W2988137462 hasLocation W29881374621 @default.
• W2988137462 hasOpenAccess W2988137462 @default.
• W2988137462 hasPrimaryLocation W29881374621 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W1978744472 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W1999169975 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2078419756 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2091132249 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2116807595 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2133386222 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2134138525 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2145330119 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2171155114 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2289507146 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W235954254 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2404417369 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2466575548 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2528465189 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2775954490 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W2999347516 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W3110502424 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W3171118250 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W3189815579 @default.
• W2988137462 hasRelatedWork W3196652917 @default.
• W2988137462 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2988137462 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2988137462 magId "2988137462" @default.

• next