Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3011309374> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3011309374 endingPage "1759" @default.
- W3011309374 startingPage "1737" @default.
- W3011309374 abstract "To evaluate all simulation models for ophthalmology technical and non-technical skills training and the strength of evidence to support their validity and effectiveness. A systematic search was performed using PubMed and Embase for studies published from inception to 01/07/2019. Studies were analysed according to the training modality: virtual reality; wet-lab; dry-lab models; e-learning. The educational impact of studies was evaluated using Messick’s validity framework and McGaghie’s model of translational outcomes for evaluating effectiveness. One hundred and thirty-one studies were included in this review, with 93 different simulators described. Fifty-three studies were based on virtual reality tools; 47 on wet-lab models; 26 on dry-lab models; 5 on e-learning. Only two studies provided evidence for all five sources of validity assessment. Models with the strongest validity evidence were the Eyesi Surgical, Eyesi Direct Ophthalmoscope and Eye Surgical Skills Assessment Test. Effectiveness ratings for simulator models were mostly limited to level 2 (contained effects) with the exception of the Sophocle vitreoretinal surgery simulator, which was shown at level 3 (downstream effects), and the Eyesi at level 5 (target effects) for cataract surgery. A wide range of models have been described but only the Eyesi has undergone comprehensive investigation. The main weakness is in the poor quality of study design, with a predominance of descriptive reports showing limited validity evidence and few studies investigating the effects of simulation training on patient outcomes. More robust research is needed to enable effective implementation of simulation tools into current training curriculums." @default.
- W3011309374 created "2020-03-23" @default.
- W3011309374 creator A5006241226 @default.
- W3011309374 creator A5006774773 @default.
- W3011309374 creator A5011548789 @default.
- W3011309374 creator A5073256560 @default.
- W3011309374 creator A5077507972 @default.
- W3011309374 creator A5084897373 @default.
- W3011309374 creator A5090902762 @default.
- W3011309374 date "2020-03-13" @default.
- W3011309374 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
- W3011309374 title "A systematic review of simulation-based training tools for technical and non-technical skills in ophthalmology" @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1487015250 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1550098617 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1552768064 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1555635764 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1568147942 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1581109557 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1604149165 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1824602886 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1826967190 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1837088267 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1840100415 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1909433792 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1965136330 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1966446404 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1967822500 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1967878896 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1968833084 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1969367567 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1970070629 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1973030015 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1975166706 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1979231270 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1981735799 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1982640191 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1992606000 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1993330821 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1996895029 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1997255658 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1997746034 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W1999246721 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2001994157 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2008398398 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2010461950 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2010829175 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2014438817 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2023058304 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2024625663 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2025645458 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2029241722 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2029431906 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2030787641 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2032961468 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2033449043 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2033906145 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2034403998 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2036244887 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2036272720 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2039339560 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2040154864 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2047584427 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2055173528 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2055406596 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2055870386 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2057225722 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2059259770 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2062962661 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2064983030 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2065458416 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2068341115 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2069907313 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2070436752 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2070772884 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2074273032 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2076667760 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2077273459 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2078266791 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2079297510 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2079483674 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2080506440 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2081882508 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2083231893 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2084325528 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2085487772 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2086863187 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2088026613 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2089853158 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2090278850 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2091390702 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2094238582 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2094292412 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2094417435 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2102109440 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2105467770 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2118372425 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2121719763 @default.
- W3011309374 cites W2122805150 @default.