Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3012246182> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3012246182 endingPage "7567" @default.
- W3012246182 startingPage "7561" @default.
- W3012246182 abstract "Crises in science concern not only methods, statistics, and results but also, theory development. Beyond the indispensable refinement of tools and procedures, resolving crises would also benefit from a deeper understanding of the concepts and processes guiding research. Usually, theories compete, and some lose, incentivizing destruction of seemingly opposing views. This does not necessarily contribute to accumulating insights, and it may incur collateral damage (e.g., impairing cognitive processes and collegial relations). To develop a more constructive model, we built on adversarial collaboration, which integrates incompatible results into agreed-on new empirical research to test competing hypotheses [D. Kahneman, Am. Psychol. 58, 723–730 (2003)]. Applying theory and evidence from the behavioral sciences, we address the group dynamic complexities of adversarial interactions between scientists. We illustrate the added value of considering these in an “adversarial alignment” that addressed competing conceptual frameworks from five different theories of social evaluation. Negotiating a joint framework required two preconditions and several guidelines. First, we reframed our interactions from competitive rivalry to cooperative pursuit of a joint goal, and second, we assumed scientific competence and good intentions, enabling cooperation toward that goal. Then, we applied five rules for successful multiparty negotiations: 1) leveling the playing field, 2) capitalizing on curiosity, 3) producing measurable progress, 4) working toward mutual gain, and 5) being aware of the downside alternative. Together, these guidelines can encourage others to create conditions that allow for theoretical alignments and develop cumulative science." @default.
- W3012246182 created "2020-03-23" @default.
- W3012246182 creator A5007830440 @default.
- W3012246182 creator A5042092337 @default.
- W3012246182 creator A5046786525 @default.
- W3012246182 creator A5067477814 @default.
- W3012246182 creator A5080791781 @default.
- W3012246182 date "2020-03-13" @default.
- W3012246182 modified "2023-10-03" @default.
- W3012246182 title "Adversarial alignment enables competing models to engage in cooperative theory building toward cumulative science" @default.
- W3012246182 cites W1602643802 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W1818536883 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W1858115704 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W1993609373 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2022154998 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2037725716 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2038638838 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2054076995 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2057659248 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2057748516 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2058584057 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2060127052 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2073020783 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2091175956 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2096411586 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2109453861 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2118544600 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2119114901 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2120349889 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2142553778 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2146941608 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2148019323 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2165753747 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2171882928 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2248732222 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2362912888 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2387324665 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2416809066 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2497046050 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2525687297 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2750388580 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2789560769 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2789706100 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2791423782 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2792819737 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2811276689 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2909699495 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2913939165 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2937214313 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W2950959976 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W3163012965 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W4235026501 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W4235548065 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W4237327899 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W4245509029 @default.
- W3012246182 cites W4252665401 @default.
- W3012246182 doi "https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1906720117" @default.
- W3012246182 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/7148555" @default.
- W3012246182 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32170010" @default.
- W3012246182 hasPublicationYear "2020" @default.
- W3012246182 type Work @default.
- W3012246182 sameAs 3012246182 @default.
- W3012246182 citedByCount "25" @default.
- W3012246182 countsByYear W30122461822020 @default.
- W3012246182 countsByYear W30122461822021 @default.
- W3012246182 countsByYear W30122461822022 @default.
- W3012246182 countsByYear W30122461822023 @default.
- W3012246182 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3012246182 hasAuthorship W3012246182A5007830440 @default.
- W3012246182 hasAuthorship W3012246182A5042092337 @default.
- W3012246182 hasAuthorship W3012246182A5046786525 @default.
- W3012246182 hasAuthorship W3012246182A5067477814 @default.
- W3012246182 hasAuthorship W3012246182A5080791781 @default.
- W3012246182 hasBestOaLocation W30122461821 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C100521375 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C14224292 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C175444787 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C199776023 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C2778701210 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C2779602485 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C33435437 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C37736160 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C539667460 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConcept C98045186 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConceptScore W3012246182C100521375 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConceptScore W3012246182C111472728 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConceptScore W3012246182C111919701 @default.
- W3012246182 hasConceptScore W3012246182C138885662 @default.