Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3014234566> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3014234566 endingPage "1513" @default.
- W3014234566 startingPage "1501" @default.
- W3014234566 abstract "It has recently been reported how to quantify inter-individual differences in the response to an exercise intervention using the standard deviation of the change scores, as well as how to appraise these differences for clinical relevance. In a parallel-group randomised controlled trial, the key trigger for further investigation into inter-individual responses is when the standard deviation of change in the intervention sample is substantially larger than the same standard deviation derived from a suitable comparator sample. ‘True’ and clinically relevant inter-individual differences in response can then be plausibly expected, and potential moderators and mediators of the inter-individual differences can be explored. We now aim to critically review the research on the inter-individual differences in response to exercise training, focusing on maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max). A literature search through the relevant bibliographic databases resulted in the identification of six relevant studies that were published prior to the influential HEalth, RIsk factors, exercise Training And GEnetics (HERITAGE) Family Study. Only one of these studies was found to include a comparator arm. Re-analysis of the data from this study, accounting for random within-subjects variation, revealed an absence of clinically important inter-individual differences in the response of VO2max to exercise training. The standard deviation of change was, in fact, larger (±5.6 mL/kg/min) for the comparator than the intervention group (±3.7 mL/kg/min). We located over 180 publications that resulted from the HERITAGE Family Study, but we could not find a comparator arm in any of these studies. Some authors did not explain this absence, while others reasoned that only inter-individual differences in exercise response were of interest, thus the intervention sample was investigated solely. We also found this absence of a comparator sample in on-going studies. A perceived high test–retest reliability is offered as a justification for the absence of a comparator arm, but the test–retest reliability analysis for the HERITAGE Family Study was over a much shorter term than the length of the actual training period between baseline and follow-up measurements of VO2max. We also scrutinised the studies in which twins have been investigated, resulting in concerns about how genetic influences on the magnitude of general within-subjects variability has been partitioned out (again in the absence of a comparator no-training group), as well as with the intra-class correlation coefficient approach to data analysis. Twin pairs were found to be sometimes heterogeneous for the obviously influential factors of sex, age and fitness, thereby inflating an unadjusted coefficient. We conclude that most studies on inter-individual differences in VO2max response to exercise training have no comparator sample. Therefore, true inter-individual differences in response cannot be quantified, let alone appraised for clinical relevance. For those studies with a comparator sample, we found that the inter-individual differences in training response were not larger than random within-subjects variation in VO2max over the same time period as the training intervention." @default.
- W3014234566 created "2020-04-10" @default.
- W3014234566 creator A5001965350 @default.
- W3014234566 creator A5023579171 @default.
- W3014234566 creator A5047656635 @default.
- W3014234566 date "2017-01-17" @default.
- W3014234566 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W3014234566 title "Inter-Individual Responses of Maximal Oxygen Uptake to Exercise Training: A Critical Review" @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1534124531 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1546792714 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1594881360 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1801946579 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1965855329 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1967843472 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1971474283 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1983962926 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1987307635 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W1995705380 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2000749215 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2002745120 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2004844047 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2005188365 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2006417958 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2014478990 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2027764283 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2030069564 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2031775018 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2031807525 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2032826483 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2033785475 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2035357709 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2036147078 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2057264876 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2067813974 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2068633037 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2068881191 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2070450583 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2073520427 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2074119251 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2082335023 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2085568044 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2093840858 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2100550631 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2107870851 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2119882662 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2123279057 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2124089679 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2124211545 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2128619219 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2130907129 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2133197025 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2144693601 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2152712346 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2156979977 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2159091122 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2162551959 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2165703184 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2166770001 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2172280757 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2173008358 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2206965945 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2319231450 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2466790303 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W4292691146 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W4383054200 @default.
- W3014234566 cites W2854376284 @default.
- W3014234566 doi "https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-017-0680-8" @default.
- W3014234566 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28097487" @default.
- W3014234566 hasPublicationYear "2017" @default.
- W3014234566 type Work @default.
- W3014234566 sameAs 3014234566 @default.
- W3014234566 citedByCount "65" @default.
- W3014234566 countsByYear W30142345662017 @default.
- W3014234566 countsByYear W30142345662018 @default.
- W3014234566 countsByYear W30142345662019 @default.
- W3014234566 countsByYear W30142345662020 @default.
- W3014234566 countsByYear W30142345662021 @default.
- W3014234566 countsByYear W30142345662022 @default.
- W3014234566 countsByYear W30142345662023 @default.
- W3014234566 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3014234566 hasAuthorship W3014234566A5001965350 @default.
- W3014234566 hasAuthorship W3014234566A5023579171 @default.
- W3014234566 hasAuthorship W3014234566A5047656635 @default.
- W3014234566 hasBestOaLocation W30142345662 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C1862650 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C196310339 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C22679943 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C2777953023 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C43893838 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C84393581 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConcept C99508421 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConceptScore W3014234566C105795698 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConceptScore W3014234566C126322002 @default.
- W3014234566 hasConceptScore W3014234566C1862650 @default.