Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3018582384> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3018582384 abstract "This is an update of the original review published in 2007.Carcinoma of the rectum is a common malignancy, especially in high income countries. Local recurrence may occur after surgery alone. Preoperative radiotherapy (PRT) has the potential to reduce the risk of local recurrence and improve outcomes in rectal cancer.To determine the effect of preoperative radiotherapy for people with localised resectable rectal cancer compared to surgery alone.We searched the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) (the Cochrane Library; Issue 5, 2018) (4 June 2018), MEDLINE (Ovid) (1950 to 4 June 2018), and Embase (Ovid) (1974 to 4 June 2018). We also searched ClinicalTrials.gov and the WHO International Clinical Trials Registry Platform (ICTRP) for relevant ongoing trials (4 June 2018).We included randomised controlled trials comparing PRT and surgery with surgery alone for people with localised advanced rectal cancer planned for radical surgery. We excluded trials that did not use contemporary radiotherapy techniques (with more than two fields to the pelvis).Two review authors independently assessed the 'Risk of bias' domains for each included trial, and extracted data. For time-to-event data, we calculated the Peto odds ratio (Peto OR) and variances, and for dichotomous data we calculated risk ratios (RR) using the random-effects method. Potential sources of heterogeneity hypothesised a priori included study quality, staging, and the use of total mesorectal excision (TME) surgery.We included four trials with a total of 4663 participants. All four trials reported short PRT courses, with three trials using 25 Gy in five fractions, and one trial using 20 Gy in four fractions. Only one study specifically required TME surgery for inclusion, whereas in another study 90% of participants received TME surgery.Preoperative radiotherapy probably reduces overall mortality at 4 to 12 years' follow-up (4 trials, 4663 participants; Peto OR 0.90, 95% CI 0.83 to 0.98; moderate-quality evidence). For every 1000 people who undergo surgery alone, 454 would die compared with 45 fewer (the true effect may lie between 77 fewer to 9 fewer) in the PRT group. There was some evidence from subgroup analyses that in trials using TME no or little effect of PRT on survival (P = 0.03 for the difference between subgroups).Preoperative radiotherapy may have little or no effect in reducing cause-specific mortality for rectal cancer (2 trials, 2145 participants; Peto OR 0.89, 95% CI 0.77 to 1.03; low-quality evidence).We found moderate-quality evidence that PRT reduces local recurrence (4 trials, 4663 participants; Peto OR 0.48, 95% CI 0.40 to 0.57). In absolute terms, 161 out of 1000 patients receiving surgery alone would experience local recurrence compared with 83 fewer with PRT. The results were consistent in TME and non-TME studies.There may be little or no difference in curative resection (4 trials, 4673 participants; RR 1.00, 95% CI 0.97 to 1.02; low-quality evidence) or in the need for sphincter-sparing surgery (3 trials, 4379 participants; RR 0.99, 95% CI 0.94 to 1.04; I2 = 0%; low-quality evidence) between PRT and surgery alone.Low-quality evidence suggests that PRT may increase the risk of sepsis from 13% to 16% (2 trials, 2698 participants; RR 1.25, 95% CI 1.04 to 1.52) and surgical complications from 25% to 30% (2 trials, 2698 participants; RR 1.20, 95% CI 1.01 to 1.42) compared to surgery alone.Two trials evaluated quality of life using different scales. Both studies concluded that sexual dysfunction occurred more in the PRT group. Mixed results were found for faecal incontinence, and irradiated participants tended to resume work later than non-irradiated participants between 6 and 12 months, but this effect had attenuated after 18 months (low-quality evidence).We found moderate-quality evidence that PRT reduces overall mortality. Subgroup analysis did not confirm this effect in people undergoing TME surgery. We found consistent evidence that PRT reduces local recurrence. Risk of sepsis and postsurgical complications may be higher with PRT.The main limitation of the findings of the present review concerns their applicability. The included trials only assessed short-course radiotherapy and did not use chemotherapy, which is widely used in the contemporary management of rectal cancer disease. The differences between the trials regarding the criteria used to define rectal cancer, staging, radiotherapy delivered, the time between radiotherapy and surgery, and the use of adjuvant or postoperative therapy did not appear to influence the size of effect across the studies.Future trials should focus on identifying participants that are most likely to benefit from PRT especially in terms of improving local control, sphincter preservation, and overall survival while reducing acute and late toxicities (especially rectal and sexual function), as well as determining the effect of radiotherapy when chemotherapy is used and the optimal timing of surgery following radiotherapy." @default.
- W3018582384 created "2020-05-01" @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5008208200 @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5024382768 @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5039883139 @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5041337278 @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5042502380 @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5052816020 @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5062422288 @default.
- W3018582384 creator A5074856508 @default.
- W3018582384 date "2018-10-03" @default.
- W3018582384 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
- W3018582384 title "Preoperative radiotherapy and curative surgery for the management of localised rectal carcinoma" @default.
- W3018582384 cites W104466403 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W122155191 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W129238531 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1480141401 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1492190372 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1538907916 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1585172067 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1592964109 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1739333826 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1757407923 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1862303280 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1896630734 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1899767765 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1908675343 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1944391634 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1963782590 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1967803994 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1968588574 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1968698109 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1968772763 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1969227627 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1969561516 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1971838125 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1972924417 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1974281067 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1975061972 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1975172590 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1975765859 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1978224105 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1978808039 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1982597946 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1982777873 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1985403999 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1988867891 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1988973560 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1989382906 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1994210154 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1994513558 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1996346324 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W1997678735 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2000687665 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2002431717 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2004603560 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2006072423 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2006216517 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2007983135 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2008131349 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2008373838 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2008833109 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2009781085 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2010533979 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2010617390 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2011409664 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2013304077 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2015159074 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2017132889 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2020938668 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2020956130 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2020972487 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2021416608 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2022323370 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2024289087 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2027469879 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2029511848 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2034945181 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2036477956 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2036776638 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2043236131 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2043317119 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2043677478 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2043768933 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2044601095 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2044788022 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2046953205 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2050020104 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2050838616 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2053486014 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2054111097 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2055683712 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2057331955 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2057579848 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2059491071 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2060825762 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2061353826 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2063776175 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2065384164 @default.
- W3018582384 cites W2069636589 @default.