Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3021454583> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3021454583 abstract "Abstract Peer review is embedded in the core of our knowledge generation systems, perceived as a method for establishing quality or scholarly legitimacy for research, while also often distributing academic prestige and standing on individuals. Despite its critical importance, it curiously remains poorly understood in a number of dimensions. In order to address this, we have analysed peer review to assess where the major gaps in our theoretical and empirical understanding of it lie. We identify core themes including editorial responsibility, the subjectivity and bias of reviewers, the function and quality of peer review, and the social and epistemic implications of peer review. The high-priority gaps are focused around increased accountability and justification in decision-making processes for editors and developing a deeper, empirical understanding of the social impact of peer review. Addressing this at the bare minimum will require the design of a consensus for a minimal set of standards for what constitutes peer review, and the development of a shared data infrastructure to support this. Such a field requires sustained funding and commitment from publishers and research funders, who both have a commitment to uphold the integrity of the published scholarly record. We use this to present a guide for the future of peer review, and the development of a new research discipline based on the study of peer review." @default.
- W3021454583 created "2020-05-13" @default.
- W3021454583 creator A5009210770 @default.
- W3021454583 creator A5075553665 @default.
- W3021454583 date "2020-04-30" @default.
- W3021454583 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W3021454583 title "The limitations to our understanding of peer review" @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1504922255 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1561313043 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1578561495 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1886120841 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1897139626 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1971896716 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1985282759 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1992788944 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W1999169975 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2003913001 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2005950835 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2012950673 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2018223524 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2021920339 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2022536451 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2034283884 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2041212401 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2041723949 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2045148187 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2063743914 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2076765281 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2078020500 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2085271766 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2102675127 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2133126210 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2144816075 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2145485458 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2152243616 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2158942069 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2171827218 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2176101783 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2235693693 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2336977259 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2339294314 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2461645408 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2527516663 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2538910358 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2570760970 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2592437185 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2592989848 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2604669265 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2609499779 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2618665414 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2626284853 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2737578613 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2737988770 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2743567953 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2748401780 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2753410613 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2754461217 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2756626687 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2763785586 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2768281947 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2771841635 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2786497440 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2788415229 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2803567385 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2804392128 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2888173901 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2888809297 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2895416954 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2898136155 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2902356319 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2903652688 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2909282566 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2910081691 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2910210452 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2917178759 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2928505459 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2938357171 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2940242975 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2941337565 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2948947599 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2949583693 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2952240703 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2954112540 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2954430020 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2955090621 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2963844980 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2964143002 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2964481132 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2964719748 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2969186822 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2973009231 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2973121766 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W2996173315 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W3008802372 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W3103708955 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W3110179196 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W4230864654 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W4231511862 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W4234753240 @default.
- W3021454583 cites W4235332646 @default.