Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3022834401> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3022834401 endingPage "1972" @default.
- W3022834401 startingPage "1953" @default.
- W3022834401 abstract "Purpose To compare the efficacy and safety of individual devices for femoral and/or tibial graft fixation in anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. Methods The PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, and Web of Science databases were searched from inception to December 12, 2018. Randomized controlled trials comparing individual devices for ACL graft fixation were included. Bayesian network meta-analysis was performed to assess the efficacy profile using the following outcomes: Lysholm score, International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC) category, laxity, range of motion, and Tegner score. The incidence of infection, effusion, and graft rupture for each device was reported. Results We included 57 randomized controlled trials involving 4,304 patients aged 23.8 to 40.9 years. The female proportion ranged from 0% to 100%. The length of follow-up ranged from 6 to 144 months. Of the 13 studied femoral fixation devices, none was significantly different from the others regarding the Lysholm score, IKDC category, range of motion, and Tegner score. Bioabsorbable interference screws (standardized mean difference, 1.3; 95% credible interval, 0.0-2.5) showed higher laxity than the EndoPearl at a borderline level of statistical significance, but the difference varied substantially within multiple sensitivity analyses. Infection (2.0%) was most commonly seen with the EndoPearl, whereas the bone mulch screw had the highest incidence of effusion (5.5%) and graft rupture (5.5%). For the 9 studied tibial fixation devices, no significant difference was observed in the aforementioned efficacy measurements. Bioabsorbable interference screws with staples had the highest incidence of infection (11.1%) and effusion (15.6%), whereas graft rupture was most commonly seen with the bone plug (4.0%). Conclusions Graft fixation devices in ACL reconstruction share a similar efficacy profile in terms of the Lysholm score, IKDC category, range of motion, and Tegner score but not laxity. On the other hand, safety profiles seem to vary among different devices. These findings can support surgeons, alongside their experience and preference, as well as the relative cost of each device, in delivering an individualized plan for an optimal operation. Level of Evidence Level II, meta-analysis of Level I and II studies." @default.
- W3022834401 created "2020-05-13" @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5015850576 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5022596740 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5031114859 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5037855527 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5041571735 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5043839950 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5046247618 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5063557255 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5064970788 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5083440388 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5084297561 @default.
- W3022834401 creator A5088533080 @default.
- W3022834401 date "2020-07-01" @default.
- W3022834401 modified "2023-09-30" @default.
- W3022834401 title "Comparative Risk-Benefit Profiles of Individual Devices for Graft Fixation in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis" @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1537972189 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1617328014 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1967385770 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1973555832 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1974125679 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1978109598 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1980910291 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1987535610 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1994334230 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1995232697 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1995777506 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1996698606 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W1998837615 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2002714501 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2005872412 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2005987828 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2006563791 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2006653667 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2007029946 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2010818945 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2011452808 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2024737544 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2025733065 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2026557267 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2030625656 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2032705602 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2035605947 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2042454600 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2044464018 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2046362994 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2046857081 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2048609918 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2048821464 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2049629232 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2050305815 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2053528816 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2056211953 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2058507604 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2059903074 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2061167912 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2061227862 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2064524842 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2064576431 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2068255892 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2068944812 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2069690926 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2071294018 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2078506899 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2079629687 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2080069729 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2082328458 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2083226396 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2085803274 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2086642505 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2088946530 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2093289271 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2096820816 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2113144077 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2113791418 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2118344996 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2125690447 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2126748426 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2129696329 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2131347256 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2131886165 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2132106136 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2139061200 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2150529573 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2154682612 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2156479859 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2162321417 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2163070948 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2163315798 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2164678492 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2169500930 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2170438331 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2170663537 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2200321012 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2263461392 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2343056193 @default.
- W3022834401 cites W2463616031 @default.