Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3029468047> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3029468047 endingPage "54" @default.
- W3029468047 startingPage "49" @default.
- W3029468047 abstract "Abstract Purpose A recent meta-analysis by Munshi et al. (Lancet Respiratory Medicine, 2019) claimed mortality treatment efficacy for extra corporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) in the acute respitratory syndrome (ARDS) despite very low meta-analytic study numbers (n = 2 (RCTs), risk-ratio (RR) 0·73 (95%CI: 0·58–0·92); n = 5 (2 RCT, 3 observational), RR 0·69 (95%CI: 0·50–0·95)). We explore this efficacy claim by a comprehensive re-analysis of the data. Methods Data were sourced from the two- and five-study meta-analyses, conducted using the Der-Simonian & Laird (DSL) method. A variety of frequentist (DSL, restricted maximum likelihood (REML), Paul-Mandel (PM), with/without Hartung-Knapp-Sidik-Jonkman variance correction), a beta-binomial model (BBN)) and Bayesian models (2 finite-mixture and several Markov-Chain-Monte-Carlo) were used to estimate treatment effects. Fragility-indices, the minimum patients changing mortality outcome needed to induce a conclusion change were also applied. Results For the 2-study and 5-study meta-analysis only the uncorrected frequentist estimators (DSL, REML, PM) demonstrated significant RR. Except for the BBN model, which was significant for the 2-study meta-analysis, intervals for all other models included the null. Both meta-analyses demonstrated fragility. Conclusions Having canvassed the conduct of both meta-analyses presented by Munshi et al. and proffered alternative methods, we find no certainty regarding the efficacy of ECMO in ARDS." @default.
- W3029468047 created "2020-06-05" @default.
- W3029468047 creator A5032246159 @default.
- W3029468047 creator A5083319191 @default.
- W3029468047 date "2020-10-01" @default.
- W3029468047 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W3029468047 title "ECMO, ARDS and meta-analyses: Bayes to the rescue?" @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1580781770 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1784175517 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1803108444 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1885620792 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1918813775 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1958895821 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1962828273 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1967920356 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1971130432 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1984406996 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1988172012 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W1989782940 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2001569600 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2032506622 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2054884879 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2089250884 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2101328245 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2105123265 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2107328434 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2129670822 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2131701504 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2139168999 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2141408576 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2143109076 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2152751551 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2164957370 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2165852759 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2166546590 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2168331993 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2271307894 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2438033049 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2527786681 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2544437330 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2560317207 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2770202174 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2784015963 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2790268129 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2792076277 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2803603947 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2804479356 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2804595505 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2909054539 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2909355137 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2909849393 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2911047707 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2933917276 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2967981766 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2968695024 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W2969351597 @default.
- W3029468047 cites W4256082827 @default.
- W3029468047 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrc.2020.05.009" @default.
- W3029468047 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32516642" @default.
- W3029468047 hasPublicationYear "2020" @default.
- W3029468047 type Work @default.
- W3029468047 sameAs 3029468047 @default.
- W3029468047 citedByCount "2" @default.
- W3029468047 countsByYear W30294680472015 @default.
- W3029468047 countsByYear W30294680472021 @default.
- W3029468047 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3029468047 hasAuthorship W3029468047A5032246159 @default.
- W3029468047 hasAuthorship W3029468047A5083319191 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C107673813 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C177713679 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C207201462 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C2776348555 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C2776485726 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C2777714996 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C107673813 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C126322002 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C154945302 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C177713679 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C207201462 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C2776348555 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C2776485726 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C2777714996 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C41008148 @default.
- W3029468047 hasConceptScore W3029468047C71924100 @default.
- W3029468047 hasLocation W30294680471 @default.
- W3029468047 hasOpenAccess W3029468047 @default.
- W3029468047 hasPrimaryLocation W30294680471 @default.
- W3029468047 hasRelatedWork W2015960525 @default.
- W3029468047 hasRelatedWork W2153683596 @default.
- W3029468047 hasRelatedWork W2417291335 @default.
- W3029468047 hasRelatedWork W2549155837 @default.
- W3029468047 hasRelatedWork W2560762496 @default.
- W3029468047 hasRelatedWork W3023589795 @default.
- W3029468047 hasRelatedWork W3029468047 @default.