Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3032461567> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3032461567 endingPage "1259" @default.
- W3032461567 startingPage "1242" @default.
- W3032461567 abstract "Recently, Wu, Wang, and Evans (2019) and Bu, Waltman, and Huang (2019) proposed a new family of indicators, which measure whether a scientific publication is disruptive to a field or tradition of research. Such disruptive influences are characterized by citations to a focal paper, but not its cited references. In this study, we are interested in the question of convergent validity, i.e., whether these indicators of disruption are able to measure what they propose to measure ('disruptiveness'). We used external criteria of newness to examine convergent validity: in the post-publication peer review system of F1000Prime, experts assess papers whether the reported research fulfills these criteria (e.g., reports new findings). This study is based on 120,179 papers from F1000Prime published between 2000 and 2016. In the first part of the study we discuss the indicators. Based on the insights from the discussion, we propose alternate variants of disruption indicators. In the second part, we investigate the convergent validity of the indicators and the (possibly) improved variants. Although the results of a factor analysis show that the different variants measure similar dimensions, the results of regression analyses reveal that one variant (DI5) performs slightly better than the others." @default.
- W3032461567 created "2020-06-05" @default.
- W3032461567 creator A5005396724 @default.
- W3032461567 creator A5027052270 @default.
- W3032461567 creator A5075783656 @default.
- W3032461567 creator A5091551383 @default.
- W3032461567 date "2020-08-01" @default.
- W3032461567 modified "2023-10-03" @default.
- W3032461567 title "Are disruption index indicators convergently valid? The comparison of several indicator variants with assessments by peers" @default.
- W3032461567 cites W1533350200 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W1557530328 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W163712256 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W1965433309 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W1973971405 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W1977862340 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W1998116478 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2008667434 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2010465475 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2019753053 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2050123348 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2050161578 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2066752129 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2066884817 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2068452509 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2106539315 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2110462941 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2117692326 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2126644589 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2154053722 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2154710696 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2164146029 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2303284028 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2401645159 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2436401451 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2512925182 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2607413328 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2791998006 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2794465725 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2896629373 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2913773162 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2914281332 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2924476770 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2962925905 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2963580986 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2975166839 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2979592798 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W2987046955 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W3101604308 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W3122634626 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W3123050710 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W4247460398 @default.
- W3032461567 cites W4255117183 @default.
- W3032461567 doi "https://doi.org/10.1162/qss_a_00068" @default.
- W3032461567 hasPublicationYear "2020" @default.
- W3032461567 type Work @default.
- W3032461567 sameAs 3032461567 @default.
- W3032461567 citedByCount "23" @default.
- W3032461567 countsByYear W30324615672019 @default.
- W3032461567 countsByYear W30324615672021 @default.
- W3032461567 countsByYear W30324615672022 @default.
- W3032461567 countsByYear W30324615672023 @default.
- W3032461567 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3032461567 hasAuthorship W3032461567A5005396724 @default.
- W3032461567 hasAuthorship W3032461567A5027052270 @default.
- W3032461567 hasAuthorship W3032461567A5075783656 @default.
- W3032461567 hasAuthorship W3032461567A5091551383 @default.
- W3032461567 hasBestOaLocation W30324615671 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C121244757 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C124101348 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C136764020 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C171606756 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C202444582 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C2522767166 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C2777382242 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C2780009758 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C3018868096 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C70410870 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConcept C9652623 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C121244757 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C124101348 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C136764020 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C15744967 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C171606756 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C202444582 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C2522767166 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C2777382242 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C2780009758 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C3018868096 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C33923547 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C41008148 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C70410870 @default.
- W3032461567 hasConceptScore W3032461567C9652623 @default.
- W3032461567 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W3032461567 hasLocation W30324615671 @default.
- W3032461567 hasLocation W30324615672 @default.