Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3035763968> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3035763968 abstract "A diagnostic judgment of a teacher can be seen as an inference from manifest observable evidence on a student’s behavior to his or her latent traits. This can be described by a Bayesian model of in-ference: The teacher starts from a set of assumptions on the student (hypotheses), with subjective probabilities for each hypothesis (priors). Subsequently, he or she uses observed evidence (stu-dents’ responses to tasks) and knowledge on conditional probabilities of this evidence (likelihoods) to revise these assumptions. Many systematic deviations from this model (biases, e.g. base-rate neglect, inverse fallacy) are reported in literature on Bayesian reasoning. In a teacher’s situation the information (hypotheses, priors, likelihoods) is usually not explicitly represented numerically (as in most research on Bayesian reasoning), but only by qualitative esti-mations in the mind of the teacher. In our study, we ask to which extent individuals (approximately) apply a rational Bayesian strategy or resort on other biased strategies of processing information for their diagnostic judgments. We explicitly pose this question with respect to non-numerical settings. To investigate this question, we developed a scenario that visually displays all relevant information (hypotheses, priors, likelihoods) in a graphically displayed hypothesis space (called “hypothegon”) – without recurring to numerical representations or mathematical procedures. 42 pre-service teach-ers were asked to judge the plausibility of different misconceptions of six students based on their responses to decimal comparison tasks (e.g. 3.39 > 3.4). Applying a Bayesian classification proce-dure, we identified three updating strategies: A Bayesian update strategy (BUS, processing all probabilities), a combined evidence strategy (CES, ignoring the prior probabilities but including all likelihoods), and a single evidence strategy (SES, only using the likelihood of the most probable hypothesis). In study 1, an instruction on the relevance of using all probabilities (priors and likelihoods) only weakly increased the processing of more information. In study 2, we found strong evidence that a visual explication of the prior-likelihood interaction led to an increase of processing the interaction of all relevant information. These results show that the phenomena found in general research on Bayesian reasoning in numerical settings extend to diagnostic judgments in non-numerical settings." @default.
- W3035763968 created "2020-06-25" @default.
- W3035763968 creator A5000129913 @default.
- W3035763968 creator A5058818637 @default.
- W3035763968 date "2020-07-03" @default.
- W3035763968 modified "2023-10-05" @default.
- W3035763968 title "Processing Probability Information in Nonnumerical Settings – Teachers’ Bayesian and Non-bayesian Strategies During Diagnostic Judgment" @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1124355382 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1210699751 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W137420995 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1493876129 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1495540294 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W158727920 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1966107659 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1969411308 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1976717536 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1985252491 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W1986107724 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2009191024 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2016877725 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2017987083 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2018635757 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2020912185 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2022371018 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2039395668 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2044641991 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2055476838 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2061173121 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2090966258 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2097279224 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2123781216 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2130623327 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2140785063 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2141956557 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2144066648 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2145161351 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2148962857 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2155655731 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2158553842 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2159292941 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2188398335 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2334529533 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W251659662 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2536575803 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2570755836 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2594683579 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2766185881 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2778544210 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2798269939 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2897860938 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2917796852 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2944633571 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2950557080 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W2981362155 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W3010416646 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W4231324690 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W4234587807 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W4248094046 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W4292157289 @default.
- W3035763968 cites W789509321 @default.
- W3035763968 doi "https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2020.00678" @default.
- W3035763968 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/7348070" @default.
- W3035763968 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32719627" @default.
- W3035763968 hasPublicationYear "2020" @default.
- W3035763968 type Work @default.
- W3035763968 sameAs 3035763968 @default.
- W3035763968 citedByCount "4" @default.
- W3035763968 countsByYear W30357639682021 @default.
- W3035763968 countsByYear W30357639682022 @default.
- W3035763968 countsByYear W30357639682023 @default.
- W3035763968 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3035763968 hasAuthorship W3035763968A5000129913 @default.
- W3035763968 hasAuthorship W3035763968A5058818637 @default.
- W3035763968 hasBestOaLocation W30357639681 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C101112237 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C107673813 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C119857082 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C142291917 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C160234255 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C162376815 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C177264268 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C177769412 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C2776214188 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C101112237 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C107673813 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C119857082 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C142291917 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C154945302 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C15744967 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C160234255 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C162376815 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C177264268 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C177769412 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C180747234 @default.
- W3035763968 hasConceptScore W3035763968C199360897 @default.