Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3038372010> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3038372010 abstract "ABSTRACT Information is coded in the brain at different scales for different phenomena: locally, distributed across regions and networks, and globally. For pain, the scale of representation is controversial. Although generally believed to be an integrated cognitive and sensory phenomenon implicating diverse brain systems, quantitative characterizations of which regions and networks are sufficient to represent pain are lacking. In this meta-analysis (or mega-analysis) using data from 289 participants across 10 studies, we use model comparison combined with multivariate predictive models to investigate the spatial scale and location of acute pain representation. We compare models based on (a) a single most pain-predictive module, either previously identified elementary regions or a single best large-scale cortical resting-state network module; (b) selected cortical-subcortical systems related to evoked pain in prior literature (‘multi-system models’); and (c) a model spanning the full brain. We estimate the accuracy of pain intensity predictions using cross validation (7 studies) and subsequently validate in three independent holdout studies. All spatial scales convey information about pain intensity, but distributed, multi-system models better characterize pain representations than any individual region or network (e.g. multisystem models explain >20% more of individual subject pain ratings than the best elementary region). Full brain models showed no predictive advantage over multi-system models. These findings quantify the extent that representation of evoked pain experience is distributed across multiple cortical and subcortical systems, show that pain representation is not circumscribed by any elementary region or conical network, and provide a blueprint for identifying the spatial scale of information in other domains. Significance Statement We define modular, multisystem and global views of brain function, use multivariate fMRI decoding to characterize pain representations at each level, and provide evidence for a multisystem representation of evoked pain. We further show that local views necessarily exclude important components of pain representation, while a global full brain representation is superfluous, even though both are viable frameworks for representing pain. These findings quantitatively juxtapose and reconcile divergent conclusions from evoked pain studies within a generalized neuroscientific framework, and provide a blueprint for investigating representational architecture for diverse brain processes. Author Note Data storage supported by the University of Colorado Boulder “PetaLibrary”. Research funded by NIMH R01 MH076136, NIDA R01 DA046064 and NIDA R01 DA035484. Lauren Atlas is supported in part by funding from the Intramural Research Program of the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, National Institutes of Health (ZIA-AT000030). Marina Lopez-Sola is supported by a Serra Hunter fellow lecturer program. We would like to thank Dr. Christian Buchel for contributing data to this project, and Dr. Marta Čeko for comments and feedback on the manuscript." @default.
- W3038372010 created "2020-07-10" @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5001964885 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5004122059 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5006154621 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5023740479 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5031032159 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5033630633 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5036324000 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5041962211 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5042529459 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5069949293 @default.
- W3038372010 creator A5076916607 @default.
- W3038372010 date "2020-07-04" @default.
- W3038372010 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W3038372010 title "Evoked pain intensity representation is distributed across brain systems: A multistudy mega-analysis" @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1487335548 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1506409150 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1519746197 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1534340867 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1664843084 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1706861413 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W176201993 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W181509621 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1881300191 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1963543003 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1976193721 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1979071588 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1983006199 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1987906186 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1989363579 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1989389824 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1989522832 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1989982790 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1990609390 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W1995906064 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2007729962 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2008961184 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2011131455 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2014157362 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2014779151 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2020617419 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2026049606 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2031583388 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2035378228 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2037272682 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2042837986 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2044479451 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2046504031 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2046836290 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2053237118 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2055962504 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2060449369 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2061170062 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2065893025 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2067849553 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2068906079 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2076118331 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2085561705 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2085955270 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2089632738 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2094918351 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2096043274 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2097180277 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2105824687 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2108008975 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2109173536 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2110373398 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2113168655 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2114900140 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2116658855 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2123341385 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2124757386 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2125197016 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2131165483 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2135382170 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2136015881 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2142353736 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2150146047 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2152160545 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2155028101 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2158090607 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2158295749 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2159334079 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2160938249 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2162010696 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2167277498 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2179752489 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2206243626 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2253338868 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2288271511 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2332549914 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2336480635 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2339872010 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2409807130 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2499800833 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2530925272 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2577537660 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2588447348 @default.
- W3038372010 cites W2614737846 @default.