Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3039456232> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 93 of
93
with 100 items per page.
- W3039456232 endingPage "1076" @default.
- W3039456232 startingPage "1057" @default.
- W3039456232 abstract "Purpose Peer reviewer evaluations of academic papers are known to be variable in content and overall judgements but are important academic publishing safeguards. This article introduces a sentiment analysis program, PeerJudge, to detect praise and criticism in peer evaluations. It is designed to support editorial management decisions and reviewers in the scholarly publishing process and for grant funding decision workflows. The initial version of PeerJudge is tailored for reviews from F1000Research's open peer review publishing platform. Design/methodology/approach PeerJudge uses a lexical sentiment analysis approach with a human-coded initial sentiment lexicon and machine learning adjustments and additions. It was built with an F1000Research development corpus and evaluated on a different F1000Research test corpus using reviewer ratings. Findings PeerJudge can predict F1000Research judgements from negative evaluations in reviewers' comments more accurately than baseline approaches, although not from positive reviewer comments, which seem to be largely unrelated to reviewer decisions. Within the F1000Research mode of post-publication peer review, the absence of any detected negative comments is a reliable indicator that an article will be ‘approved’, but the presence of moderately negative comments could lead to either an approved or approved with reservations decision. Originality/value PeerJudge is the first transparent AI approach to peer review sentiment detection. It may be used to identify anomalous reviews with text potentially not matching judgements for individual checks or systematic bias assessments." @default.
- W3039456232 created "2020-07-10" @default.
- W3039456232 creator A5008376826 @default.
- W3039456232 creator A5018077373 @default.
- W3039456232 creator A5024503979 @default.
- W3039456232 creator A5028344006 @default.
- W3039456232 creator A5036549394 @default.
- W3039456232 date "2020-06-15" @default.
- W3039456232 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W3039456232 title "Automatically detecting open academic review praise and criticism" @default.
- W3039456232 cites W1971648300 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W1987425720 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W1989281298 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2034165193 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2041212401 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2079772095 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2084046180 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2095455968 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2151386967 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2167023602 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2171827218 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2235693693 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2291451608 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2526355008 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2609499779 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2760849492 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W2910210452 @default.
- W3039456232 cites W4211186029 @default.
- W3039456232 doi "https://doi.org/10.1108/oir-11-2019-0347" @default.
- W3039456232 hasPublicationYear "2020" @default.
- W3039456232 type Work @default.
- W3039456232 sameAs 3039456232 @default.
- W3039456232 citedByCount "14" @default.
- W3039456232 countsByYear W30394562322021 @default.
- W3039456232 countsByYear W30394562322022 @default.
- W3039456232 countsByYear W30394562322023 @default.
- W3039456232 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3039456232 hasAuthorship W3039456232A5008376826 @default.
- W3039456232 hasAuthorship W3039456232A5018077373 @default.
- W3039456232 hasAuthorship W3039456232A5024503979 @default.
- W3039456232 hasAuthorship W3039456232A5028344006 @default.
- W3039456232 hasAuthorship W3039456232A5036549394 @default.
- W3039456232 hasBestOaLocation W30394562322 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C11012388 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C138368954 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C151719136 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C2775868214 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C2776950860 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C2778121359 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C66402592 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConcept C7991579 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C11012388 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C138368954 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C151719136 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C154945302 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C15744967 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C17744445 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C199539241 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C2775868214 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C2776950860 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C2778121359 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C41008148 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C66402592 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C77805123 @default.
- W3039456232 hasConceptScore W3039456232C7991579 @default.
- W3039456232 hasIssue "5" @default.
- W3039456232 hasLocation W30394562321 @default.
- W3039456232 hasLocation W30394562322 @default.
- W3039456232 hasOpenAccess W3039456232 @default.
- W3039456232 hasPrimaryLocation W30394562321 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W1631585051 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W2150818832 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W2593058442 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W2626568907 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W2888662092 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W2902285665 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W2903394456 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W2975174210 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W4200238620 @default.
- W3039456232 hasRelatedWork W3205826705 @default.
- W3039456232 hasVolume "44" @default.
- W3039456232 isParatext "false" @default.
- W3039456232 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W3039456232 magId "3039456232" @default.
- W3039456232 workType "article" @default.