Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3095434907> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3095434907 endingPage "535" @default.
- W3095434907 startingPage "519" @default.
- W3095434907 abstract "By synthesizing the argumentation theory of new rhetoric with research on heuristics and motivated reasoning, we develop a conceptual view of argumentation based on reasoning motivations that sheds new light on the morality of decision-making. Accordingly, we propose that reasoning in eristic argumentation is motivated by psychological (e.g., anxiety reduction) or material (e.g., vested interests) gains that do not depend on resolving the problem in question truthfully. Contrary to heuristic argumentation, in which disputants genuinely argue to reach a practically rational solution, eristic argumentation aims to defeat the counterparty rather than seeking a reasonable solution. Eristic argumentation is susceptible to arbitrariness and power abuses; therefore, it is inappropriate for making moral judgments with the exception of judgments concerning moral taboos, which are closed to argumentation by their nature. Eristic argumentation is also problematic for strategic and entrepreneurial decision-making because it impedes the search for the right heuristic under uncertainty as an ecologically rational choice. However, our theoretical view emphasizes that under extreme uncertainty, where heuristic solutions are as fallible as any guesses, pretense reasoning by eristic argumentation may be instrumental for its adaptive benefits. Expanding the concept of eristic argumentation based on reasoning motivations opens a new path for studying the psychology of reasoning in connection to morality and decision-making under uncertainty. We discuss the implications of our theoretical view to relevant research streams, including ethical, strategic and entrepreneurial decision-making." @default.
- W3095434907 created "2020-11-09" @default.
- W3095434907 creator A5024562881 @default.
- W3095434907 creator A5079252364 @default.
- W3095434907 date "2020-10-26" @default.
- W3095434907 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
- W3095434907 title "Arguing to Defeat: Eristic Argumentation and Irrationality in Resolving Moral Concerns" @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1507885202 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1539618770 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W157856474 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1774007993 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1837287643 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1891847548 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1972117855 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1988631338 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1992665716 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1994106556 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1995835640 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1996748585 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1997398948 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W1999394629 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2006977279 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2008058169 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2008466475 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2016362814 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2018083543 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2023292379 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2031963937 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2033220551 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2037129160 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2038615357 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2046054386 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2050731102 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2058471438 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2060360420 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2061804625 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2062483523 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2067761470 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2073259619 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2074330718 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W207537803 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2077702735 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2078403332 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2085535361 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2085968192 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2089011479 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2090316682 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2093744445 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2095745288 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2096016260 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2103172287 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2104256533 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2105938655 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2107517384 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2110234406 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2111221954 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2117535423 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2119432837 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2119659537 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2121160924 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2121366015 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2123791568 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2124663919 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2128058576 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2128498260 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2128665387 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2128974935 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2136962789 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2138151890 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2140777058 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2143280243 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2144108520 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2147094445 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2149893809 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2157916681 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2159292941 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2160640786 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2162260603 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2165258518 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2168631029 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2171395624 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2303555323 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2329031405 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2409823294 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2475988931 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2484437428 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2493006469 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2496775934 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2519182586 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2520456639 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2531824745 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2585604413 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2593761652 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2597479896 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2610173154 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2655825240 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2737106639 @default.
- W3095434907 cites W2767057444 @default.