Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3110078204> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 96 of
96
with 100 items per page.
- W3110078204 endingPage "522" @default.
- W3110078204 startingPage "519" @default.
- W3110078204 abstract "DeMatteo et al. (2020a) published a Statement in this journal declaring that the Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R) “cannot and should not” be used in U.S. capital-sentencing cases to assess risk for serious institutional violence. Their stated concerns were the PCL-R’s “imperfect interrater reliability,” its “variability in predictive validity,” and its prejudicial effects on the defendant. In a Cautionary Note, we (Olver et al., 2020) raised questions about the Statement’s evaluation of the PCL-R’s psychometric properties, presented new data, including a meta-meta-analysis, and argued that the evidence did not support the Statement’s declaration that the PCL-R “cannot” be used in high stakes contexts. In their reply, titled “Death is Different,” DeMatteo et al. (2020b) concurred with several points in our Cautionary Note, disputed others, asserted that we had misunderstood or mischaracterized their Statement, and dismissed our new data and comments as irrelevant to the Statement’s purpose. This perspective on our commentary is inimical to balanced academic discourse. In this article, we contend that DeMatteo et al. (2020b) underestimated the reliability and predictive validity of PCL-R ratings, overestimated the centrality of the PCL-R in sentencing decisions, and underplayed the importance of other factors. Most of their arguments depended on sources other than capital cases, including mock trials, Sexually Violent Predator (SVP) hearings, and studies that included the prediction of general violence. We conclude that the rationale for the bold “cannot and should not” decree is open to debate and in need of research in real-life venues." @default.
- W3110078204 created "2020-12-07" @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5000985587 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5005147146 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5009404777 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5014000601 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5015647568 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5020403439 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5040116080 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5041398195 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5047284354 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5049913352 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5053295016 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5053734000 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5062243497 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5067612294 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5069628734 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5069713363 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5070053071 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5071971928 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5079103100 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5079205789 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5079364040 @default.
- W3110078204 creator A5088902643 @default.
- W3110078204 date "2020-11-01" @default.
- W3110078204 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W3110078204 title "The PCL–R and capital sentencing: A commentary on “Death is different” DeMatteo et al. (2020a)." @default.
- W3110078204 doi "https://doi.org/10.1037/law0000290" @default.
- W3110078204 hasPublicationYear "2020" @default.
- W3110078204 type Work @default.
- W3110078204 sameAs 3110078204 @default.
- W3110078204 citedByCount "4" @default.
- W3110078204 countsByYear W31100782042021 @default.
- W3110078204 countsByYear W31100782042022 @default.
- W3110078204 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5000985587 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5005147146 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5009404777 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5014000601 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5015647568 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5020403439 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5040116080 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5041398195 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5047284354 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5049913352 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5053295016 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5053734000 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5062243497 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5067612294 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5069628734 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5069713363 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5070053071 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5071971928 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5079103100 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5079205789 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5079364040 @default.
- W3110078204 hasAuthorship W3110078204A5088902643 @default.
- W3110078204 hasBestOaLocation W31100782042 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConcept C73484699 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConcept C83646750 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConceptScore W3110078204C15744967 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConceptScore W3110078204C166957645 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConceptScore W3110078204C17744445 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConceptScore W3110078204C185592680 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConceptScore W3110078204C73484699 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConceptScore W3110078204C83646750 @default.
- W3110078204 hasConceptScore W3110078204C95457728 @default.
- W3110078204 hasIssue "4" @default.
- W3110078204 hasLocation W31100782041 @default.
- W3110078204 hasLocation W31100782042 @default.
- W3110078204 hasLocation W31100782043 @default.
- W3110078204 hasLocation W31100782044 @default.
- W3110078204 hasOpenAccess W3110078204 @default.
- W3110078204 hasPrimaryLocation W31100782041 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W1574067136 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W1979554332 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W2056704778 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W2105784618 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W3197559158 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W355416590 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W437331315 @default.
- W3110078204 hasRelatedWork W897258703 @default.
- W3110078204 hasVolume "26" @default.
- W3110078204 isParatext "false" @default.
- W3110078204 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W3110078204 magId "3110078204" @default.
- W3110078204 workType "article" @default.