Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3110173253> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3110173253 endingPage "111" @default.
- W3110173253 startingPage "102" @default.
- W3110173253 abstract "Abstract Using peer review to assess the validity of research proposals has always had its fair share of critics, including a more-than-fair-share of scholars. The debate about this method of assessing these proposals now seems trivial when compared with assessing the validity for granting funding by lottery. Some of the same scholars have suggested that the way grant lottery was being assessed has made random allocation seem even-handed, less biased and more supportive of innovative research. But we know little of what researchers actually think about grant lottery and even less about the thoughts of those scientists who rely on funding. This paper examines scientists’ perspectives on selecting grants by ‘lots’ and how they justify their support or opposition. How do they approach something scientifically that is, in itself, not scientific? These approaches were investigated with problem-centered interviews conducted with natural scientists in Germany. The qualitative interviews for this paper reveal that scientists in dominated and dominating field positions are, more or less, open to the idea of giving a selection process by lots a try. Nonetheless, they are against pure randomization because from their point of view it is incompatible with scientific principles. They rather favor a combination of grant lottery and peer review processes, assuming that only under these conditions could randomly allocated funding be an integral and legitimate part of science." @default.
- W3110173253 created "2020-12-07" @default.
- W3110173253 creator A5001388667 @default.
- W3110173253 date "2020-12-03" @default.
- W3110173253 modified "2023-10-02" @default.
- W3110173253 title "Science rules! A qualitative study of scientists’ approaches to grant lottery" @default.
- W3110173253 cites W1977862340 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W1984734857 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W1992473939 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2007188662 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2009037680 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2026241885 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2027108366 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2030415573 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2032020071 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2038004520 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2040367295 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2048226528 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2056647894 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2072020930 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2072829188 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2113929081 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2129508295 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2130939375 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2148022239 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2208665323 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2287659220 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2322421231 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2338437147 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2518635282 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2753669124 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2808695277 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2893881317 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2911070541 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2969633830 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2969916750 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2975145430 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2979799401 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2981564382 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2984676581 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2987502572 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2990004562 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W2990531678 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W3001239834 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W3001442806 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W3012943324 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W3122634626 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W3125028478 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W4211042726 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W4237327899 @default.
- W3110173253 cites W4245671161 @default.
- W3110173253 doi "https://doi.org/10.1093/reseval/rvaa027" @default.
- W3110173253 hasPublicationYear "2020" @default.
- W3110173253 type Work @default.
- W3110173253 sameAs 3110173253 @default.
- W3110173253 citedByCount "6" @default.
- W3110173253 countsByYear W31101732532021 @default.
- W3110173253 countsByYear W31101732532022 @default.
- W3110173253 countsByYear W31101732532023 @default.
- W3110173253 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3110173253 hasAuthorship W3110173253A5001388667 @default.
- W3110173253 hasBestOaLocation W31101732531 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C118084267 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C175444787 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C190248442 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C2777340749 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C2780668109 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C36289849 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C39549134 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C118084267 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C144024400 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C162324750 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C175444787 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C17744445 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C190248442 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C199539241 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C2777340749 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C2780668109 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C36289849 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C39549134 @default.
- W3110173253 hasConceptScore W3110173253C94625758 @default.
- W3110173253 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W3110173253 hasLocation W31101732531 @default.
- W3110173253 hasOpenAccess W3110173253 @default.
- W3110173253 hasPrimaryLocation W31101732531 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W1975022222 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W1997020923 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W2029155846 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W2042210531 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W2070373142 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W2102890905 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W2243394318 @default.
- W3110173253 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.