FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3123147864> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W3123147864 endingPage "490" @default.
• W3123147864 startingPage "463" @default.
• W3123147864 abstract "This Article reviews several functional explanations that have been given to the dramatic spread of proportionality (early legal development, conflict management, lingua franca, and raw judicial power) and suggests an intrinsic new one. Proportionality, we believe, is essentially a requirement of justification, representing a profound shift in constitutional law on a global level, which we characterize, following South African scholar Etienne Mureinik, as a shift from a culture of authority to a culture of justification. At its core, a culture of justification requires that governments should provide substantive justification for all their actions, by which we mean justification in terms of the rationality and reasonableness of every action and the trade-offs that every action necessarily involves, i.e., in terms of proportionality. We identify several features of Western constitutional systems that have evolved after WWII, and that support the culture of justification. These include a broad conception of rights, a broad approach to constitutional interpretation with an emphasis on principles and values rather than on text, low barriers to substantive review, and no legal black holes (areas and actions with respect to which government needs to provide no justification). Most importantly in terms of our review, it involves a two-stage form of judicial review, identifying the infringement of the right, and justifying the infringement, with an emphasis on the second stage of justification. We also suggest two preliminary historical explanations for the rise of the culture of justification. One is its connection to the rise of the human rights ideology which developed after WWII, and which provided a response to the threats of nationalism and populism. The other is its roots in the optimistic belief in rationality and reason that can be traced to the nineteenth-century German legal science movement. We end our review by characterizing the gradual shift towards proportionality and the culture of justification as a shift towards an administrative model of constitutional law, which we term the administrization of constitutional law." @default.
• W3123147864 created "2021-02-01" @default.
• W3123147864 creator A5048121079 @default.
• W3123147864 creator A5054480909 @default.
• W3123147864 date "2011-04-01" @default.
• W3123147864 modified "2023-10-04" @default.
• W3123147864 title "Proportionality and the Culture of Justification" @default.
• W3123147864 cites W129279452 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W1512597729 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W1580510701 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W172211418 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W1798760885 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W18439555 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W1981428507 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2022337645 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2039981008 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2084079389 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2112443613 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2167665920 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2177819156 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2359603595 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2483444879 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2587720201 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2590725625 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2796139134 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W2796173346 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W3121297752 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W3121862366 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W4213439731 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W4214880717 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W4245780328 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W4245905980 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W4246981353 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W4247276202 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W4301911951 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W597497591 @default.
• W3123147864 cites W905591949 @default.
• W3123147864 doi "https://doi.org/10.5131/ajcl.2010.0018" @default.
• W3123147864 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
• W3123147864 type Work @default.
• W3123147864 sameAs 3123147864 @default.
• W3123147864 citedByCount "81" @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642012 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642013 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642014 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642015 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642016 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642017 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642018 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642019 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642020 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642021 @default.
• W3123147864 countsByYear W31231478642022 @default.
• W3123147864 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W3123147864 hasAuthorship W3123147864A5048121079 @default.
• W3123147864 hasAuthorship W3123147864A5054480909 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C158071213 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C183763965 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C18650270 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C190253527 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C201717286 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C2775946814 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C48764862 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C144024400 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C158071213 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C17744445 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C183763965 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C18650270 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C190253527 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C199539241 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C201717286 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C2775946814 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C48764862 @default.
• W3123147864 hasConceptScore W3123147864C94625758 @default.
• W3123147864 hasIssue "2" @default.
• W3123147864 hasLocation W31231478641 @default.
• W3123147864 hasOpenAccess W3123147864 @default.
• W3123147864 hasPrimaryLocation W31231478641 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W1600232538 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W2117160553 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W2122869744 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W3122278704 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W3123147864 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W3126096257 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W3189660175 @default.
• W3123147864 hasRelatedWork W1922063759 @default.
• W3123147864 hasVolume "59" @default.
• W3123147864 isParatext "false" @default.
• W3123147864 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W3123147864 magId "3123147864" @default.
• W3123147864 workType "article" @default.