FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3123881216> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W3123881216 endingPage "246" @default.
• W3123881216 startingPage "199" @default.
• W3123881216 abstract "The Southern District of New York’s local rules are clear: [A]ll active judges . . . shall be assigned substantially an equal share of the categories of of the court over a period of time. Yet for the past fourteen years, Southern District Judge Scheindlin has been granted near-exclusive jurisdiction over one category of case: those involving wide-sweeping constitutional challenges to the NYPD’s stop-and-frisk policies. In 1999, Judge Scheindlin was randomly assigned Daniels v. City of New York, the first in a series of high-profile and high-impact stop-and-frisk cases. Since then, she has overseen an uninterrupted stream of equally landmark stop-and-frisk cases, which culminated in an August 12, 2013 order granting a sweeping injunction against the NYPD. The were assigned according to the Southern District’s cases local rule, which allows judges to accept a new case related to an earlier-filed case already on their docket. Unlike past stop-and-frisk scholarship, this article addresses the procedural rules that have shaped the development of stop-and-frisk law, arguing that case assignment rules should not permit any district judge to exert total control over the evolution of significant Constitutional jurisprudence. The article begins by challenging the commonly-held assumption that federal are assigned to district judges at random. It explains that although random assignment is widely assumed and generally heralded, it is not enforceable. Instead, district courts retain discretion to assign as they wish, with little (if any) obligation for transparency. The article looks specifically to the Southern District of New York’s Local Rules, examining the numerous ways in which are assigned to specific judges according to the cases’ subject matter, through a system hidden from the public and devoid of oversight. The article then traces stop-and-frisk litigation from its roots in Terry v. Ohio to the complex and protracted stop-and-frisk filed in federal courts across the country today. It explains how police have utilized stop-and-frisk practices before and after Terry, focusing on the Giuliani-era theory of hot-spot policing. The article turns to the stop-and-frisk litigation before Judge Scheindlin, using it to examine the serious — and substantive — consequences of nonrandom case assignment in an adversary system. Nonrandom assignment allows an interested judge to inject herself into the litigation as a player with a stake in the outcome. Giving one district judge power over an entire category of Fourth Amendment jurisprudence elevates her decisions to a quasi-appellate level of significance, violating the principle that a district court opinion is not binding on any court within the same district. The article proposes amendments to the Southern District’s Local Rules to prohibit manipulation of case assignments, and advocates for the publication of assignment decisions as well as for motion practice challenging the assignments. Finally, it warns of the impact Judge Scheindlin’s control over this area of the law may have if appealed to the Supreme Court. Her decisions take a broad view of a plaintiff’s right to enforce the Fourth Amendment. Yet because her interpretation is so broad, her decisions may be reversed, and the rights at stake narrowed." @default.
• W3123881216 created "2021-02-01" @default.
• W3123881216 creator A5059004893 @default.
• W3123881216 date "2014-06-20" @default.
• W3123881216 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
• W3123881216 title "The Danger of Nonrandom Case Assignment: How the Southern District of New York's Related Cases Rule Shaped Stop-and-Frisk Rulings" @default.
• W3123881216 hasPublicationYear "2014" @default.
• W3123881216 type Work @default.
• W3123881216 sameAs 3123881216 @default.
• W3123881216 citedByCount "1" @default.
• W3123881216 countsByYear W31238812162016 @default.
• W3123881216 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W3123881216 hasAuthorship W3123881216A5059004893 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C10138342 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C182306322 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C2776213154 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C2776949292 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C2777632292 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C2778272461 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C2778447849 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C61547137 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C69775031 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConcept C71043370 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C10138342 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C144133560 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C17744445 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C182306322 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C199539241 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C2776213154 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C2776949292 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C2777632292 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C2778272461 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C2778447849 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C61547137 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C69775031 @default.
• W3123881216 hasConceptScore W3123881216C71043370 @default.
• W3123881216 hasIssue "2" @default.
• W3123881216 hasOpenAccess W3123881216 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W126253174 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W140041052 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W1541118117 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W1867948147 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W1980870390 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W2347078344 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W2892863779 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W3121721924 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W3121793022 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W3122685031 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W3122751706 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W3123053795 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W3123420893 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W83076801 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W840083088 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W843628474 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W853427604 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W862725663 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W273612257 @default.
• W3123881216 hasRelatedWork W3125293412 @default.
• W3123881216 hasVolume "19" @default.
• W3123881216 isParatext "false" @default.
• W3123881216 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W3123881216 magId "3123881216" @default.
• W3123881216 workType "article" @default.