Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3130122185> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3130122185 abstract "Abstract Background Chronic ankle instability (CAI) arises from the two etiological factors of functional (FAI) and mechanical ankle instability (MAI). To distinguish the contributions of the two etiologies, it is necessary to quantitively assess functional and mechanical deficits. Validated and reproducible assessment of mechanical instability remains a challenge in current research and practice. Physical examination, stress sonography and a novel 3D stress MRI have been used, while stress radiography has been called into question and arthrometry is limited to research purposes. The interaction of these primarily mechanical measurements with the functional and subjective components of CAI are subject to debate. The aim of this study was the evaluation of the clinical and biomechanical preferences of the three different methods in the diagnosis of MAI. Methods In this cross-sectional diagnostic study, we compared three different diagnostic approaches to mechanical ankle instability: (1) manual stress testing (anterior drawer test [ADT] and talar tilt test [TTT]), (2) stress sonography and (3) 3D stress MRI (3SAM) The latter includes quantification of 3D cartilage contact area (CCA) in plantarflexion-supination compared to neutral-null position. We applied these measurements to a cohort of patients suffering from chronic mechanical ankle instability ( n = 25) to a matched cohort of healthy controls ( n = 25). Perceived instability was assessed using the Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool (CAIT) and Forgotten Joint Score (FJS). Functional deficits were measured using postural sway and the y-Balance test. Results Significant differences between the two groups (single-factor “group” ANOVA, p < 0.05) were found in all of the mechanical assessments with strong effect sizes. Spearman’s correlations were strong for CAIT and manual stress testing (TTT rho = − 0.83, ADT rho = − 0.81), 3D stress MRI (rho = − 0.53) and stress sonography (TTT rho = − 0.48, ADT rho = − 0.44). Furthermore, the correlation between manual stress testing and CCA in the fibulotalar articulation (CCA FT ) was strong (rho = 0.54) and the correlations to stress sonography were moderate (ADT rho = 0.47 and TTT rho = 0.43). The calculation of cutoff values revealed a distance of > 5.4 mm increase in ligament length during stress sonography (sensitivity 0.92, specificity 0.6) and > 43% loss of articulating surface in the fibulotalar joint (CCA FT in supination-plantarflexion using 3SAM, sensitivity 0.71, specificity 0.8) as potential cutoff values for diagnosing MAI. Conclusions Manual stress testing showed to be a valuable method of identifying mechanical ankle instability. However, due to is subjective character it may overvalue patient-reported instability as a factor which explains the high correlation to the CAIT-score, but this may also reduce its value in diagnosing the isolated mechanical quality of the joint. Thus, there is a persisting need for objective and reproducible alternatives focusing on MAI. According to our results, 3D stress MRI and stress sonography represent valuable alternatives and may be used to quantitively assess mechanical ankle instability in research and practice. Trial registration German Registry of Clinical Trials # DRKS00016356 , registered on 05/11/2019." @default.
- W3130122185 created "2021-03-01" @default.
- W3130122185 creator A5002907717 @default.
- W3130122185 creator A5016640620 @default.
- W3130122185 creator A5019532909 @default.
- W3130122185 creator A5031052370 @default.
- W3130122185 creator A5036526404 @default.
- W3130122185 creator A5046367110 @default.
- W3130122185 creator A5070477373 @default.
- W3130122185 date "2021-02-17" @default.
- W3130122185 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W3130122185 title "Clinical evaluation of manual stress testing, stress ultrasound and 3D stress MRI in chronic mechanical ankle instability" @default.
- W3130122185 cites W1104996925 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W1133977102 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W1920519379 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W1959869021 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W1975923077 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W1980930732 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2011604319 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2016315674 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2017569397 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2024345060 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2027633966 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2053685257 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2054818110 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2057053184 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2066148089 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2081929184 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2108861982 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2109411677 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2114279807 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2134855752 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2140393199 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2146125914 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2149609371 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2160767462 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2162830756 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2170894168 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2181024862 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2291136475 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2338801821 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2417274707 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2486935324 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2571291872 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2608352816 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2612966558 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2615209730 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2754836612 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2933399300 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2942494444 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2949012120 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W2968882093 @default.
- W3130122185 cites W3005589553 @default.
- W3130122185 doi "https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-021-03998-z" @default.
- W3130122185 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/7890850" @default.
- W3130122185 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33596891" @default.
- W3130122185 hasPublicationYear "2021" @default.
- W3130122185 type Work @default.
- W3130122185 sameAs 3130122185 @default.
- W3130122185 citedByCount "16" @default.
- W3130122185 countsByYear W31301221852021 @default.
- W3130122185 countsByYear W31301221852022 @default.
- W3130122185 countsByYear W31301221852023 @default.
- W3130122185 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3130122185 hasAuthorship W3130122185A5002907717 @default.
- W3130122185 hasAuthorship W3130122185A5016640620 @default.
- W3130122185 hasAuthorship W3130122185A5019532909 @default.
- W3130122185 hasAuthorship W3130122185A5031052370 @default.
- W3130122185 hasAuthorship W3130122185A5036526404 @default.
- W3130122185 hasAuthorship W3130122185A5046367110 @default.
- W3130122185 hasAuthorship W3130122185A5070477373 @default.
- W3130122185 hasBestOaLocation W31301221851 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C105702510 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C126838900 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C137627325 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C141071460 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C142724271 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C170700871 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C1862650 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C2778640784 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C527108885 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConcept C99508421 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C105702510 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C126838900 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C137627325 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C141071460 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C142724271 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C170700871 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C1862650 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C2778640784 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C527108885 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C71924100 @default.
- W3130122185 hasConceptScore W3130122185C99508421 @default.
- W3130122185 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W3130122185 hasLocation W31301221851 @default.
- W3130122185 hasLocation W31301221852 @default.
- W3130122185 hasLocation W31301221853 @default.
- W3130122185 hasLocation W31301221854 @default.
- W3130122185 hasOpenAccess W3130122185 @default.