Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3137137337> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3137137337 endingPage "1075" @default.
- W3137137337 startingPage "1061" @default.
- W3137137337 abstract "Phylogenetic comparative methods (PCMs) are commonly used to study evolution and adaptation. However, frequently used PCMs for discrete traits mishandle single evolutionary transitions. They erroneously detect correlated evolution in these situations. For example, hair and mammary glands cannot be said to have evolved in a correlated fashion because each evolved only once in mammals, but a commonly used model (Pagel's Discrete) statistically supports correlated (dependent) evolution. Using simulations, we find that rate parameter estimation, which is central for model selection, is poor in these scenarios due to small effective (evolutionary) sample sizes of independent character state change. Pagel's Discrete model also tends to favor dependent evolution in these scenarios, in part, because it forces evolution through state combinations unobserved in the tip data. This model prohibits simultaneous dual transitions along branches. Models with underlying continuous data distributions (e.g., Threshold and GLMM) are less prone to favor correlated evolution but are still susceptible when evolutionary sample sizes are small. We provide three general recommendations for researchers who encounter these common situations: i) create study designs that evaluate a priori hypotheses and maximize evolutionary sample sizes; ii) assess the suitability of evolutionary models-for discrete traits, we introduce the phylogenetic imbalance ratio; and iii) evaluate evolutionary hypotheses with a consilience of evidence from disparate fields, like biogeography and developmental biology. Consilience plays a central role in hypothesis testing within the historical sciences where experiments are difficult or impossible to conduct, such as many hypotheses about correlated evolution. These recommendations are useful for investigations that employ any type of PCM. [Class imbalance; consilience; correlated evolution; evolutionary sample size; phylogenetic comparative methods.]." @default.
- W3137137337 created "2021-03-29" @default.
- W3137137337 creator A5031505281 @default.
- W3137137337 creator A5082202287 @default.
- W3137137337 date "2021-03-15" @default.
- W3137137337 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W3137137337 title "Evolutionary Sample Size and Consilience in Phylogenetic Comparative Analysis" @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1525734744 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1605984840 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1779341151 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1941659294 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1951225927 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1964153068 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1968371014 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1968759975 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1969264427 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1981705330 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W1989148204 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2003133488 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2013410948 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2013907950 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2015638160 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2024223694 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2025942236 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2030121195 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2030631285 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2035622691 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2038427571 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2040100260 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2040708857 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2042220296 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2047577234 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2047595933 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2052061474 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2061140759 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W207291124 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2075159929 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2086293112 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2094951587 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2095796640 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2098713714 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2101846955 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2102163163 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2105120559 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2110224102 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2113714330 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2114525641 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2117801354 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2124424299 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2131237643 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2134871125 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2135611147 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2139409085 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2142635246 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2144673831 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2148823819 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2149361198 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2150102946 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2151409320 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2154518589 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2160276669 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2163377164 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2164787828 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2168175751 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2498782314 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2588969809 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2801159594 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2944177810 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2950472597 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2951131905 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2951967147 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2970540026 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W2971644666 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W3002552645 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W3016352084 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W4231426548 @default.
- W3137137337 cites W4242565687 @default.
- W3137137337 doi "https://doi.org/10.1093/sysbio/syab017" @default.
- W3137137337 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33720380" @default.
- W3137137337 hasPublicationYear "2021" @default.
- W3137137337 type Work @default.
- W3137137337 sameAs 3137137337 @default.
- W3137137337 citedByCount "7" @default.
- W3137137337 countsByYear W31371373372022 @default.
- W3137137337 countsByYear W31371373372023 @default.
- W3137137337 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3137137337 hasAuthorship W3137137337A5031505281 @default.
- W3137137337 hasAuthorship W3137137337A5082202287 @default.
- W3137137337 hasBestOaLocation W31371373372 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C104317684 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C119857082 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C129848803 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C139807058 @default.
- W3137137337 hasConcept C169760540 @default.