Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3147332305> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3147332305 abstract "This paper proposes that 'why' in wh-in-situ languages (Korean, Japanese, and Chinese) is directly merged into [Spec,CP] of the clause it modifies. This proposal not only captures long-standing issues regarding the peculiarity of 'why', as opposed to other wh-phrases, but also accounts for previously unnoticed asymmetries among why-constructions. In particular, I argue that due to its initial merge position, 'why' in an interrogative clause is licensed with external merge while 'why' in a declarative clause must undergo LF-movement. This argument is supported by the non-uniform behavior of 'why' with respect to the Intervention Effiect in Korean and Japanese (cf. Beck and Kim 1997) and is further confirmed by the question-marker drop phenomenon in Japanese. Under this proposal, a puzzling divergence between Chinese and Korean/Japanese in wy-constructions is reduced to the fact that Chinese disallows A'-scrambling. The proposal also captures a syntactic parallelism between 'why' in wh-in-situ languages and 'why' in wh-fronting languages, like Italian and Irish. Among the theoretical consequences of this paper is a demonstration that a subject may scramble (cf. Saito 1985) and that string-vacuous scrambling is responsible for judgment variations concerning the Intervention Effect. * I thank Noam Chomsky, Sabine Iatridou, Shigeru Miyagawa, Norvin Richards, Ken Wexler, and very specially Danny Fox and David Pesetsky for their numerous helpful comments and extensive discussion on this paper. At various stages, this paper has also benefited from questions and comments from Joseph Aoun, Rajesh Bhatt, Cedric Boeckx, Sylvain Bromberger, Chris Collins, Paul Hagstrom, Irene Heim, James Huang, Anoop Mahajan, Luigi Rizzi, Wei-tien Dylan Tsai, John Whitman, Edwin Williams, and the audiences at the Ling-Lunch at MIT, Workshop on Wh-Movement at Utrecht/Leiden, the 77th LSA annual meeting, WAFL-1, and JKL-13. I am deeply grateful to Marcel den Dikken and two anonymous reviewers of NLLT for their detailed comments, which greatly improved the content and the presentation of the paper. I wish to thank my informants: for Korean data, Joon Yong Ahn, Yeun-Jin Jung, Youngok Ko, Youngoo Lee, Ju-Eun Lee; for Japanese data, Sachiko Kato, Masa Kuno, Nanako Machida, Hideki Maki, Shigeru Miyagawa, Shoichi Takahashi; for Chinese data, Ressy Ai, Feng-Fan Hsieh, Zhiqiang Li, Hooi Ling Soh. My gratitude also goes to Philip Monahan for his generous help in proofreading. Of course, all remaining errors in the paper are mine. This content downloaded from 157.55.39.118 on Mon, 06 Mar 2017 18:00:28 UTC All use subject to http://about.jstor.org/terms" @default.
- W3147332305 created "2021-04-13" @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5001435609 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5002217842 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5007245136 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5007288618 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5008643363 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5011725781 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5012960243 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5017895991 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5018252982 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5019319336 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5019763674 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5021135104 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5022922810 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5028752521 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5032445352 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5039560880 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5044579154 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5046206462 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5046275232 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5049435035 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5049816509 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5052543096 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5058160171 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5061699360 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5064142032 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5071558028 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5074461919 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5083351091 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5090552664 @default.
- W3147332305 creator A5090825328 @default.
- W3147332305 date "2016-01-01" @default.
- W3147332305 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W3147332305 title "SYNTAX OF WHY-IN-SITU: MERGE INTO [SPEC,CP] IN THE OVERT SYNTAX*" @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1003321824 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W140355684 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1490151999 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1498614766 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1506941071 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1546813535 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1551467849 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1555554653 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1557431989 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1560447924 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1599924086 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1964165491 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W1996672843 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2018824094 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2083136407 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2100920050 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2105019843 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2112393279 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2117677946 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2497192894 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W7231872 @default.
- W3147332305 cites W2483204348 @default.
- W3147332305 hasPublicationYear "2016" @default.
- W3147332305 type Work @default.
- W3147332305 sameAs 3147332305 @default.
- W3147332305 citedByCount "1" @default.
- W3147332305 countsByYear W31473323052015 @default.
- W3147332305 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5001435609 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5002217842 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5007245136 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5007288618 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5008643363 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5011725781 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5012960243 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5017895991 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5018252982 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5019319336 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5019763674 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5021135104 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5022922810 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5028752521 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5032445352 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5039560880 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5044579154 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5046206462 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5046275232 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5049435035 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5049816509 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5052543096 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5058160171 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5061699360 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5064142032 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5071558028 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5074461919 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5083351091 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5090552664 @default.
- W3147332305 hasAuthorship W3147332305A5090825328 @default.
- W3147332305 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W3147332305 hasConcept C197129107 @default.
- W3147332305 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W3147332305 hasConcept C2185349 @default.
- W3147332305 hasConcept C23123220 @default.
- W3147332305 hasConcept C2777453737 @default.
- W3147332305 hasConcept C2778565505 @default.