Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3175459009> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3175459009 abstract "John Rawls intends his doctrine of political liberalism to be free of metaphysical commitments. For this reason, Rawls’ conception of autonomy is not supposed to be dependent on the truth of any one metaphysical theory of human nature. Instead, Rawls states that people are rationally autonomous – able to develop their moral powers – and fully autonomous – able to act from a sense of justice – positing that we can accept these conceptions of autonomy whatever our other philosophical commitments.Though autonomy is not Rawls’ central concern, I argue that, nevertheless, full autonomy is integral to Rawls’ theory of justice. Without fully autonomous citizens, there is no one to realise justice as fairness. Through his way of thinking about human nature, Rawls assumes that people will be motivated to become fully autonomous. Through the possession of the moral powers, and the witnessing of the just workings of society’s institutions, a person will wish to act as a fully autonomous citizen should. I argue against making this assumption. Instead, I evaluate Rawls’ conception of the person against data in neuroscience and psychology, and thereby articulate two central concerns. First, a person’s moral psychology is largely dependent on her upbringing. If a person’s upbringing has not instilled in her a sense of the importance of fairness, there is little hope of her becoming fully autonomous in the way Rawls imagines. Second, in the neuroscience of free will, evidence suggests that we are much less in control of our thought processes than is traditionally imagined. If we are not in full control of our thought processes, there may be little we can do to prevent our being influenced by ideas that undermine justice as fairness.This is why I argue that, to realise political liberalism in the way Rawls formulates it, a system of moral education is necessary; a system that is much more demanding than that imagined by Rawls. It cannot be assumed that people are inherently predisposed to the value of justice as fairness, nor can it be imagined that the majority of people would reject alternative doctrines through their capacity to regulate their thoughts. A strong prior commitment to justice as fairness is therefore necessary. If political liberalism is to be realised in the way Rawls imagines, people must be educated in the importance of justice as fairness, with the aim of such a system of education being the development of fully autonomous citizens." @default.
- W3175459009 created "2021-07-05" @default.
- W3175459009 creator A5013081011 @default.
- W3175459009 date "2021-03-19" @default.
- W3175459009 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W3175459009 title "Autonomy in political liberalism" @default.
- W3175459009 cites W107842537 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W112201882 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W127261969 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1489965517 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1499784205 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1500610545 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1524967216 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1530656339 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1535803599 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1538050987 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1541077798 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1541703906 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1549135038 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1566861774 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1566893064 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1568513494 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1572512745 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1572553204 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W157443556 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1575299446 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1578413428 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1588542075 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W163472689 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1679875037 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W169219175 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1694605483 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1790202905 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1853490720 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W185512519 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1963748183 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1966340639 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1968969966 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1972410569 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1973168969 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1974162108 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1975376054 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1977024661 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1977502671 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1981364594 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1987459019 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1988648661 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1990080997 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1990625895 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1992600622 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1993649195 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W1993968723 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2000242809 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2001136156 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2002235070 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2002527625 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2002871221 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2008689560 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2010055482 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2010708142 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2013876224 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2016053589 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2019465132 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2025271685 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2026133433 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2026269721 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2027328564 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2031713215 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2035079822 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2035437214 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2041607960 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2044534070 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2044985950 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2047892647 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2048547761 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2051996996 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2056397859 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2059176358 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2061146094 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2062069304 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2062131993 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2062491445 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2070032978 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2073380718 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2073538608 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2074258649 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2077659983 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2077669689 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2081703383 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2084523847 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2092283429 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2107521677 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2109952008 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2112387992 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2112593361 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2112869782 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2114043250 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2114422902 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2125823313 @default.
- W3175459009 cites W2128567037 @default.