Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3176238785> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3176238785 endingPage "635" @default.
- W3176238785 startingPage "608" @default.
- W3176238785 abstract "In many legal systems, preliminary proceedings and the prosecutor’s charging decision predict the outcome of the trial, as reflected in high conviction rates. This charging decision is mostly based on the final police report, which is primarily aimed to substantiate the given suspicion and may lead to a preponderance of incriminating evidence. We investigated if a written statement by the defense (an alternative story) can balance out this information disparity and can alter the charging decision. Building on classical debiasing methods, the Story Model and narrative persuasion, we hypothesized that an alternative story reduces the likelihood of being charged, because the police report becomes less unique. Participants of three experiments (criminal-law students, N = 684) received either only the police report, or the police report plus an alternative story (vs. a statement merely claiming innocence) and were asked to make charging decisions. The presence of prior conviction evidence (PCE) was varied. Results show that 1) an alternative story reduces (and PCE increases) the likelihood of being charged, 2) a statement merely claiming innocence is less but still effective, and 3) PCE effects were small and inconsistent. Underlying mechanisms, implications for criminal procedural law, and applicability to adversarial systems are discussed." @default.
- W3176238785 created "2021-07-05" @default.
- W3176238785 creator A5048712352 @default.
- W3176238785 creator A5061756641 @default.
- W3176238785 creator A5065498966 @default.
- W3176238785 creator A5089236089 @default.
- W3176238785 date "2021-06-19" @default.
- W3176238785 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W3176238785 title "Alternative stories and the decision to prosecute: an applied approach against confirmation bias in criminal prosecution" @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1592839149 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1963721875 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1964667662 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1964898772 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1970743895 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1975265777 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1975791152 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1979446207 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1979916110 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1984737313 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W1996018314 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2000742832 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2011749266 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2018415576 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2019877736 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2035370986 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2038901583 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2041447799 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2050689620 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2053486949 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2057279252 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2068516786 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2075078671 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2079791600 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2080256953 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2087484885 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2088297507 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2095688955 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2106337187 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2114792912 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2128639258 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2129872418 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2132829442 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2151722097 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2158416048 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2159569734 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2163275922 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2334802313 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2502636606 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2795610411 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2795879112 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2818161558 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W2890352379 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W3017228661 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W3042469171 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W3121814263 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W3122150393 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W3123476072 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W3123915779 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W3124599781 @default.
- W3176238785 cites W4235809384 @default.
- W3176238785 doi "https://doi.org/10.1080/1068316x.2021.1941013" @default.
- W3176238785 hasPublicationYear "2021" @default.
- W3176238785 type Work @default.
- W3176238785 sameAs 3176238785 @default.
- W3176238785 citedByCount "5" @default.
- W3176238785 countsByYear W31762387852022 @default.
- W3176238785 countsByYear W31762387852023 @default.
- W3176238785 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3176238785 hasAuthorship W3176238785A5048712352 @default.
- W3176238785 hasAuthorship W3176238785A5061756641 @default.
- W3176238785 hasAuthorship W3176238785A5065498966 @default.
- W3176238785 hasAuthorship W3176238785A5089236089 @default.
- W3176238785 hasBestOaLocation W31762387851 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C144237770 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C148220186 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C199033989 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C2776283789 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C2777026412 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C2777278149 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C2777359062 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C2778252816 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C2779458634 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C2781310500 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C37736160 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C504945742 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C73484699 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConceptScore W3176238785C138885662 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConceptScore W3176238785C144237770 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConceptScore W3176238785C148220186 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConceptScore W3176238785C15744967 @default.
- W3176238785 hasConceptScore W3176238785C17744445 @default.