Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W3205692009> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W3205692009 endingPage "1130" @default.
- W3205692009 startingPage "1108" @default.
- W3205692009 abstract "Abstract According to classical theism, the universe depends on God in a way that goes beyond mere (efficient) causation. I have previously argued that this ‘deep dependence’ of the universe on God is best understood as a type of grounding. In a recent paper in this journal, Aaron Segal argues that this doctrine of deep dependence causes problems for creaturely free will: if our choices are grounded in facts about God, and we have no control over these facts, then we do not control our choices and are therefore not free. This amounts to a grounding analogue of the Consequence Argument for the incompatibility of free will and determinism. If successful, it would have application beyond classical theism: similar concerns would apply to any view that takes our choices to be grounded in a deeper reality which is beyond our control. However, I show that the argument is not successful. Segal’s Grounding Consequence Argument is so closely analogous to the Causal Consequence Argument that any response to the one provides a response to the other. As a result, if you don’t think that prior causes (whether deterministic or indeterministic) undermine free will, you shouldn’t think that prior grounds undermine free will." @default.
- W3205692009 created "2021-10-25" @default.
- W3205692009 creator A5058909328 @default.
- W3205692009 date "2021-10-15" @default.
- W3205692009 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W3205692009 title "Foundational Grounding and Creaturely Freedom" @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1152817606 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1517920372 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1520467851 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1541703906 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W185512519 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1967015803 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1968488273 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1971337246 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1973443353 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1998940988 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2012111239 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2018047081 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2025342735 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2041907644 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2058071576 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2061470644 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2076110444 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2092460842 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2097080168 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2123137115 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2146402260 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2162596449 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2169527305 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2169605018 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2314330590 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2326355927 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2466830020 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2502739406 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2572702818 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2600504333 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2792279599 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2792896795 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2793548097 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2808165491 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W2955020617 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W3012979925 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W3023856917 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W3033134244 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W3188551251 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W34790780 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W4231969216 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W4234991495 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W4239599965 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W4240161594 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W4247314130 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W625960733 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1963827896 @default.
- W3205692009 cites W1983520345 @default.
- W3205692009 doi "https://doi.org/10.1093/mind/fzab024" @default.
- W3205692009 hasPublicationYear "2021" @default.
- W3205692009 type Work @default.
- W3205692009 sameAs 3205692009 @default.
- W3205692009 citedByCount "1" @default.
- W3205692009 countsByYear W32056920092022 @default.
- W3205692009 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W3205692009 hasAuthorship W3205692009A5058909328 @default.
- W3205692009 hasBestOaLocation W32056920091 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C10038465 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C126693752 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C166151441 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C192183473 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C200610012 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C26921437 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C2775924081 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C2776211767 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C521304379 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C80038905 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConcept C98184364 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C10038465 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C111472728 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C126693752 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C138885662 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C154945302 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C166151441 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C185592680 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C192183473 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C200610012 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C26921437 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C27206212 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C2775924081 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C2776211767 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C41008148 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C521304379 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C55493867 @default.
- W3205692009 hasConceptScore W3205692009C80038905 @default.